[ home ] [ meta / arch ] [ pony / pic / merch / oat ] [ art / fic / collab ] [ rp / ooc ] [ g / vinyl ] [ gala / int ] [ anon ]

/pony/ - Show Discussion

The place to discuss the show and its universe, while gushing over the brilliance of Team Faust.
Name
Email
Subject
Comment
File
Flags
Password (For file deletion.)

This is a test site! Posts made here will be lost.

Apr 1: Come join us for a MLP marathon.
Mar 31: With the Merger coming up soon, we have created an official steam group for the combined sites. It can be found at http://steamcommunity.com/groups/PonychanSteam

File: 141282365235.png (582.32 KB, 1280x720, Celestia_points_to_Twilight�…)

Official Weekly Re-Visit Thread S1 E23 Nickel Storm 36780950

Okay folks up next we have Season 1 Episode 23, The Cutie Mark Chronicles, Written by: M.A.Larson.

The link to the episode: http://www.dailymotion.com/video/xwp34u_mlp-fim-s1-e23-the-cutie-mark-chronicles-hd-no-watermarks_shortfilms

Watch this episode again, comment as you do. What did you like/dislike, anything you missed before? Or just general discussion about every little aspect of this episode.

LETS WATCH THIS CLASSIC AGAIN AND HAVE FUN!!]

!!Rarity ## Mod 36780952

File: 141282409760.png (89.19 KB, 300x300, 131800234662.png)

Sticky

36780960

File: 141286996079.png (629.57 KB, 853x480, Did that just happen.png)

>>36780950

This was shaping up to be a great episode, until it made Scootaloo look like the dead weight crippled pony she is well know for, constantly bringing down the efforts of the CMC in finding their Cutie Marks.

It also made Dash the original Mary Sue of FiM, back in the day this was one of the most "fun" episodes to discusss, for the reasons I mentioned above.

Mondo!peSTIcIDes 36780961

File: 141287442917.png (24.71 KB, 665x868, 327712__safe_oc_artist-colon-t…)

>>36780960
>This was shaping up to be a great episode, until it made Scootaloo look like the dead weight crippled pony she is well know for, constantly bringing down the efforts of the CMC in finding their Cutie Marks.

Is that what it looked like to you? I really liked Scootaloo in this episode. In fact, she was probably my favorite at the time as a result. The way she handled things seemed so rational compared to the other two.

NostalgiaSchmaltz!jdKt6Dif02 36780964

File: 141287921942.png (511.01 KB, 654x868, sunil93.png)

Egh. Still one of my least favorite S1 episodes, down there with Call of the Cutie and Stare Master.

While it was nice to get some "backstory" on the main6, the rest of the episode was handled rather badly. It was shaping up to be an interesting CMC episode, but then the CMC quickly took a backseat to stories about the main6, and almost nothing actually happened in the present time except for a hamfisted moral forced onto the end.

36780966

File: 141288619745.png (940.36 KB, 1280x720, Being stare'd.png)

>>36780961

If I didn't thought that then I wouldn't have worded it out that way, I never liked Dash back in S1 and well into S2, Scootaloo wanting to be just like her made her worst CMC inmediatly to me.

Toothless 36780969

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mXxP_-XaKrk
This song made this whole episode all worth it.

Nother Nonymous (Element of Threadkilling) 36780979

File: 141290529431.jpg (67.74 KB, 304x308, Mr_Horse_Yessir_I_like_it.jpg)

>>36780950
Wonderful episode. The Pie family on the Amish rock farm. Fluttershy finding her first friends. Twilight's exam. Twilight sputtering and exploding. Twilight's parents and their brief potted-plant experience. Applejack and the high life in Manehattan. Rarity talking to her horn. "And that's how Equestria was made!" and the never-to-be-repeated look on Scootaloo's face. The revelation of the underlying link between the Mane Six. All these backstories in 22 minutes, followed by hugs all around. Yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes!

Last edited at Thu, Oct 9th, 2014 18:42

Anonymous 36781037

File: 141301693769.jpg (125.38 KB, 610x610, image.jpg)

Anonymous 36781064

>>36780979
What face would that be?

The Scyphozoa!SCIPIOB65. 36781065

File: 141307748162.png (395.53 KB, 633x753, wat.png)

>>36781064
This one, I think?

Nother Nonymous (Element of Threadkilling) 36781069

File: 141308207022.png (200 KB, 634x573, Scootaloo_wtf.png)

>>36781065
This one.

Cheerilee1980 36781077

File: 141314435755.png (421.93 KB, 1280x720, Filly_Fluttershy_embarrassed_S…)

I hope S5 will have more filly flashbacks.

Anonymous 36781079

>>36781077
I hope there's a legit age-regression/progression episode in season 5. Someone stuck as an infant or elder due to magical mishap!

36781080

File: 141316454798.png (417.96 KB, 1280x720, Teach me your secrets.png)

>>36781079

Magical mishap you say?
Twi fixes everything in the end?
That sounds like Fluttershutter bait.

Anonymous 36781081

>>36781080
I'd rather it be Deus Ex Celestia and not a Twifix.
As in, I would hope that whatever magical mishap happens it also affects Twilight's magic. Or Twi's away on some royal business or whatever.

Last edited at Sun, Oct 12th, 2014 18:50

Unlikeable Pony (element of being banned. again) 36781094

File: 141325508443.gif (238.07 KB, 281x274, derp.gif)

BEST. EPISODE. EVER.


no, seriously, I love this episode. This is one of THE episodes that made me a brony.
I loved the mane six's backstories in this, and every single one felt powerful.


AJ figuring out what she wanted to be in life was great due to how it Lined up with her element of honesty: She tried to live a lie of who she was and was ashamed of her rural background: In the end she realized that's who she WAS and that she would never be happy living a lie, and returned back home.

Pinkie pie's cutie mark was gained spreading laughter and cheer to her family, lining up with both her Element and what she loves to do in life.

Rainbow dash discovered her passion in life while being loyal to her friend and defending fluttershy

Ect.




All in all, THIS is why I loved Larson. Goddamn, was this a good episode.

Now, i don't mean to sound like a Whiny douche, but it was also nice to see things play out without everything pointing to Twilight as the most special pony ever: its nice having things spread around to the others in the Group dynamic (And I don't say this as a Dash fan, I would love to see more Big significance handed to Rarrar, Flutters, AJ or pinkie as well).

I kind of get the impression that if it was redone nowadays it would be ordered that Twilight's giant magic nova that Showed everyone their destinies instead.

Toothless 36781104

File: 141326088044.png (94.58 KB, 313x305, Back in the bag.png)

>>36781094
>Rainbow dash discovered her passion in life while being loyal to her friend and defending fluttershy
Don't forget the part where Dash nearly killed the pony she was protecting.

Last edited at Mon, Oct 13th, 2014 21:28

Mondo!peSTIcIDes 36781105

File: 141326126313.png (36.69 KB, 412x382, I have no idea.png)

>>36781094

I think some of those definitions are a it of a stretch. You left out Rarity, for one, whose talent was some combination of costume design and gem finding. You could try to twist that to say she was generously offering these gems she magically found for use in the play, but she pretty directly benefited, and it wasn't really shown to be generous in the script at all.

And I don't think Rainbow Dash's loyalty was actually in question during that race, either. She was totally sticking up for her friend, but her talents and passion were for racing, not loyalty, and she again had ulterior motives for the race aside from just defending Fluttershy's honor (which is kind of a silly reason to race anyway).

Applejack's is even worse. She wasn't lying or being dishonest at any point, she just wasn't sure what she wanted out of life. She thought living in the city looked good, she tried it, it wasn't good, she came home.

Fluttershy and Pinkie Pie fit that, at least. And Twilight technically did, but hers is a lot easier to pull that off with.

The Scyphozoa!SCIPIOB65. 36781108

>>36781104
I think pegasi of that age are generally assumed not to be at risk of falling to their deaths? I mean, they live on a cloud, and I don't remember seeing any safety railing. If Fluttershy could get out to that place where the only things to stand on are tiny scattered clouds, everyone probably expected that, while she can't fly well, she'd at least generate enough lift to avoid dying.

It would be like accidentally knocking over a toddler, to find that he INSTADIED when he broke his neck on the kitchen floor.

36781114

File: 141330431770.png (643.27 KB, 1280x720, Grit those teeth.png)

>>36781081

With all due respect, I don't feel like throwing Twi into a bus is something I would enjoy seeing.

>>36781104

Of course she got away with that, back in the day Dash was such a Mary Sue.

Anonymous 36781115

>>36781114
They've done it to Spike. I don't see why Twi couldn't be away on official business.

PiercingSight !zEniXTGVeQ 36781357

File: 141350855755.png (384.86 KB, 667x634, DJ-+-;P.png)

This was seriously one of the episodes I enjoyed the most because it gave so much life and vibrance to the rest of the canon. It's not just that the episode in and of itself was good, but that there was a sense of discovery in learning about all the different places and cultures of Equestria while at the same time learning how the mane cast came to be who they are, how cutie marks are received, how Twilight became the Princess' pupil, where Spike came from, etc. etc.

We learn a ton because we are dragged (in Rarity's case, literally) from one location to the next, from one culture to the next, from one personality, one life-changing-story, one background discovery to the next.

It's because of this episode that the fanfics have thrived the way they have, that the episodes still have the potential to explore, surprise, and still maintain a level of canonical consistency.

The same goes with any episode where we learn about the past, or about other areas in Equestria, be it Discord, NMM, Tirek, Fillydelphia, Appeloosa, etc.

So while some have issues with the flow of the story, the perhaps "Mary Sue" "Magical Fate brought us together" reveal, I think it's this episode which gave the world a lot more detail and vibrance than would have been possible in any other single episode.


Delete Post [ ]
Edit Post
[ home ] [ meta / arch ] [ pony / pic / merch / oat ] [ art / fic / collab ] [ rp / ooc ] [ g / vinyl ] [ gala / int ] [ anon ]