Moonstuck

> Now the tea party is over. We must continue forth through the maze and find that filly!

Right! But you have no idea where she went, and this is a tricky maze to navigate.

Why, you would never have found the bat pony if he hadn’t left those convenient arrows for you to follow!

> That filly needs to be taught a lesson. Devise a cool and unusual punishment!

You proceed to hold an elegant tea party and “forget” to invite her.

Take that, ruffian!

> Maybe the filly that crushed the flowers and the filly that the moonitaur saw was the same filly !

The recovering bat pony takes this opportunity to interject that he too saw this mysterious filly—in fact, it was she who had led him astray during the mad rush through the maze.
Hmm. First the moonflowers, then the Minitaur…this strange mare seems determined to commit terrible crimes and use her startling resemblance to you to set you up.
But to what end?

> It seems that Moonitaur is understanding, and says that was suspicious because of some mysterious pony confrontation.

The Moonitaur has her own, suspiciously-similar story! It seems that she and her baby were walking along, minding their own bovine business, when suddenly she fell down a deep, jam-covered hole that had never been in her labyrinth before!

When she finally managed to escape, her baby was gone, and her only clues were a scent of evil jam and a mysterious filly-like figure.

> Respectfully explain situation. :x in an adorable way.

You tell the Moonitaur the entire story, all about the crash-landing and the eyepatch and the falling into a hole covered in jam and the death and subsequent resurrection of the Cartographer’s Cap and the Minitaur that wouldn’t leave you alone and and and…