Blotter updated: 06/17/12Show/Hide Show All

Image

Tag History
(edit info)
Rating

Prev | Index | Next

Comments

HeinousActsZX
#571893
9 months ago
Octavia? Meh. Don't like, but won't hate.
AdrianBrony
#571911
9 months ago
I still like the concept of octavia being pinkie's sister.
Anonymous
#571923
9 months ago
Oh look it's that retarded "Octavia is Pinkie's sister" headcanon again.
HeinousActsZX
#571932
9 months ago
Bad anon! Bad! What did I say about hating? Go to your room, mister/missy!
Anonymous
#571955
9 months ago
It's a cool idea, because they she does look a lot like Inky Pie, but it makes no sense in the context of the show.
Rainbow_Dude
#571964
9 months ago
@HeinousActsZX THAT'S the Spirit of a Brony ;D
Btw, don't like too
FanOfMostEverything
#571981
9 months ago
Sauce would be appreciated. That or an artist explanation of Blinky's story and the origin of the foal.
GreyAcumane
#571996
9 months ago
It makes perfect sense in the context of the show. Inky Pie was the one rocking out at Pinkie's party, so there's no reason to think she wouldn't be musically inclined.
Plus with Pinkie's full name being "Pinkamena Diane Pie" it would be easy to extrapolate similar names for her sisters, such as "Incantessa Octavia Pie" and hence Octavia uses her middle name for stage.
As far as how she gave no real acknowledgement to Pinkie at the Gala; obviously she's a professional, and she can wait until after the party to gab with her sister, and in the meantime she at least threw her sister a bone of laying down the soundtrack for her sister's usual zany antics.

On top of that, you basically have a perfect trio in relation to Granny Pie's song "giggle at the ghosties" where Pinkie took the laughter as the most important aspect and threw parties and works at a bakery now, Inky took the song as the most important aspect and took up music and became the performer Octavia, and Blinky took the bravery aspect as the most important part and has or will be inheriting the rock farm to keep it running and protecting it from whatever dangers may crop up (it does seem to be at least somewhat near to the everfree forest)

To all the detractors; sorry, but Octavia Pie makes perfect sense and fits wonderfully into canon.
Anonymous
#572035
9 months ago
I'm sorry but, that is possibly the most contrived explanation I've possibly heard ever. It's not your fault I'm surprised you put so much thought into it, but as a firm believer in Occam's Razor I just cannot except this as canon.
AdrianBrony
#572049
9 months ago
I'm seconding anon. never confuse headcanon with canon. the results are awkward.
PonyPuffy
#572076
9 months ago
I do like the idea of Octavia being Pinkie's sister, but until we see any evidence on the show pro or con it's just a fan theory...a fun one but just a theory and fancanon
Anonymous
#572149
9 months ago
Looks like a shitstorm is coming.
*Opens up umbrella*
Anonymous
#572194
9 months ago
It's a new comedy show about Octavia having to live with the Pies after an unforturnate accident destroyed her home...
*gets paper* wait what? She's staying with one of her bandmates instead? So she's not going to get involved in a crazy comedy show?... Oh okay. Well, so much for that.
DeeperMadness
#573102
9 months ago
I can't see Octavia being a member of the Pie family. It's just such a daft idea to me.

Besides, that would mean one fewer pony to love.
Anonymous
#573317
9 months ago
dm raises a valid point
Anonymous
#573363
9 months ago
Whatever happened to just enjoying the cuteness of a drawing regardless of the thought behind it?
Elysiaa
#574446
9 months ago
I support the Octavia is Pinkie's sister theory
But that's just my opinion
G33K1001
#576435
9 months ago
Opinions people everyone has them
lets focus on the drawing, in my opinion the sketch looks nice i cant imagene how long that took... home to see it colored, and the poses are, elegant and well made
My review for this sketch 10
Necroceine
#577947
9 months ago
By the way as no one seems to have said, the foal is Peachy Pie from the talent show in The Show Stoppers. Unless you meant how she's related. Probably a distant cousin or something. Anything closer would be very awkward to explain, as Pinkie didn't seem to show up for Peachy.