
| Anonymous #553100 9 months ago |
Good question ... |
| Tacoworld501 #553101 9 months ago |
Cuz
Internet |
| Blubhead #553103 9 months ago |
I dunno ... I dunno any more |
| Anonymous #553104 9 months ago |
because OC should not invade our precious artwork, it's a fanfic, let it stay a fanfic |
| Anonymous #553113 9 months ago |
And fanfic cant have artwork ?
Stupid point imo, cause all "artwork" art FANart, fan make them, so it's logic that fan add fan made pony on there fan made artwork. |
| Frisby #553115 9 months ago |
Because it's the "thing" to do right now, and a lot of people jumped on the bandwagon. |
| Anonymous #553116 9 months ago |
Where to start? Mary Sueness, wangst, flat characterization, annoying fans? |
| WhiteLycan #553117 9 months ago |
/)_- It begins...
*pours the whiskey* |
| primedawg9170 #553118 9 months ago |
It's the internet, mate. That's all you need to know. |
| Yorec #553119 9 months ago |
I thought nyxrage ended when season 2 started. Why are people still on this? |
| Anonymous #553125 9 months ago |
@Anon116
Agree on the Mary Sueness and wangst. Annoying; fans every Fandom has it (seriously, making Twilight sparkle going against Celestia? I don't want to insult your intelligence people, but don't be blind to the obvious things) |
| Anonymous #553126 9 months ago |
I think Frisby is right...
In fact Bronies are in majority a big band of followers. Love pony cause it's the cool thing of the moment. And if hate Nyx is the cool thing to do, here they go. Lame, think by yourself, read the stories of nyx (thing I still dont have done, but I will) and THEN hate it or not. |
| zeyro #553127 9 months ago |
Because people like to hate a character and rag on them even when the author attempts to fix the mistakes they made.
That being said, it's not like they're completely wrong, just that they could be nicer about it. |
| Skylight #553130 9 months ago |
I haven't read the fic that Nyx pops up in (Shit, I don't even know the name). Frankly, I just couldn't give less of a shit about Nyx. |
| ChickNeighney #553135 9 months ago |
I just couldn't be bothered to read it. I guess I'll listen to it when that Azekahh guy on Youtube get's around to reading it. I'm just too lazy to do it myself. |
| Hakar #553137 9 months ago |
Because we're trying to become more like the furry fandom. |
| Anonymous #553142 9 months ago |
Because the minority of her fans have caused her to be severely overrated. And in a community where the background characters are overrated, that's probably not a good thing. |
| Anonymous #553146 9 months ago |
I give up. Why? |
| cyx7 #553147 9 months ago |
I have an OC and his name is Dyx.
He lives in Corduroy-ville, down button lane... |
| Anonymous #553149 9 months ago |
Nyx is just a cheap appeal to cuteness from what I can tell. |
| Cotton_Meadow #553155 9 months ago |
Nyx is hated out of the same reason the fanfic; "Cupcakes" is loved. |
| thatguy #553156 9 months ago |
I don't like her for the same reason I don't like Cupcakes
I haven't read either story and have no interest to, but the fans are zealous in shoving it in people's faces, often just to piss people off. |
| Saufsoldat #553158 9 months ago |
Because she's a poorly-conceived Mary Sue OC with a fanbase desperately claiming the opposite. |
| MisterSeven #553159 9 months ago |
#553137
![]() |
| kassarc16 #553160 9 months ago |
"Because the minority of her fans have caused her to be severely overrated."
Some would say that about FiM and us. |
| zeyro #553164 9 months ago |
So from what I'm reading, people hate Nyx because the fans of it are spreading it everywhere even when it's unwanted?
So those spreading My Little Pony everywhere when it's unwanted means that My Little Pony should be hated as well? If I'm not mistaken, doing just that is exactly how we got our own image board and the beginning of our fandom. |
| thatguy #553170 9 months ago |
#553164
Spreading the show and spreading a fan work isn't the same thing. |
| Brollyhero93 #553181 9 months ago |
Because she is not REAL..... |
| PowerWordStun #553182 9 months ago |
Because it's cool to hate OCs. |
| Anonymous #553187 9 months ago |
I don't see much hate in these comments, is nyx even that hated anymore? |
| Eriko #553190 9 months ago |
Brolly , ponies aren't real .. yet you love them.
Everything has annoying fans.. looking at a few now. |
| santan #553195 9 months ago |
i dont hate nyx. because shes all cute and stuff... but everything is cute to me so everything is cute... CUTE!!!!
ugh i need to tell the fire maggots that are made of fireballs to continue the pants war. |
| hernycwo #553196 9 months ago |
Because people keep posting shit like this about it. |
| Bongo #553202 9 months ago |
http://ponibooru.413chan.net/post/view/68266
|
| HeinousActsZX #553206 9 months ago |
Honestly? Compared to Griffy at this point, she isn't. |
| Anonymous #553221 9 months ago |
Because all fanfic, except for trolls like "Cupcakes", is shit?
What is creepier is that there are adults actually spending time to write these. |
| Anonymous #553238 9 months ago |
because OC alicorns suck. Unless your name is Lauren Faust, any alicorn character you make is fail... |
| Impulse #553249 9 months ago |
Come on people, It's an OC. OC's suck. End of story. |
| Anonymous #553254 9 months ago |
Griffy has set a new low and is absorbing the Nyx hate |
| Anonymous #553260 9 months ago |
Nyx was never a Mary Sue for me, and even if she was she was a working one.
I love the idea of a Fallout Equestria Wiki and don't see the point in people thinking it's stupid. Just don't visit it then, why do you care ? Griffy is a real mary sue ... |
| PowerWordStun #553265 9 months ago |
What Bongo said Kkat said. :/ |
| Kein #553435 9 months ago |
Please, consult:
>>43113 |
| ILSS #553531 9 months ago |
Because anonymous users argue with themselves about it. |
| Some_Anon #553561 9 months ago |
![]() |
| PonyRIG #553574 9 months ago |
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RFZrzg62Zj0 |
| DashApples #554005 9 months ago |
I will not read your comments here, but the logical explanation is here. She's been hated in the story by individual ponies.
Also, as far as I know Nyx is only hated on ponibooru. You guys suck. really. |
| d715 #554068 9 months ago |
A lot of reason, mainly the story is overhyped and seen as perfect, while it has MAJOR flaws (like how only unicorns can used the Element of Magic, dispite the show making it painfully clear that "Magic" means friendship)
For Nyx I can see the main reason is because, dispite the story suppose to be about how she deals with being see as a monster for being Nightmare Moon, no one and I mean no one has a problem with her and she doesn't even have any traits Nightmare Moon has, she's more or less just a perfect little angel. What she should have been was a mini Nightmare Moon who learns to be good while dealing with the stigma of being veiwed as a little hellspawn |
| Anonymous #554081 9 months ago |
from what I can tell it's a combination of things
1) apparently the writing in the original release of Past Sins was kind of shoddy in general, although I'm told that's been worked over in later revisions 2) Nyx raises a couple of the traditional "bad OC" red flags: overaccessorization, setting-bending (an alicorn, although admittedly this was required for the conceit of the story), and warping of preestablished characters (I see a lot of complaints about Twilight and Celestia both being written OOC for the sake of ensuring that they will react to Nyx in the desired way - one of the most fundamental traits of your traditional "Mary Sue" character) 3) her behavior in the second half of the story apparently comes across as the bad kind of angst - the kind that makes a character unlikeable (this is mostly from context clues, I only read like the first five chapters of the original Past Sins and don't remember them very well) |
| Anonymous #554086 9 months ago |
http://i.imgur.com/a2D8c.jpg
Go engorge yourselves now, You hear!? |
| Anonymous #554162 9 months ago |
@#554081
Number 3 is the one of the few reasons I have any dislike for her. I just don't mind her really and she's hardly posted around everywhere nowadays. |
| DashApples #554431 9 months ago |
Seriously, read the story whole before hating and assuming things. |
| Anonymous #554691 9 months ago |
Past Sins isn't the only fic with Nyx, y'know.
She was in Creeping Darkness first |
| Hex-Master #554752 9 months ago |
Because her existence makes all the characters I love into horrible parodies of themselves.
I don't give a fuck how cute that little brat is, she's gotta go when she messes with Celestia and Luna. |
| Vicron #558927 9 months ago |
When I read fanfiction I place it, in my head in an alternate universe so any characterization glitches don't bother me. Although I didn't really have to do that for past sins, sometimes ooc behavior enhances the story. Sometimes it says that the character has been influenced on a deep level by the oc which I think is cool. |
| Anonymous #560124 9 months ago |
I have come to the decision that arguing about an overhyped OC and their fanfic is incredibly stupid, and the sooner we stop bitching and praising it, the sooner it will fall into obscurity. |
| WatermelonRat #573190 9 months ago |
It should be noted that a lot of the "annoying fans" touted as an excuse to hate Nyx and Past Sins are intentionally trying to stir up trouble. For example, ^^^Hex-Master, a very prominent Nyx-hater, suggested in the comments of another pic that someone go to ponychan and act like a fan claiming Nyx was canon. |
| Anonymous #573196 9 months ago |
Because hating on OC's makes you KEWL! |
| Anonymous #574329 9 months ago |
Because she's the cancer killing the pony fandom. |
| Anonymous #576116 9 months ago |
Because...
"puts on sunglasses" Many idiots like to hate any OC XD This is strange that many people hate exactly Nyx |
| Anonymous #613872 9 months ago |
'cuz ez funeee |
| Anonymous #622511 8 months ago |
I didn't know Nyx until now I found out it was all just about an overhyped fanfic with overhyped fans claiming that this marie-sue character could be canon.
So now I read the fics, I think there's nothing special about them, and Nyx is actually a pretty badly written character. (and designed horribly, in my opinion) So all I ask is: Why did this get popular and why do people CARE? |
| Anonymous #829042 6 months ago |
Wow, Kkat officially rocks now, even if I do hate Fallout: Equestria to no end. |
| Anonymous #1038042 4 months ago |
Fuck Nyx |