
| PonyRIG #477034 10 months ago |
inb4 massive disscussion |
| Anonymous #477035 10 months ago |
This little bitch here stole a TON of animations meant to be included on the next Desktop Ponies update, passing them as her own AND stealing other people's fangames as well.
DA's staff isn't doing jack, so if you guys could drop by to give her a piece of your mind and to report her stolen content, DA's staff will be forced to intervene. (Thanks a lot in advance, people) |
| BILL_POOTIS #477039 10 months ago |
Wait, didn't someone already try to steal these sprites and say they were their own?
If I remember, their comment section was filled to the brim calling her out on it. |
| Sevireth #477041 10 months ago |
well no, no one lost anything so its not theft
she doesnt cite the original artists but other than that and offensively bad english i dont see any problems big enough to require a call for the personal army |
| Flammie #477042 10 months ago |
Wow do people even have a life by stealing? |
| Anonymous #477043 10 months ago |
http://desktopponies.co.cc/1_8_Art-Credits.html
Yup, all of that was stolen by her. |
| Shintaha #477051 10 months ago |
Also, theif. I'm a dickhead |
| Kiana #477054 10 months ago |
Sevireth, by NOT citing the original artists, she is implying that SHE created them. DA being a cite for artists and all. And how DA will automatically tag something as copyright by the user that uploads it.
So yes, by not citing the actual artists, she is stealing. And those artists are losing RECOGNITION for their hard work, so yes, they ARE losing something. It is theft. |
| Sevireth #477057 10 months ago |
theres no theft you amateurs and no one is profiting from anything
there IS, however copyright infrigement, based on exactly one comment "thank you im making lots of them" here http://batrisyia04.deviantart.com/art/pinkie-pie-in-gala-dress-258615573 |
| Anonymous #477059 10 months ago |
@ Kiana, she's not implying she made these animations, she's blatantly saying she CREATED EVERYTHING.
Sevireth seems to be this chick's personal servant, purposeling trying to muddle and derail the discussion to protect her or whatever. What the hell, man. |
| Kiana #477061 10 months ago |
^ First off, not an amateur. I've been an artist for nearly a decade.
Second, it is ART THEFT. Which is the term that's been used for it online for at least the last six years. And third, this sort of shit pisses me off. Especially when people go "Oh, no one's getting hurt!" It does hurt the artists. It takes recognition away from them, which for a commission artist can be SEVERE. The fewer people who see the work as done by the original artist, the fewer people out there that might take an interest and give the artist a big break. It is dishonest, immoral and illegal. |
| Sevireth #477063 10 months ago |
im not protecting anyone here, but i AM trying to make the fanbase im a part of to appears less of a bunch of dickheads
you dont need to call names and throw shit around in order to serve justice. have some dignity once in a while will you. |
| Turin_Aramaia #477066 10 months ago |
When I start posting my Socal Brony eBay listings that use these fanarts, I WILL credit ALL source peices. The auction will be similar to the over-the-top "Get Zat" ebay listings. What would complete the nod would be a "cabbage patch" of pony heads. I'll try to get that commissioned. |
| Anonymous #477069 10 months ago |
Yup, that confirms it.
Sevireth is this chick's lap dog, doing tricks and protecting his mistress hoping to get laid or something. The things some people does for the lack of a life... |
| Kiana #477072 10 months ago |
^ Note in the irony in calling us dickheads. Take a moment and think about that.
The short of it is that someone is being dishonest, lawbreaking and also breaking DA's own rules of service. And is getting away with it. And just for added weight: I never 'threw shit'. I am laying out the facts. |
| Sevireth #477080 10 months ago |
#477069
jesus christ shes malaysian and nigh illiterate, anonymous is so anonymous and i am still waiting for example of her claiming she "CREATED EVERYTHING". that one time she said "im making lots of them" may simply mean shes uploading more, since her language skills are atrocious enough. |
| punctualjinx #477084 10 months ago |
A bunch of pointless discussions going on here. |
| Anonymous #477087 10 months ago |
Tags are very appropriate.
Whoever cares out there is a dodo. |
| Sevireth #477088 10 months ago |
Kiana, i never meant to imply youre acting inappropriate, i was talking about anonymous comments around here and expected — and still expect - something similar to appear on her dA. |
| Anonymous #477089 10 months ago |
Oh, but people DOES gets hurt here, see.The Destop Ponies team has been devoting a lot o their time to produce all of these animations for us, constantly updating them, and without asking anything in exchange.
Then horrible people like batrisyia04 and Sevireth pop out from nowhere, stealing months worth of other people's effort for their own benefit and picking fights/insulting any person who disagrees with them. Want to make this fanbase look better? Then remove yourselves from it for good, as horrible people like you don't belong here to begin with. |
| Sevireth #477092 10 months ago |
"Make something yourself instead of stealing other people's work you sad, integrityless waste of space."
and here we go |
| Sevireth #477098 10 months ago |
and bam. i try to voice out opinion different from others and find something actually incriminating and suddenly im stealing months worth of peoples effort for my own benefit (whatever im getting fom this)
never change, ponibooru |
| Kiana #477101 10 months ago |
@ Sevireth Which is not an insult, in the emotional-attack sense. 'Sad, integrityless waste of space' is a pretty good description. As she is stealing artwork, claiming it as her own and not producing anything herself. If she were merely a non-artist fan, she'd be welcomed. But theft puts her at the lowest of the low.
Therefore, she has no integrity, what she is doing is sad and she is only taking up space and making the fandom worse through her actions. |
| Anonymous #477102 10 months ago |
Okay...so what do you want the Ponibooru Council of Artistic Justice and Mercy to do about it? Report it to the DA admins and be done with it |
| Anonymous #477104 10 months ago |
ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ |
| Kiana #477112 10 months ago |
Anon, going by above statements, people HAVE reported this to DA and nothing has come from it. Apparently they're hoping that by getting more support, DA will actually take notice. |
| BILL_POOTIS #477113 10 months ago |
Damn. Looks like PonyRIG was right. |
| Sevireth #477115 10 months ago |
^
okay, those z's have a point. someone is breaking copyright law on the internet and i for some reason appear to unwittingly defend them. there are better ways to embarass myself out there, ill be gone now. |
| Pegasi #477116 10 months ago |
Thats not friendship...
Just be civil guys. |
| Anonycat #477122 10 months ago |
I wonder hen people will stop stealing for attention.
I mean, making your own animations isn't THAT difficult as to justify stealing them from other people and reposting them as your own. |
| Anonymous #477132 10 months ago |
I WANT PICTURES. PICTURES OF PONIES. |
| Kiana #477136 10 months ago |
@Anonycat Heck, Ponibooru accepts ANY pony related art. You don't even have be a 'good' artist (which is, of course, entirely opinion based) to have artwork here.
So stealing goes from ridiculous to pointless. You could make something in MSPaint and still get recognition for it. All stealing does is get you infamy. |
| Anonymous #477137 10 months ago |
There is Theft of Copyright, as the original Artist's ability to claim sole copyright was removed when the Impersonator posted. |
| Anonymous #477154 10 months ago |
I'm a Malaysian brony and I am VERY disappointed with her. Its a disgrace to us Malaysian bronies. I really hope that she will come to her senses and know that she has make a mistake. |
| Anonycat #477170 10 months ago |
@Kiana, the guys at the Desktop Ponies team offer templates and lots of advice to whoever wants to create their own animations or join the team, so yeah, this chick had no reason to come and steal everything.
Hell, if she wanted to repost our stuff at her gallery, she could have asked permission and most of us (myself included) would have said yes, as long she cited the original source. Browsing through her gallery I discovered a game she claims to be making (it could be stolen as well) were she's using more uncredited material, this time from a fangame named "Derpy Delivery" |
| Kiana #477171 10 months ago |
Okay, someone adding 'Sevireth's_Trolling' as a tag is uncalled for. |
| Anonycat #477179 10 months ago |
Hey, a bro from Malaysia? Cool! |
| Anonycat #477183 10 months ago |
@ Kiana, you should have seen what Sevireth himself added to the tags before they were edited out. |
| Anonymous #477188 10 months ago |
lol wtf is diz girl thinking? |
| Vincent991 #477209 10 months ago |
http://www.youtube.com/user/batrisyia04 GUYS! SHE'S JUST A KID! COME ON! |
| Anonymous #477213 10 months ago |
She is a fucking 7 year old kid and she already did this sinful thing? Bring out the holy water!!! |
| Kiana #477227 10 months ago |
@Anonycat Is that right? Funny, for someone trying to claim the moral high ground on us... Of course, this IS the guy that started using the term 'dickhead' in his argument. Kind of voids the moral high ground. |
| Anonymous #477228 10 months ago |
what? no more raging? what happened bronies? |
| Anonymous #477231 10 months ago |
I RAGE!! There you happy? |
| Anonymous #477251 10 months ago |
FART NOISES |
| Anonymous #477257 10 months ago |
How does i insert picture into comments? I want to give her a present. |
| Anonymous #477262 10 months ago |
is it bananas so that she could go to the MOOOOOOOOOOOOON? |
| Anonymous #477283 10 months ago |
Where's the RAGE???? |
| Anonymous #477338 10 months ago |
on da moon. |
| Anonymous #477364 10 months ago |
Where's the LOVE? |
| edudls #477373 10 months ago |
Sevireth's being a dick, art theft is bad but happens all the time, and this little tard should be reported. Can we move on now? Or have we already, and I'm just being an idiot? |
| Kiana #477389 10 months ago |
^ The latter, my friend. |
| BILL_POOTIS #477455 10 months ago |
@Vincent991
I... Kinda fell bad now... |
| Anonymous #477461 10 months ago |
and people wonder why i hate humanity
stealing my little pony GIFs? childish |
| Anonycat #477602 10 months ago |
*sigh* Hey, guess what...
The thief is sending threats to the Desktop Ponies team members, claiming they stole from HER. |
| BILL_POOTIS #477612 10 months ago |
^
Wait, what? REALLY?! Have any screen shots of that? |
| Anonycat #477640 10 months ago |
http://starsteppony.deviantart.com/art/Applejack-gala-dress-254896119 |
| BILL_POOTIS #477661 10 months ago |
Oh wooooooooooow... |
| Sevireth #477683 10 months ago |
"you stole my idea!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! you stole all my ideas!"
geez okay alright thats genuinely funny about tags, i replaced what was there with "art_theft da desktop_ponies deviantart" around 3 hours ago and thats it and i apologize if i came across as a troll, i only wanted to look at situation from another angle since the deviant in question didnt really seem to be the kind to deliberately claim others work as their own — she didnt seem intelligent enough. i felt like the crowd is about to lynch some alternatively gifted individual, to be frank. but yeah that reaction's asking for it now. |
| Kiana #477742 10 months ago |
^ In my experience, intelligence is not a requirement to claim someone's work as your own. Heck, I've seen people who aren't even smart enough to claim GOOD art as their own, but they still claim someone else's art is theirs.
I don't think this is a matter of a mentally challenged individual acting foolish. This looks more like your standard case of GIFT. Or regular human idiocy. Either she's just an idiot (By which I mean 'CHOOSING to be a pain in the arse') or she's deranged. Neither excuses her actions, but the second means we shouldn't hate her personally. (Not that I'll just happily let it slide. It means someone needs to watch her like a hawk so she doesn't start breaking laws on a whim.) |
| Kiana #477755 10 months ago |
To clarify, it boils down to one of two things:
1. She knows what she's doing is wrong, but is choosing to do it anyway. In which she could use a Bright Slap and 'grounding'. 2. She DOESN'T know/understand what she's doing is wrong, in which case she clearly needs a care taking looking over her shoulder at all times, for her own good. |
| Anonycat #477982 10 months ago |
I can't wait to see her reaction when she discovers half of "her" gallery already deleted by DA's staff.
For what I've collected from her deranged posts, broken grammar and incredible stupidity (just go and see it by yourself) she's very likely to throw an incredible tantrum at everyone for "attacking" her and for making her abide to "boring" rules. |
| Kiana #478293 10 months ago |
She is welcome to find a mountain cave to live in if she'd rather not follow rules. Rules ARE what society is build upon, after all. |
| Edudls #478723 10 months ago |
@Kiana7389 Apparently not. |
| Kiana #479049 10 months ago |
^ It was settled when my comment was made. It only heated up again after about an hour. |
| Anonymous #479675 10 months ago |
She's gonna get trolled... |