Blotter updated: 06/17/12Show/Hide Show All

Image

Tag History
(edit info)
Rating

Prev | Index | Next

Comments

Erin
#103293
1 year ago
Reminder that Pinkie Pie's saturation went up when she discovered something that brought colour into her life.

Music does the same for a lot of people.
Waka
#103296
1 year ago
maybe, similar to the real world, their hair color changes a bit as they get older. Makes sense to me.
Anonymous
#103298
1 year ago
All her colors made two tones darker....... I can live with that.
AdrianBrony
#103317
1 year ago
You believe every detail of pinkie's imagination?

that's rich I tells ya.

seriously, erin has a point, Pinkie changed colors about the same amount when she found her calling... might be in the family.
Anonymous
#103328
1 year ago
She got a tan.
AJTalon
#103373
1 year ago
So it just means if Pinkie and Octavia have sex, it's not incest. It's only slightly less clop worthy, right? To those who do that sort of thing...
Anonymous
#103378
1 year ago
You can't prove anything!

True, most likely Octavia is probably just a random background pony put together for a couple of scenes and probably won't be seen again unless we need another classical band scene.

I still like the sister idea, maybe because I really do want to see Pinkie's sisters again and this is the closest we've got currently.
feather
#103391
1 year ago
I personally place no credence in Pinkie's story in Cutey Mark Chronicles. there's probably SOME truth to it, but with Pinkie Pie, I think all you can get out of it that she has parents and sisters, and at some point, somehow as a result of the Sonic Rainboom (or not) they partied.
Anonymous
#103451
1 year ago
It's like that scene in Family Guy where Peter thinks every asian he runs into in Chinatown is Jackie Chan.
They could do an episode where Pinkie goes back to the farm and we see the grey sister, with the same hair cut, a rock cutie mark and the original tone, and people will be arguing "Octavia's a clone!" or "Pinkie has three sisters!" or "It's a Jekyl and Hyde/secret life thing!"
The worst thing about bronies is how hard set they are on sticking to their fandom fantasies, even when the hard facts are staring them in the face. I can only imagine the uproar in season 2 when Derpy gets more screen time and it's confirmed that she doesn't have a daughter.
Anonymous
#103561
1 year ago
well duh, she had a dye job to look pretty for the gala gig.
Anonymous
#103719
1 year ago
I prefer the idea of her being Lyra's sister
Oh-noes
#103728
1 year ago
^Me too. But I can see it work as Pinkie's sister too.
Anonymous
#103875
1 year ago
"I can only imagine the uproar in season 2 when Derpy gets more screen time and it's confirmed that she doesn't have a daugher."

Or worse...she DOES have a daughter, but its a non-unicorn with a different name!

Poor Dinky :(
Anonymous
#104377
1 year ago
@Erin
The problem with that is that only Pinkie did, the rest of her family DIDN'T.
Anonymous
#104690
1 year ago
Eyes Color: Purple V.s Light Purple
Skin Color: Dark Grey V.s Light Grey
Mane Style: hmmmm.. I Don't Know what Mane Style they have...
Cutie Mark: Undiscovered Mark V.s A Musical Mark
Which Sister do you prefer?: I Prefer Lyra Sister >:D
Anonymous
#105174
1 year ago
Same eyes, same body, fan-base has proclaimed it.
That's like saying Dinky isn't Derpy's daughter.
Anonymous
#105800
1 year ago
^^Hair can change color as you get older.
Anonymous
#111704
1 year ago
Hair color can change for humans as they age as well.
TypeNameHere
#134215
1 year ago
I'm sticking with the "Octavia is Pinkie Pie's sister" theory. If Season 2 disproves this theory (I think the fan-term is "jossed"), then that'll be fine too, I guess, because I really can't argue against canon.

As much as I like Lyra though, I really don't think she and Octavia are related.
Anonymous
#134234
1 year ago
As much as they look alike, she didn't react to Pinkie like a sister would, and Pinkie didn't recognize her. Pinkie would be the first to loudly greet family in that kind of public situation.
TypeNameHere
#135175
1 year ago
^ Some people have noticed that when Pinkie leaps into the stage, everypony except Octavia is shocked. Octavia had an "Oh crap, it's her" expression.

And Pinkie is probably somewhat estranged from the rest of her family (her flashbacks being as unreliable as they are), so it's entirely possible she didn't recognize her at first.
Anonymous
#194631
1 year ago
Updated version: >>25913
Aponymousse
#194699
1 year ago
@TypeNameHere
Octavia could've reacted like that because she heard of Pinkie, but haven't really met her or anything. If not, maybe she's from Manehatten, where they've just about seen everything and it doesn't really surprise her compared to the stuff she seen.

I'm with #234 here. I would think at least one of them would acknowledge that they are sisters. I can understand if Octavia didn't acknowledge her due to being jaded by her sister's wacky hijinks and personality, but I would think Pinkie would at least make an attempt to celebrate their reunion, or at least go to her first when asking them to play the pony pokey.

The only reason I could think of that they wouldn't acknowledge each other and being sisters would be due to time and/or budget constraints.
Anonymous
#224318
1 year ago
Keep in mind that the creators took to mind some of the brony community's ideas for the second season. What with the adding parts for our favorite background ponies, it wouldn't surprise me if they took the fanon behind Octavia and incorporated it into the show.
mycoid
#237490
1 year ago
#105174 fan base = cannon? oh you. ^_^
Lockstep
#237525
1 year ago
Know what? Maybe they just see each other all the time. Or they write regularly. They keep close, so both of them already knew that the other would be at the Gala, and they didn't feel the need to catch up or anything.
Anonymous
#255846
1 year ago
I love this theory, although I doubt it'll be made canon. XD But it'd be neat to see Octavia and Pinkie interact if we ever see this pony again!

@#103451
>The worst thing about bronies is how hard set they are on sticking to their fandom fantasies, even when the hard facts are staring them in the face.
>The worst thing about bronies is how hard set they are on sticking to their fandom fantasies
>The worst thing about bronies
Ugh. I...do not like it when people do this. I'm not sure if you meant to, but here it sounds like you are saying that ALL bronies are like this. Some are. Some aren't.

Also:
>even when the hard facts are staring them in the face.
You...don't get the concept of "theories", so you? There's a difference between saying "OMFG OCTAVIA IS DEFINITELY PINKIE'S SISTER" (translation: "That is canon and if you try and say otherwise I will not listen or admit for a second that I could be wrong.") and "Hey, you know, Octavia looks a bit like Pinkie's sister...maybe they're the same pony? That'd be cool!"

Personally, I love how much fan speculation is in this community. Sure, you see fanon in other fandoms, but this show's fandom has some of the most "extreme" examples. How many other cartoons have people naming and making backstories for random BG characters?

>I can only imagine the uproar in season 2 when Derpy gets more screen time and it's confirmed that she doesn't have a daughter.
As somebrony else mentioned, this is referred to as "jossing", and when it happens for other shows, it's never really bothered me. I'll be disappointed depending on how much I wanted that theory to be true, but I don't get in an uproar about it, and I honestly don't think many bronies will, either. It's just the ones who DO react like that, would be really, really loud about it...

Also, what #224318 said, assuming Octavia ever returns (which I honestly doubt, tbh, but it'd be neat).

@Lockstep That...actually makes sense. Although Pinkie was probably so eager to try and make the party more exciting, she might have not even recognized Octavia. She CAN be a bit clueless sometimes. <3 While Octavia was just wondering what the heck her crazy sister was DOING.
kanashiikage
#259149
1 year ago
Comparing these pictures, their color schemes just seem too different for me. It's not like Pinkie's subdued pink to bright pink. Octavia's like a brownish grey mixture while Pinkie's sis is just grey Octavia's hair is black, while Pinkie's sis is gray.

I'm not going to write it out, but I just can't see the following for this theory just like I don't understand the Derpy/Dinky theory.
Anonymous
#746913
7 months ago
The, thing is: what's nice about Lauren Faust, is that she takes fanon into consideration, a lot. Bronies go around loving Derpy, Lauren becomes aware through her DevientArt page, and she declares Derpy to he the crossed-eyed ponies name. She then arranges to have Derpy stuck into every episode of S2 so far! It's like a "Where's Derpy?" kinda deal. If enough fans declare this to be so, then I'm sure Faust would take our beliefs into consideration, and could arrange a way to make it so, unless a larger plan is at hand, such as revealing Pinkies real sisters adult forms, or developing a subplot around Octavia.