
| Edef #390252 11 months ago |
Awesome. |
| drpepperfan1 #390254 11 months ago |
There we go, now in a proper size. You're welcome. |
| Anonymous #390275 11 months ago |
These get more insane by the panel. |
| Warhammer3025 #390277 11 months ago |
I normally enjoy these (being as dark-yet-silly as they are) but now she's being mean to Fluttershy.
Nopony gets to be mean to Fluttershy. Nopony. |
| PVRyohei #390280 11 months ago |
Is it weird that i'm wish i was taken instead of Fluttershy? And i'm not saying this because i want to save her. |
| drpepperfan1 #390286 11 months ago |
Oh man, I can't wait for the butthurt that the other upload got to start here. I'm gonna be laughing for ages. |
| Anonymous #390296 11 months ago |
I like the style, and the over the top Pinkamena keeps me laugh. Dunno if it's another dimention or whatever, she's pinkamena to me. |
| Anonymous #390297 11 months ago |
Pinkamina, you're a big meaniepants! |
| Kooner #390298 11 months ago |
Awesome as always. |
| nintendofreak768 #390299 11 months ago |
I love this artist. I know it may be fluttershy but still this is fucking amazing art. I hope to see this version of pinkamenia go more crazy more often. |
| nyxabuse #390313 11 months ago |
@Warhammer3025: (to repost from the other upload)
No. I think this is great. People have been loving this blog about a vicious murdering raping cannibal; and now she goes after somepony we actually care about. It's drawn us in with the awesome characterisation, and is now going for the emotional punch. It's a masterpiece. |
| Anonymous #390314 11 months ago |
I <3 Fluttershy, but this is ok I guess.
:I |
| Chronos_Pony #390317 11 months ago |
I'm torn as to whether I like this or I hate it. |
| Jiranis #390322 11 months ago |
Can we get a part 2 to this plox.
I need some nightmare fuel. |
| Saufsoldat #390324 11 months ago |
Can't wait for the next one, this is simply brilliant. |
| nyxabuse #390326 11 months ago |
^I think that we'll either only see the aftermath, or there will be a few strips with tied-up Fluttershy in the background. |
| nyxabuse #390331 11 months ago |
(That was meant as a reply to Jiranis) |
| Muffinoffun #390334 11 months ago |
I feel like a terrible person for liking these. |
| Zarkanorf #390337 11 months ago |
I love the shivers this guy sends down my spine.
By all means, continue! |
| Anonymous #390342 11 months ago |
Silly Bronies, Shyshy's just rolepalyin', do none of you do BDSM? |
| nyxabuse #390368 11 months ago |
^Yeah, you keep telling yourself that. |
| Anonymous #390375 11 months ago |
Seriously, she's within licking distance of Pinkie's face and has not engaged the stare, she's obviously NOT in a distress situation. |
| Anonymous #390379 11 months ago |
Awww please be nice to Fluttershy, she deserves it.
But still SO AWESOME, even if my heart cries for poor Fluttershy ... |
| nyxabuse #390392 11 months ago |
^^In the show, Fluttershy has only used The Stare when others are in danger. Furthermore, this is PINKIE PIE doing what she is doing - one of Fluttershy's closest friends. The confusion may well stop her from using The Stare, even instinctively. |
| K_thanks #390393 11 months ago |
Oh guys, i bet in this alternative universe everyone is evil |
| Warhammer3025 #390400 11 months ago |
@nyxabuse
I hadn't considered that angle. I still don't like it, but I can see where someone would. |
| Anonymous #390405 11 months ago |
So, this is Psychomina and Fuckaloo craving up vicious wildlife hunter and all arround nasty Cuttershy?
PROCEED. |
| Anonymous #390425 11 months ago |
My question is : If they are touching nose to nose, WHY AREN'T THEY KISSING YET? I mean, really, they are both adorable in those last two panels.
We need Makeout pics with them! |
| nyxabuse #390435 11 months ago |
^^No. Don't lie to yourself. This is the same animal-loving birdsong-training town vet Fluttershy that you see in the show. And Pinkie is going to rape and torture her to death.
Anything else is a cop-out. Let yourself feel the pain. |
| ChickNeighney #390436 11 months ago |
I like this ask thing, but Fluttershy better get outta this alive or Imma be pissed. |
| Anonymous #390443 11 months ago |
While they kiss, Fluttershy bites off her tongue. And then she gets justifiedly angry (and partially mute).
A sick idea, but then so is this comic... |
| Dark_Horst #390450 11 months ago |
NOT OKAY! |
| Anonymous #390455 11 months ago |
Crooky likes to go for the balls: No one freaked when 'mena stole lyra, Nor wen she carved up caramel, Nor when she hied Scoots, Nor when she went Pedo; Nigga figured he gotta step up his game. Now sum dickwad presents him a mane 6 in a platter, whas's a Nigga gonna do, huh? WHAZZ A NEEGG-UHH GONNA DOO??!! |
| Icehawk #390464 11 months ago |
Oh wow, this is an insane yet rather awesome turn of events, he really knows how to push the emotional shock and awe buttons. |
| Wafflecannon #390467 11 months ago |
As much as the alarm bells in my head went off when Fluttershy got involved I still can't bring myself to dislike this one. Crookedtrees just has this way of charging each panel with emotion.
Although, the last panel makes me worried that she's gonna cut Fluttershy's tongue out... |
| Anonymous #390482 11 months ago |
One of the greatest things about this is that I imagine this Pinkamena talking in one of those crazy two-tone voices like "Aint that cute"-guy, The Red Guy and HIM.
She'd be all sweet in the first two panels and the second-to last, but in the fourth and last panel her voice goes deep, gravelly and absolutely insane. |
| Anonymous #390484 11 months ago |
NOOOOOO! FLUTTERSHY!
*Puts on Viking helmet* BRONIES! TO. AAAAAAAARRRRMS! |
| ChickNeighney #390487 11 months ago |
This is actually not as good as his other stuff. The other ones were clever or funny in some way or another. This is neither. It's just mean. |
| Trombe #390491 11 months ago |
My morbid curiosity makes me desire to see the further development of this particular course of events. |
| PVRyohei #390497 11 months ago |
I'm hoping for some consensual BDSM next.
Some gore wouldn't be bad, but not as awesome. Also, i don't hate fluttershy, i'm just getting in the mood of the thing. |
| nyxabuse #390498 11 months ago |
@wafflecannon: Oh gods, don't give her ideas! |
| Anonymous #390499 11 months ago |
I'd love to see a Part 2 to this, regardless of what happens in it. Yeah, yeah, nobody touches Fluttershy, but still, I wanna see where this goes. CrookedTrees loves making shocking art it seems, and I'm quite a fan of how he does it. |
| Anonymous #390525 11 months ago |
We need part two NOW! |
| Luna69 #390536 11 months ago |
POSSIBILITIES! The situation, the situation
Because of fanon and Fluttershy being a closet sadomasochist, things will turn out ok. And she'll either get free or be enlisted to help Pinkamena or turn the tables on Pinkamena and rape her. I dunno :I *shrug* OR She is going to be raped, butchered and turned into smoked pegasus wings cause they're delicious all the while screaming her full damn head off for help even though nopony will ever hear her. She will die in pain, scared, and alone at the hooves of what used to be one of her best friends. CrookedTrees did this because of the large fanbase Fluttershy has. He wanted to dig up the anthill, stir the pot, w/e. |
| PinkamenaDiane #390544 11 months ago |
Holy crap, I'm not even that heartless. I like Fluttershy! |
| Karazor #390550 11 months ago |
Oh, sure, when it's Rainbow being tortured to death for the five zillionth time no one cares, but when it's Fluttershy everyone's up in arms.
I mean, I'm certainly not happy about the idea of Fluttershy being tortured to death, but I'm not cool with it happening to Rainbow either. So you guys get to feel the way I feel when Cupcakes gets brought up all the time. |
| Edef #390561 11 months ago |
It's pathetic how people wave off every other pony but when it's Fluttershy it's "WAAAH HOW COULD YOU!?"
This is easily the best askpinkamina yet. |
| Anonymous #390565 11 months ago |
here's hoping we get to see Scootaloo rape her, after all it's her favorite. |
| nyxabuse #390572 11 months ago |
^I'm fairly sure we're not going to see anything actually graphic; it'll probably just be the aftermath. |
| Luna69 #390574 11 months ago |
Karazor and Edef, I've seen a lot of people be horrified by cupcakes and anything cupcakes related. I puked my guts out when I read it. I avoid anything cupcakes related. In fact, just typing and reading about it makes me want to go empty my stomach.
You both are just seeing 'WAAAH HOW COULD YOU' in a higher concentration here. There's probably more 'WAAAH HOW COULD YOU' than there was with RainbowDash because, honestly, RainbowDash can be a bit of an ass. Get off your high horse and let Fluttershy's fanbase writhe about in horror. |
| KhrisKross #390588 11 months ago |
Yeah, I'm not a fan of Fluttershy, not in the least, but I LOVES me some Pinkamena! >:) |
| PVRyohei #390590 11 months ago |
I know people will hate me for this, but i kind of liked cupcakes. I do take fics seriously, i love shipping and PinkieDash is one of my favorites, but i also enjoy other categories, and if cupcakes managed to get such a reaction from the fandom, then it deserves respect. |
| KhrisKross #390596 11 months ago |
^ You summed up my feelings exactly. |
| ChickNeighney #390608 11 months ago |
It's not that I liked Cupcakes, it's just that it made me laugh more than it creeped me out. There were only 2 parts that got to me, but then the rest just made me laugh. It was hyped up to be more than it was. I was expecting to walk out of it never thinking about Pinkie the same way again, but just walked out with a good joke or two. |
| Dribbles #390620 11 months ago |
I feel disappointment. This series has served some good black comedy (regardless of the occasional fan service stuff), and now it seems he's taking the cheap route. Oh well, the art is still great. |
| Anonymous #390621 11 months ago |
How exactly do you use this site? I don't see ways to ask questions or anything. |
| WhirlyWillow #390623 11 months ago |
You know......sleep is overrated anyway..... |
| nyxabuse #390642 11 months ago |
^^Click on 'will you be my friend?'
Or go to http://askpinkaminadianepie.tumblr.com/ask |
| Anonymous #390647 11 months ago |
^Thanks. |
| Luna69 #390652 11 months ago |
And that's how some people deal with cupcakes. As a joke. In the way it was written, yeah.
:3 I've got a weak constitution and a fantastic imagination. Don't even pretend to gag in front of me. |
| PonyPuffy #390660 11 months ago |
Even though its Fluttershy on the receiving end of Pinkamena's torture I can't bring myself to dislike this...yeap Psycho Pinkie is that cool!! |
| PinkamenaDiane #390669 11 months ago |
You know, about my comment earlier. Yeah, I am that heartless. I had to go have some soup and a good long think. so... yeah... |
| Anonymous #390708 11 months ago |
@390455
Your mother. |
| Anonymous #390786 11 months ago |
... |
| Luna69 #390817 11 months ago |
I wonder how many people went to go watch vid's with Fluttershy in them on youtube and/or started writing fanfics about this, just to make sure she's ok. This is art. This is an artist. Your beloved waifu will be there in the next season. I promise. Who wants a hug?
Shh, it's ok. It'll be ok. You're ok. She's ok. Everything's ok. |
| ChickNeighney #390829 11 months ago |
Just because it's not canon doesn't mean you can't have a negative reaction to it. |
| Luna69 #390855 11 months ago |
Yes, I know that. I understand greatly, but also, there are those out there that take this stuff very very seriously. I've seen it happen, even with lego's. *horrific flashbacks* D:
Anyhoo... with some people, this is their life. This is what makes them happy. And with some people, it's Fluttershy that makes them happy. |
| Anonymous #390857 11 months ago |
@ Luna
Because liking a character means wanting them as a waifu. Clearly. |
| Luna69 #390864 11 months ago |
D: I was just trying to comfort a little, you know? I'm a humanitarian. :I |
| Luna69 #390871 11 months ago |
Oh oy, @ Anon 857, I'm not saying EVERYONE wants Fluttershy as a waifu, I'm talking about those that do. |
| ChickNeighney #390881 11 months ago |
I see what you're getting at, Luna, but it's still annoying that, whenever someone has a negative reaction to something, there's always one arsehole that says the obvious, "it's not even real/canon." Any number of people can have a party over a positive, cute picture, but as soon as someone goes, "aww, that's not cool," someone's gotta be a douche. |
| Luna69 #390907 11 months ago |
Awww... you're calling me a douche/arsehole? What did I do to you? Can I not offer a bode of comfort in these dark times? |
| Luna69 #390912 11 months ago |
And here I was genuinely believing I was being a good person. Well, I'll be damned. |
| ChickNeighney #390922 11 months ago |
lol, I didn't mean it like that, but however you wanna interpret it is fine. |
| Luna69 #390928 11 months ago |
oh lol, ok X3 I forgive you *cuddles*
My blonde is probably showing. My bad. X3 |
| Anonymous #390930 11 months ago |
Well I just begged for Fluttershy's life. I hope Pinkamina will listen. |
| ChickNeighney #390943 11 months ago |
Now that you did that, Anon 930, CT's most likely gonna pull a, "lol we were playing all along. ;P"
Either that or a, "too late. ;P" |
| Anonymous #390956 11 months ago |
^Simple misunderstanding there, Luna69, sorry about that.
Anyway, I just had an awesome, horrifying idea. What if the next one has them in bed, and everybody is of course all super relieved Fluttershy is okay...Then she pulls back the covers...And all that's there is Fluttershy's head. Pure motherfucking MAGIC. |
| Anonymous #390972 11 months ago |
I can't wait to see where he goes with this. Killing off Fluttershy would take some serious balls, yet somehow I doubt he's going that route...
Also, has anypony here considered that Pinkamena has made a serious mistake by uncovering Fluttershy's *eyes*? |
| Luna69 #390979 11 months ago |
The stare doesn't work on the insane. |
| Luna69 #390982 11 months ago |
Oh! Anon 956, I forgive you too *cuddles* |
| Anonymous #390984 11 months ago |
Just in case I made sure to ask if she would share some of that smoked wing.
We should be good when the next installment hits. Unless she hogs it all. |
| Dribbles #390988 11 months ago |
Incidentally, where has Gummy been during this series? |
| Anonymous #390992 11 months ago |
Gumbo |
| Anonymous #391032 11 months ago |
I have the weirdest boner. |
| Gnollbard #391059 11 months ago |
Goddamnit. I hate myself for saving these, but they're so high-quality... |
| Homfrog #391072 11 months ago |
@Dribbles Pinkamena's got a new pair of boots! |
| Anonymous #391073 11 months ago |
......And then I suddenly disliked Ask Pinkamina. Imagine that.... |
| Anonymous #391104 11 months ago |
As long as it saves Fluttershy, I don't really care, ChickNeighney. |
| SirPayne #391121 11 months ago |
I love fluttershy, but that doesnt stop me from disliking this ask. Its brilliantly done, and is obviously doing a good job of making people uncomfortable. Id you dont like it, go read a happy fic. |
| SirPayne #391124 11 months ago |
^ shit I mean it doesnt stop me from liking it. I love this ask. |
| Bongo #391583 11 months ago |
BUTTHURT
BUTTHURT EVERYWHERE |
| mycoid #391651 11 months ago |
@ anon342 that is what I was thinking...
No I haven't...wish I could. |
| sodomitor #391953 11 months ago |
Now that's nice change from all 'kissing' and 'cute murderer'. let's see some real, crazy, scary butcher-rapist Pinkamena Diane! And fuck you FS lovers, I'll laugh at your butthurt.
Seriously thought, fucken awesome Her face! |
| bersl2 #391957 11 months ago |
@Bongo
I am not butthurt; I am *EMOTIONALLY EVICERATED*. |
| Anonymous #392042 11 months ago |
You better don't put a finger on her because if you do something to her...
![]() |
| ChickNeighney #392104 11 months ago |
^
Nobody lays a finger. *puts on sunglasses* On my Flutterfinger. |
| Huacaya #392122 11 months ago |
Interesting.
No, very interesting. A number of thoughts: Firstly, the look Pinkamena has in the first panel almost destroys the 4th wall and tells the viewer 'Why yes, I AM just doing this to piss you off'. Bonded Fluttershy is hawt Fluttershy. Just saying. Oh my dearest flutters, what has happened to you? I don't think she would yell out like that. By this point I'd think she would be both cowed and broken. But that's a minor complaint. I can't tell if the last line is meant to be a joke or if it's meant to be taken ironically. Also, I'm I the only one who noticed the Flutters just got the 'crazy eye' look in the last panel? Anyway, I like where this is going. I hope Flutters isn't just slaughtered, but I don't think crookedtrees would do that. It's too … simple. I hope this has a more psychological bent to it and Fluttershy is pushed and pushed and pushed until she strikes back, through either madness or desperation, becoming the antithesis of her entire character. I hope Pinkamena somehow turns the lovable Fluttershy into a predator. Either way, CrookedTrees has managed to elicit emotion from a large number of people with his work. Not many people can claim that. |
| Anonymous #392159 11 months ago |
@ Huacaya
CrookedTrees used the 'crazy' eye thing to depict adrenaline rush or something. Fluttershy is shaking and tears are coming from her eyes, yeah she probably would have been quiet in that situation 'cowed and broken' as you put it. That look in the first panel? That's the look of a predator with a new toy. Let's face it. According to this tumblr, Fluttershy is going to die. Fluttershy is going to be raped, torn and cut to pieces, and eaten. This Pinkamena is going to kill Fluttershy. You FS fans probably won't see every detail, or maybe you will, this tumblr is unpredictable like that. Either way, she's a goner. On this tumblr Fluttershy will die, and there's nothing you can do about it. |
| Anonymous #392759 11 months ago |
^^ I think the last line's only meant as a reference to the line from Best Night Ever. |
| nyxabuse #393179 11 months ago |
WRT Fluttershy being 'cowed and broken': realistically, I would think she would be shitting herself with fear right now. But I get the impression that this is her JUST having been captured by Pinkamena, so a panicked reaction (as we see here) is to be expected (she can't believe what is going on, why has Pinkie tied her up, what's that funny smell, etc.).
After a few hour of horrific physical and sexual abuse, then you should get the 'cowed and broken' effect you seem to have been expecting. |
| Anonymous #393259 11 months ago |
Twilight Sparkle is Enrage |
| Gatekeeper #393688 11 months ago |
As much as I love Fluttershy I can't bring myself to hate this.
Looking at the comments, it looks like Crookedtrees got quite the reaction out of people, which I have to applaud. |
| Anonymous #393733 11 months ago |
Yeah, this is a bit of a trolltumblr. Albeit a very well-drawn one!
But I don't think that this is Pinkie. I don't think that this is any form of Pinkie. Pinkie Pie would not even pull a prank on such a sensitive pony as Fluttershy, and I doubt that any alternate personality of hers, or even any form of her in an alternate universe, would have the heart to torture and destroy Fluttershy. So who--or what--is this we are dealing with then? My guess would be a sort of Molestia-type situation where this Pinkamina Diane Pie has either been posessed by something of pure hatred and evil, or has been slaughtered and the whatever-it-is is now using her guise. |
| derp #393974 11 months ago |
Wow I have such a wingboner right now! |
| Anonymous #394478 11 months ago |
It funny, I can't handle sadfics or very grimdark death/rape/torture fics. But in art it just has less impact. Guess it doesn't hurt I actually LIKE crookedtrees Pinkamena. Kinda nonsensical that she has such attachment to Scoots but is willing to kill any other number that comes up, including her best friends... maybe it's because Scoots accepts her and she knows her friends never would?
Also I don't think this is the same Pink one from Cupcakes. That was not Pinkamena all crazy, that was Pinky Pie with the poofy hair and all. Pinkamena is fully aware of her actions and implications thereof, Pinky was completely unable to differentiate right from wrong. |
| Anonymous #394619 11 months ago |
It's not like it's going to show a reenactment of cupcakes with Fluttershy instead of Rainbow Dash.
No overly violent imagery has been shown in the blog EVER. Some sadism, some corpses, that's it. |
| Anonymous #394676 11 months ago |
I liked this. Probably because I'm currently suffering from Hype Backlash from Fluttershy because of all the attention she gets. Yeah, she's cute, but she's not the best pony at all (that title belongs to Rainbow or Pinkie).
Loved it, can't wait for the next one! |
| Anonymous #394729 11 months ago |
Lol, I love how so many people are angry at this because its Fluttershy. But when other ponies get tortured and eaten, it's completely fine.
I love this tumblr, and on a certain level I liked Cupcakes (probably because I love horror movies). Yeah I was sad that it was Dash getting tortured because she's my favorite, but a lot of the alternate endings were great, especially the one where Dash survived and learned how to live without her wings. Long story short, I'm not mad. |
| Anonymous #396038 11 months ago |
If you absolutely need an "alternate reality" to cushion the butthurt:
All the Tumblr pics are not webcam shots, but rather artist renderings drawn by Pinky Pie herself as an "outlet" for her morbid Pinkamena side and an elaborate meta prank thought up by her and Rainbow Dash. All the shots of Scootaloo are modeled from life by Rainbow Dash, Fluttershy modeled her own scenes, the unicorns are modeled from Rarity. Other than Rainbow Dash, none of her models were aware of the content or subject matter they would be depicted in. |
| Anonymous #396368 11 months ago |
first panel pinkamena is sooooo hot... |
| Anonymous #398702 11 months ago |
I love this!! |
| Anonymous #398712 11 months ago |
I liked all the posts on this Tumblr; until this.
But damn, is well drawn and has that "I-don¿t-know-what" that still makes it irresistible. Hopefully the author may spare us Fluttershy lovers all the bloody scenes and just show us the aftermath o.o |
| Anonymous #400015 11 months ago |
Dude I got chills |
| Anonymous #457477 10 months ago |
Yeah, so Pinkie carved LOUDMOUTH into Fluttershy's stomach and stitched her mouth shut. So much for "SHE WON'T KILL FLUTTERSHY".
Fluttershy screamed for You to help her by the way. She screamed until the very end. And You couldn't do anything. |
| Anonymous #462198 10 months ago |
Pinkamena in the first panel: "Oh yes, there will be RAGE about this! Dance my little puppets! DANCE!" |
| FeelsGood #542834 9 months ago |
![]() |
| Sods #601384 9 months ago |
I feel for Fluttershy, but 3P is sexy. So conflicted... |
| Anonymous #746051 7 months ago |
LOVE AND TOLERANCE, LADS.
YOU WOULD ALL DO WELL TO REMEMBER IT! |