| Anonymous #331056 11 months ago |
OBJECTION!
Clearly Friendship is Magic belongs in the God Tier. |
| AdrianBrony #331059 11 months ago |
I think this is a good compromise if top tier is a variable god tier where one is higher than the other depending on the person. I'm pretty sure most of the old guard would be comfortable with midnight castle being in that consideration. |
| Anonymous #331063 11 months ago |
Seems accurate.
Bronies and non-MLP fans alike love the pilot. FiM doesn't need to be talked about. The original cartoon is well-liked and isn't that bad once you get past the weird animation. Tales, G2, and G3 are debatable. No one likes G3.5 |
| Anonymous #331065 11 months ago |
OBJECTION!
That thing which is clearly not FiM is in the same tier as FiM. Unacceptable. |
| Anonymous #331070 11 months ago |
Objection.
The pilot is win. |
| Anonymous #331076 11 months ago |
Firefly's Adventure shouldn't be in Top Tier..
It needs to be above FiM, in God Tier. |
| Anonymous #331079 11 months ago |
Funny thing is that G3.5 doesn't bug me as much as G3. |
| Anonymous #331081 11 months ago |
OBJECTION!
What pilot? |
| Anonymous #331084 11 months ago |
Anon, the pilot to the MLP franchise. |
| Anonymous #331090 11 months ago |
^ true enough, it really is pretty good. after i became a brony i watched midnight castle out of curiosity. it really is a good piece of animation. would have been better if they didn't cliche up Skorpan. why can't a monster have morals? |
| Anonymous #331091 11 months ago |
OBJECTION!
Alright, I can see that. |
| Anonymous #331095 11 months ago |
^wow filled up fast. should have said AdrianBrony then |
| Bongo #331098 11 months ago |
I don't know about you, but I like the theme songs for G2 and G3, mostly for G1 and G4. :/
The G3.5 theme can burn in hell for all I care. |
| Anonymous #331100 11 months ago |
I'd also have preferred if Scorpan were different. I liked him as a bad guy, and not a good human prince. |
| Anonymous #331122 11 months ago |
^yes! I know, right? why couldn't he be some strange demon creature with realistic morality |
| Anonymous #331130 11 months ago |
OVERULLED |
| Anonymous #331136 11 months ago |
FiM has to re-do the pilot, or reference to it. |
| Shelltoon #331157 11 months ago |
It really is a shame the rest of G1 couldn't live up to Midnight Castle. |
| Anonymous #331164 11 months ago |
i liked tales |
| Mushi #331174 11 months ago |
"ew no tier" XD |
| Anonymous #331749 11 months ago |
G3.5 is in Alfalfa Monster tier? |
| Anonymous #338905 11 months ago |
G4 should be GODLYFOREVER tier and all the others FUCKNO tiers. G4 is what made MLP what it is now. |
| Anonymous #340043 11 months ago |
G1 made My Little Pony what it is now. Without it, there would be no G4; Lauren got most of her inspiration from G1. |
| Leilana_Lappy #340568 11 months ago |
@331063: I like G3.5. I miss StarSong and Toola-Roola. |
| Anonymous #340853 11 months ago |
Anyone who says that the pilot (the one next to FiM) isn't good is someone who hasn't taken the time to actually watch it :x
If anything, it's so bad it's good, kinda like Season 1 of the Sailor Moon dubs |
| Anonymous #351099 11 months ago |
To me G3 and G3.5 are about even, though G3 might have a slight edge due to looking prettier in most places and having had more time to develop more smoothly. Now, Newborn Cuties, that you can throw into the bottom "garbage" tier. Newborn Cuties makes me go 'WHAT' at every turn. |
| Anonymous #353356 11 months ago |
G3.5 has it's own tier
The "Take out back and shoot" tier |
| Anonymous #353944 11 months ago |
ive still not watched Rescue From Midnight Castle, but I'm curious about. |
| Posey #354606 11 months ago |
Anon356, that would be where the "Baby" cartoon in 3.5 goes. That one was just an abomination against animation. |
| Anonymous #373253 11 months ago |
G2 isn't even a cartoon. |
| Anonymous #391670 11 months ago |
^ Hence the pic of the toy. It didn't have a cartoon of it's own. |
| Anonymous #419413 10 months ago |
Why the hell does everyone hate gen 3.5? I think it's freaking cute. |
| Anonymous #513672 10 months ago |
HERESY! |
| Anonymous #592498 9 months ago |
People hate 3.5 because it's so cute, it becomes nauseatingly saccharine. It crosses the line from "cute" to "OH GOD I JUST PUKED UP MY DIGESTIVE SYSTEM".
See, the thing about FIM is that it's cute, but it's cute in a good way, without going overboard. Watch almost any scene with Fluttershy or the CMC and you'll understand what I'm talking about. Seriously, though, everything except G1 and G4 can go straight to hell. |
| Anonymous #1285002 2 months ago |
I agree with this, mostly. It's a bit shaky with G1 and G1.5, since G1.5 died off before it could really do anything too bad (unlike G3.5, which did everything wrong as soon as it started).
It really depends whether your more a fan of character or story. G1.5 at least tries to make individual characters, but the stories are as bland as bread. G1 had (sorta) interesting stories but really the only character I ever notice is Surprise. |