
| Anonymous #114458 1 year ago |
Quick question, my mind's so full of fanfic, but are any of those names official v: |
| Anonymous #114459 1 year ago |
2 unicorns, 1 pega, 3 earth ponies.
nope. |
| Bnau #114460 1 year ago |
naaa I dont think so |
| Anonymous #114461 1 year ago |
Lyra
Vinyl Scratch Octavia Cherilee Derpy Dr Whooves |
| Anonymous #114464 1 year ago |
Cheerilee's name is official |
| Anonymous #114465 1 year ago |
I think Bon-Bon could be Lyra's Spike. For the second pegasus we can have Lightning Bolt (the barrel roller in the intro). |
| MetalHooves #114467 1 year ago |
If you wanna stick with background clones, then you gotta get a different peg in there, and replace cheerilee because she actually has more than one line. |
| MetalHooves #114468 1 year ago |
Actually, replace cheerilee with a pegasus. there we go. |
| Anonymous #114476 1 year ago |
OP here. I originally had Lightning Bolt in place of Carrot Top, for a 2 of every species balance, but decided she was too obscure.
And yeah, I thought about Vinyl, but decided Colgate instead. Now I think I'll edit w/ Vinyl instead though. |
| theplatinumcolt #114477 1 year ago |
what about octavia, or scratch? |
| Anonymous #114492 1 year ago |
I'd see more as:
Pegasi: Derpy Hooves and Cloud Kicker Unicorns: Lyra and Colgate or Scratch Earth Ponies: Bon Bon and Carrot Top. |
| Anonymous #114498 1 year ago |
Agreeing with Anon7 |
| your_waifu #114500 1 year ago |
i can't see vinyl scratch as a member of any secondary group. she hasn't had much fandom apart from "plays music" and really, she'd rather be on tour. |
| feather #114506 1 year ago |
why are colgate and Cherilee on there? O.o |
| Anonymous #114540 1 year ago |
OK, so, only Lyra and Derpy are agreed on, correct? |
| Anonymous #114564 1 year ago |
If you have Lyra you have to have BonBon tho. |
| Anonymous #114568 1 year ago |
^
Then Derpy, Lyra and BonBon are agreed upon then, huh? |
| Aurora_Moon #114578 1 year ago |
at least we all agree on Lyra, Bon Bon, and Derpy being in there. i do say no to Doctor Whooves/Whoof, because...its Doctor Whoof/Whooves. he cant be part of the Secondary-...wait.
i just realized. if you only count ponies, then there is a 'mane six', but count Spike, and its 7. so shouldnt it be a Secondary Seven, not Secondary Six? two pegasi, two unicorns, two earth ponies, and a non-pony 7th member. |
| Anonymous #114589 1 year ago |
Replace Cheerilee with Berry Punch, and I'm down with it. |
| your_waifu #114590 1 year ago |
i would argue carrot top before cloud kicker, just for the interactions.
and i have a personal preference for berry punch, but that is too much earth ponies... |
| your_waifu #114594 1 year ago |
^anon that ninja'd me is yes |
| Anonymous #114646 1 year ago |
If keeping with the all female, two of each type, recurring background ponies only theme, we could have...
Lyra Bon Bon Carrot Top Derpy/Ditzy Do Colgate Cloudkicker (purple Pegasus that likes doing flips) |
| Anonymous #114697 1 year ago |
^
Agreed. Sorry Linky, no room. :( |
| Anonymous #114767 1 year ago |
One-shot pegasus Whoof,maybe? |
| Anonymous #115163 1 year ago |
>>16351 |
| Anonymous #117154 1 year ago |
Agreed with most of this. But Cheerilee a big enough character in her own right. She should be replaced with either Roseluck or Berry Punch. |
| mlp_cheerilee #142406 1 year ago |
Detention for all of you! Except Anonymous, they said nice things about me. :) ~Cheers |