
| Anonymous #284646 1 year ago |
*my plot |
| Drasvin #284683 1 year ago |
The problem was Applejack said she had to pick apples when she was already pulling a cart that was piled high with apples. |
| hombad26 #284763 1 year ago |
Have you seen how many trees she has? Just one cart barely makes a dent. |
| Ponyholic #284885 1 year ago |
She had to pick which ones to use for the party. Totally legit. |
| Anonymous #285076 1 year ago |
what about the 'construction work'? |
| Silver #285159 1 year ago |
^ They had to put up banners and junk.
Yes, Applejack was clearly being dishonest. I'm in the camp that says Applejack is Loyalty whereas Rainbow Dash is Honesty. |
| Anonymous #285288 1 year ago |
well it shows that applejack is terrible at lying, so I think her honest nature prevails |
| Ponyholic #285309 1 year ago |
I don't think they're contractually obligated to do their things every second of every day anyway. |
| Anonymous #285395 1 year ago |
She said she had to pick apples.
She didn't say when. |
| Anonymous #285542 1 year ago |
"It's gorgeous..." |
| Zhrille #285593 1 year ago |
I think the obvious point here is ponies cant 'pick' apples unless they bit them off or something. Applejack should have said buck in order to truely fool pinkie... |
| elementofchaos7 #285599 1 year ago |
Personally, I think AJ will lie if it's for a good reason, i.e. if it's to benefit those she's lying to.
It was to keep a surprise party a secret. If they really HAD been planning to dump Pinkie as a friend, she probably couldn't/wouldn't have lied about it. If that makes sense. XD Besides, she didn't technically lie at all in that episode. She pretty much always has to harvest apples, Rainbow was getting supplies for the party, and they were "constructing" a party. On the other hand... @Silver >Applejack is Loyalty whereas Rainbow Dash is Honesty ...that would make sense, too. |
| Anonymous #285644 1 year ago |
>AJ is Loyalty, Rainbow is Honesty
As an individual who holds both of those virtues really close to myself, I'm okay with this. It gives me more reason to like Rainbow. |
| Anonymous #285678 1 year ago |
In truth, I don't see lying to, say, throw a surprise party the same as lying to get out of trouble and from that perspective most, if not everyone, of the five ponies would have lied to Pinkie Pie.
I think it's funny people are mentioning AJ and Dash should switch elements as Applejack did claim herself to be the "loyalist of ponies" in the Applebuck Season episode but, to me, the elements lost their meaning after the pilot episodes considering they were never referenced again. |
| WispX #285850 1 year ago |
Applejack wasn't lying. She was just withholding some information about the party. Everything she said was technically true. |
| Anonymous #286020 1 year ago |
I could believe Rainbow Dash as honesty.
Twilight: You're not a laughingstock, Rarity. Rainbow Dash (loudly): She kind of is. |