
| TooOldForThisShow #424138 10 months ago |
Different mane style. |
| Mastahopo #424146 10 months ago |
^Hairstyle isnt permanent, Pinkie is also an example of it. |
| Anonymous #424147 10 months ago |
Ponies can change their mane style if they want to, and it's pretty likely she did as she grew up. |
| Epicplatypus #424149 10 months ago |
Pinkie's sisters coat seems to be based off of a blue-gray. While octavia's is based off of a grayish-tan.
Also notice how pony's many styles never change throughtout their life from foalhood to adult (in the show) Also the mane colors are FAR to different. not buyin it. |
| Doctor_Whooves #424151 10 months ago |
Well, kids are allowed to change their hair, as they grow older, lol. But her hair is a different colour, too. It could've changed, of course, or she could've changed it herself to appear even classier.
I think it'd be cool if she were Pinkie's sister, but I don't think it's gonna happen. Maybe she could be a cousin, though. |
| Anonymous #424152 10 months ago |
Q.E.D. |
| mindcannon #424159 10 months ago |
not buying it |
| NightJack #424164 10 months ago |
Pinkie's mane and coat color stays the same really the difference in the two pics is a difference in the lighting of where she is at.
Octavia and Pinkie's sister have both different mane and coat colors |
| Anonymous #424169 10 months ago |
wait is this saying octavia is pinkies sister... cause i thought the sister already had a name |
| TooOldForThisShow #424183 10 months ago |
Octavia hasn't actually been given a real name in the show as far as I can tell. |
| Epicplatypus #424186 10 months ago |
Watch
http://youtu.be/_RXVqPgbrQo?t=40s check out pinkie's colors as the shadow moves off of her face. its the lighting people, not her actual colors that change. Compare her colors to before and after the sonic rainboom in the same lighting. |
| Doctor_Whooves #424194 10 months ago |
Except that later, in the scene with Rainbow, her palette remains noticeably darker even though Rainbow is in the exact same room, same lighting, and has her normal colours.
As she got depressed, her coloring did change somewhat. |
| HeinousActsZX #424197 10 months ago |
I'm okay with cousin, but not sister. |
| Epicplatypus #424199 10 months ago |
Still wont change the fact that Her sister and octavia are two completely different colors. |
| Anonymous #424204 10 months ago |
Epicplatypus FTW. I can buy changes in saturation and value, but Octavia and (Bli|I)nkie Pie have subtly different hues. |
| Epicplatypus #424212 10 months ago |
| Anonymous #424227 10 months ago |
octavia: most discussed pony in the show. |
| Anonymous #424231 10 months ago |
Theory dismissed |
| Epicplatypus #424258 10 months ago |
![]() |
| YAUTJA #424393 10 months ago |
Its not really related to the picture but i found it amusing when I hacked 2 bots on Bioshock 2 and their random names were pinkey and blinkey |
| Doctor_Whooves #424431 10 months ago |
Would still be funny as hell if they were cousins. Octavia could be the child of an aunt of Pinkie's mom's side, maybe. An uppity branch of the family that looks down on the rock farming. |
| Anonymous #424444 10 months ago |
I like the idea of them being sisters but really its a moot point. It will never really come up in the show, like Lyra and Bon-Bon being a couple or Caramel being chronically unlucky. Great fanon ideas that will in all likely hood, never be anymore than that. (Course, they did add Derpy. *Squee!!*) |
| elementofchaos7 #424566 10 months ago |
What #424444 said. I like this theory, but I know it's never going to happen. It's the same attitude I have with shipping. My favourite ships (in pretty much every fictional work ever...) are never going to happen, but I don't rage about it.
Basically, fanon isn't Serious Business to me, it's all just for fun. @Doctor_Whooves Maybe they live in Manehatten and are friends with Aunt and Uncle Orange? |
| CommandoDude #424876 10 months ago |
Please. This isn't even close to some of the more way out there theories.
Like Photo Finish is Pinkie's sister. |
| Deceptive_Trixter #425420 10 months ago |
^But that would mean Rainbow Dash is related to Pinkie. Darn that comic for corrupting my views. |
| Martingale #425543 10 months ago |
And unless Octavia's an amnesiac you cannot explain why she does not recognise Pinkie, or at least acts like it. |
| Anonymous #426081 10 months ago |
this is serious shit people |
| WatermelonRat #427155 10 months ago |
Echoing #424444, I like the idea as fanon, but ultimately there will never be any solid confirmation either way (unless Pinkie Pie's sister shows up in a later episode). |
| HyaenusDominae #428190 10 months ago |
Oh my god! Octavia is Inkie Pie?! OH MY GOD!!! |
| Anonymous #459970 10 months ago |
@Epicplatypus:
We get it, asshole. |
| Anonymous #483955 10 months ago |
Octavia's mane is black, not grey. It could have gotten darker with age but I doubt it. |