
| Alternating #439735 10 months ago |
Futashy |
| gashunk #439745 10 months ago |
^ what he said |
| Aurora_Moon #439747 10 months ago |
....kamen rider? power ranger?
...or maybe that she's Scootaloo's mom. |
| Saufsoldat #439765 10 months ago |
Pony lingerie. |
| Anonymous #439767 10 months ago |
Fluttershy was traumatized as a filly when she was responsible for the accidental death of one or several animals.
She tries so hard to care for animals in a desperate attempt to atone for his past. |
| JamesCorck #439768 10 months ago |
Yes, it's true. This mare has a dick. |
| NightJack #439772 10 months ago |
@Aurora_Moon That would be a shock to me if Scoots doesn't know it. |
| Zarkanorf #439774 10 months ago |
The secret was she was the nigger that stole my bike. |
| Fuzzy_Logic #439778 10 months ago |
fluttershy kept her dead parents corpses in her house instead of telling anyone they died or having them properly "disposed" of and now they are mummified versions of themselves sitting in a bed in the room she doesnt let anybody go into
if anyone touches or moves them she starts to shriek and doesn't stop until they stop touching them or put them back exactly as they were |
| Xzar #439782 10 months ago |
Fluttershy is a vampire.
A pony-eating vampire pirate ninja robot from outer space. |
| Fuzzy_Logic #439783 10 months ago |
that or she has an entire wall of jars full of aborted pony fetuses because she has a disease that causes her to miscarry any children she has so she instead aborts them before she considers them large enough to be true ponies and keeps them forever
the light shines through from behind their sillhouettes floating lifelessly plus she's a whore and is pregnant like all the time |
| drpepperfan1 #439789 10 months ago |
Futashy.
My god whats wrong with me. |
| Aurora_Moon #439796 10 months ago |
NightJack, canonically...i dont think anyone's asked Scootaloo who her mom is. so, its actually plausible to a degree because of that detail. thus, she could know, and just never said anything when Fluttershy's around. and before you ask 'then why would Scootaloo still consider stayin at Fluttershy's a sleepover?'....simple. Scoots probably lives with her dad. |
| Anonymous #439798 10 months ago |
That she's Big Mac's lover, wife, and mistress/domnitrix.
And that she also has a dick she regularly abuses him with. |
| Anonymous #439801 10 months ago |
What if Scoots' dad is Big Mac?
And it turns out that all along Big Mac and Fluttershy are married, and it's just that nopony really ever notices? |
| Anonymous #439806 10 months ago |
Futashy...
Oh wait, it has already been said, and four times to be exact. Damnit Ponibooru with your love of dicks and hhhnnnnng. |
| Anonymous #439821 10 months ago |
Hey.
I only like Futashy when it's with Big Mac, and that's just because I like the idea of the most feminine filly in Ponyville dominating the most masculine colt in Ponyville. |
| MetalHooves #439834 10 months ago |
Depends on whether or not i wrote the fic. >.>; |
| NightJack #439840 10 months ago |
@Aurora_Moon I meant that I would shocked if Fluttershy is Scootaloo's but only Flutter and the father knew. |
| CranialHeartache #439888 10 months ago |
Something perverted, and/or a really big secret from the past that she's been hiding all this time in order to keep chaos from being let loose. |
| Anonymous #439909 10 months ago |
Her love for eating meat. She whips up a disguise so she can finally enter the hotdog eating contest without anypony knowing her secret |
| Anonymous #439954 10 months ago |
I don't read fanfics, ever, so your question is pointless. |
| Jiranis #439960 10 months ago |
Anon798 wins methinks. |
| Anonymous #439971 10 months ago |
FLUTTERSHY'S SECRET FLUTTERSHY'S SECRET http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rSAUxQTDf9Q |
| Aurora_Moon #439977 10 months ago |
^^^you're still assuming that would be ze case, NightJack. which was my point. |
| Draconaes #439984 10 months ago |
Her secret is that Spike has a crush on Rarity. |
| Karazor #439996 10 months ago |
She's actually a polymorphed Eldar, trying to rebuild her craftworld's infinity circuit with stolen souls. |
| Erroneous #440009 10 months ago |
That her parents were wonderbolts that spent so much time training and performing that they never paid any attention to her. She goes all flutterage on them for not spending time with her on her birthday. On their way to their next performance they are killed by a dragon. Fluttershy hates flying as a because it reminds her of them, she has a fear of dragons due to their deaths and her abandonment issues (gala outburst) come from her parent's busy schedule.
...yeah |
| NightJack #440011 10 months ago |
@Draconaes ![]() |
| Anonymous #440053 10 months ago |
Fluttershy wrote Cupcakes. |
| Anonymous #440076 10 months ago |
^been done, i think |
| Anonymous #440269 10 months ago |
Futashy is the obvious answer, so to hell with that. I'm gonna say... she's evil, and her element of kindness includes giving aid and comfort to the enemies of ponykind. |
| ColgateUnicorn #440298 10 months ago |
Pattycakes was based off a true story |
| StreakTheFox #440325 10 months ago |
PENIS |
| Anonymous #440365 10 months ago |
#440298
I DONT HABEEB IT |
| Anonymous #440541 10 months ago |
She got so shy she fucking killed someone! |
| Anonymous #440655 10 months ago |
She's secretly a murderer. |
| Anonymous #440902 10 months ago |
She's Gilda's secret lover, and the REAL reason Gilda visited Ponyville- Dash was a surprise, and Gilda felt like a jerk for not visiting her old friend for so long.
The scene with Fluttershy in the town square was Gilda making sure nopony else knew of their romance, though Fluttershy was genuine in her shock and fear as she'd never seen Gilda act like that before and was scared, and it was Fluttershy's disappointment in her that drove Gilda off. Congrats, Pinkie and Dash. You just broke the heart of some of your best friends, and you're proud of it. You monsters. |
| OptimusSleepy #440903 10 months ago |
She's off to get forcefully rodgered by various extreme sexs toys. Or she likes sugared apple slices. It could go either way, really. |
| Anonymous #440981 10 months ago |
Fluttershy never lost her voice from 'Bridle Gossip'; she can invoke either voice at will. |
| marioandsonic #440993 10 months ago |
She comes out of the closet? |
| Lancer #441186 10 months ago |
She's a lifetime member of the NRA. |
| Anonymous #441266 10 months ago |
She writes scripts for action and suspense movies. |
| Anonymous #442279 10 months ago |
She has a dick. Obviously. |
| Anonymous #442281 10 months ago |
She is Pinkamena. |
| Anonymous #442948 10 months ago |
Penis. |
| FRiNKEL #443287 10 months ago |
Fluttershy creates a successful women's clothing/lingerie business in Ponyville. |
| Anonymous #444019 10 months ago |
well ive seen alot of leather fetishes with fluttershy
so id assume it has something to do with the fact that shes a pony. and itll probally be something with a desire to eat a muffin. |
| TBTabby #444240 10 months ago |
She once killed a Diamond Dog with her bare hooves. |
| Anonymous #465927 10 months ago |
She actually has a giant robot stored under her yard called Mazinpony Z. |
| Anonymous #483288 10 months ago |
super giant wings, or dominatrix |
| Draconequus #767307 7 months ago |
Knowing this fandom, something lesbiany. |
| YouCloppinToFoalsBro #767356 7 months ago |
Expect? Mare-cock.
Want? Like, anything else, ever. |