
| Anonymous #363150 11 months ago |
Yeah, Nyx is excellent shitstorm material.
I personally don't like her, but that's because A: She's forced onto the entire fandom, and B: I haven't don't plan to read the fic. |
| Nemns #363157 11 months ago |
Who the fuck is Nyx... |
| Anonymous #363166 11 months ago |
So should I read it because its a good fanfic or because it will teach me some lessons about what not to do when writing OC characters? |
| Anonymous #363205 11 months ago |
Read it, just don't turn off your imagination and make adjustments as you do.
It's like watching anime. A bit of liberal interpretation makes a short story go a long way. |
| santan #363211 11 months ago |
nyx is an emo fuck in that story yeah i read it wanna fight about it!? |
| Anonymous #363216 11 months ago |
Nyx is the best OC pony ever, and should be in the show. |
| Anonymous #363257 11 months ago |
It feels good to turn my nose up at OC ponies, because it makes me feel bourgeois. |
| Erroneous #363296 11 months ago |
Nyx is decent. She lacks a definitive personality because she has no memories/experieces, as a result of being created by a cult's spell. This leads to a lot of people believing her to be a Mary Sue, but its one of the first times that its justified.
Also before we get in an argument about "nature vs nurture," please remember that that is actually the entire theme of the story XD |
| Pegasi #363311 11 months ago |
Yeah, Nyx is an excellent to create drama, that even leashes out to death threads.
It's almost like a shitfight between me and Kooner. I'm almost done reading Past Sins, It's getting really epic after Chapter 8, imo. |
| Kooner #363316 11 months ago |
Yea i agree with you Pegasi ( am not here to fight , i just agree with you).
Lets just leave this whole fight leave between you and me. |
| Anonymous #363322 11 months ago |
Nyx was largely rewritten some time ago, now she is really well fleshed out and personified. Haters, re-read the fic. I personally really like this new version of Nyxie :) |
| Anonymous #363325 11 months ago |
oc? SEND IT TO THE MOON |
| Pegasi #363326 11 months ago |
^I never read the old.
Facts: -Nyx isn't a sue, she just has been created without memories of her own. -Marry-sue char's aren't automatically bad. @#363316 Well it was you, who decided to comment on my behavior. To the anon who is posting futa shit by megasweet: L3arn 2 tag, I am ruinning low on eye-bleach and amnesia-portion! |
| Kooner #363334 11 months ago |
#363326 - Well you are right , still you take this stuff way to serious , this is the internet you need to expect these thing.
Anyway lets just bury the war axe between you and me ... and start to get along. |
| Anonymous #363377 11 months ago |
no oc should ever be on the show. |
| Anonymous #363498 11 months ago |
All "OCs" (and they shouldn't be called "OCs" since you basing them from an existing world) are pathetic and lame. They're beginning to infiltrate the fandom and must be stopped at all costs. |
| Pegasi #363528 11 months ago |
^
1. Nyx is not based on a real person. 2. You are stupid 3. People are YOU are the true decline of this fandom |
| Anonymous #363585 11 months ago |
I still hate Nyx. I still say it's a sue. |
| Anonymous #363599 11 months ago |
inb4 shitstorm |
| TacoDash #363620 11 months ago |
^a little late lol |
| marioandsonic #363734 11 months ago |
Pretty much, lol |
| Anonymous #363830 11 months ago |
Pegasi: Nyx is shit. The very fact that you responded to this post makes the butthurt even more delicious.
Don't ever change. |
| Anonymous #363832 11 months ago |
I read the rewrite, it's not THAT bad. I just don't like the derailing of some of the characters.
I guess you could say Nyx is a Black Hole Sue. That kinda of Sue is usually defined by it's ability to make the plot and all characters revolve around her, though in this case it's largely justified, given what she is. Of course, in a show with no real overarching plot (yet, hopefully), does she really count as one? Any tropers who can correct me on this? |
| seapony #364396 11 months ago |
Someone please make a troll Nyx. |
| cyberblade507 #364470 11 months ago |
@Everyone Is it funny, sad, predictable, or tragically ironic that the picture brought about the exact scenario it depicts? |
| Kanrabat #365045 11 months ago |
The more popular something is, the more vocal the haters will be. That's a fact that apply to everything.
[IMG]http://i141.photobucket.com/albums/r76/Kanrabat/Fasntning-1.png[/IMG] |
| Anonymous #476001 10 months ago |
@Pegasi: >He thinks that the fandom is in a decline
Yes, because shutouts and elitist bullshit totally add to a harmonious fandom. |
| Anonymous #1105262 4 months ago |
Fuck Nyx |
| Anonymous #1487778 6 days ago |
Nyx is just adorable. She has her flaws as a characters, she's definitely not god-like so the idea of her being a Sue is very slim.
Of course, people have distorted the meaning of a Mary Sue a long time ago. Nowadays, they just say an OC is a Mary Sue because they don't like said OC. And as far as I know, Nyx is nowhere near having no flaws. So yeah, haters gonna hate! :P |