
| Wrongness #130904 1 year ago |
I was wondering about that I was like "damn Twilight work on your retention." |
| Anonymous #130980 1 year ago |
Yeah, that was a bit odd. The other ponies had no idea, but Twilight? Plus she's not socially adept enough to lie.
On the other hoof? She'd been through a lot and it was a long night. A bit of trivia? Rewatching the scene this is the order the ponies rise from their curtsey. Twilight (a half-measure after rushing to hug Her Momjesty), Rarity and Dash are tied for second, then Applejack, Pinkie Pie and finally Fluttershy. |
| Roboshi #130993 1 year ago |
this was the episode that showed me that Twilight and Rainbow dash are the only 2 with cutie marks that isn't a repeated pattern.
Pinkie-3 balloons Rarity-3 gems Applejack-3 apples Fluttershy-3 Butterflies |
| Anonymous #131111 1 year ago |
She might've been shocked because it turns out the legend was true.
I mean, it was right about the Nightmare Moon part but the event was still pretty shocking, so finding out that Celestia truly was Luna's sister would be a surprise. I mean heck Celestia had sent her to Ponyville instead of believing her when she'd first gone to Celestia about it, she might've mostly been surprised that this confirmed Celestia knew what was going on all along. |
| Anonymous #131913 1 year ago |
Well, in fairness, no one said that the two sisters were Celestia and Luna and the book didn't say that the sister who banished NMM to the moon was Celestia either.. |
| Dignity #132359 1 year ago |
But it -did- say that she raised the sun every morning. That -really- should have tipped her off. |
| Anonymous #132371 1 year ago |
Maybe Twilight just didn't know that Celestia really is this old, so she assumed that NMM's sister mentioned in the book was not Celestia but some sort of her predecessor, her shock could be more like "Wow, so it was Celestia who did this 1000 years ago" |
| Anonymous #132832 1 year ago |
^That's what I assumed. |