
| HeinousActsZX #494578 10 months ago |
Something my friend and I were talking about. I would personally prefer Discord because I think he's a great villain and I really loved John de Lancie's voice-acting. I Don't really see what Luna would add when we've already got Celestia as the ruler. If we're lucky though, we'll get both. |
| Geldon #494580 10 months ago |
Just in case you don't know this, Luna's return is already confirmed for season 2. |
| juli7 #494581 10 months ago |
NEEDS MORE LUUUUUUUUUUNA |
| hombad26 #494583 10 months ago |
Discord easily |
| HeinousActsZX #494589 10 months ago |
@Geldon I know. It's just a "What if?" type deal. |
| Anonymous #494594 10 months ago |
Discord, hands down. |
| Delicioussharkat #494596 10 months ago |
doscird |
| Anonymous #494598 10 months ago |
I choose Luna. |
| Anonymous #494601 10 months ago |
Luna. |
| TheXIIILightning #494602 10 months ago |
My choices
1. Discord 2. Luna 3. Trixie 4. Tom 5. Zecora 6. Madame LeFlour |
| BlastingGravy #494607 10 months ago |
I like both characters equally, which is why I have to answer Luna. If you use Discord again so soon, he'll become stale. Luna on the other hand, has been waiting an entire season for some much needed character development. |
| Anonymous #494608 10 months ago |
For the Discordant Anarchy!
Or empire... He does sort of rule after all and that counts as a government... For the Discordant Empire! |
| AdrianBrony #494618 10 months ago |
I woula actually go with discord for one reason: discord is "complete" in a way. his character has been examined, he's had his impact, we all know about him, and he has been gioven a conclusive end.
luna, on the other hand, has not had any characterization, she has no conclusive end, and her further absence will not have been explained satisfyingly like discord has. discord was awesome but he's had his time. I would always prefer examining a new character rather than rehash an old villain. |
| Anonymous #494619 10 months ago |
I'd have to see how Luna on the show would go before deciding.
And Luna as Nightmare Moon doesn't count. |
| Anonymous #494620 10 months ago |
I suppose...
Discord... Because he can't disappoint us. |
| herooftime1000 #494623 10 months ago |
Luna, hands down. We know the characterization of Discord and I can easily see him coming back at Season 3. Luna needs to now be introduced with a personality outside of saying a few lines. I also would like to hear her excuse for being absent all this time. |
| AdrianBrony #494625 10 months ago |
#494618
fuck. I mean I would actually go with LUNA not discord. |
| AdrianBrony #494628 10 months ago |
#494620
if the show makes decisions based on not disappointing us, it would stagnate pretty quick. |
| Geldon #494646 10 months ago |
This poll is rigged. And I'll tell you why: We've seen Discord and he was awesome, but we have no idea how Luna will be, really. |
| Mastahopo #494652 10 months ago |
Discord, he was too great to be defeated in 5 minutes, or less...
Luna already will appear. |
| Big_Hackint0sh #494662 10 months ago |
Still Luna.
While Discord was better than expected I still have hopes that Luna will be well and truly odd. Compound the foibles of royalty with millennial banishment and an episode of power-driven madness... Well, okay, the writers can't do much there. It would negate the idea that if Celestia forgives you, then that's it, you're all better now. And sisters are supposed to love each other, not give into envy (and if they do they learn their lesson by the end of the episode). Discord didn't have any such restriction. I'm just foolishly holding out hope that they'll surprise me. |
| Anonymous #494664 10 months ago |
LUNAAAAAA |
| Anonymous #494672 10 months ago |
Luna, because really there's only so many plots you could do with discord, while Luna is full of potential.
Plus it would cheapen the method of his imprisonment if he managed to break out on a time-scale so that he could participate in this, or really any future, season. |
| BlastingGravy #494674 10 months ago |
Well said, Adrian. As much as I like the fanon, I have no qualms with the show wrecking it. It's not like we can't rebuild. |
| Anonymous #494682 10 months ago |
I'd say... Discord. |
| Anonymous #494698 10 months ago |
Shouldn't you mean season 3? One is already going to appear and the other one already did. |
| AdrianBrony #494701 10 months ago |
#494674
I actually think this fandom LIKES having their fanon wrecked. Cutie mark chronicles pretty much lined up fanon and executed them, yet it's one of the most loved episodes. |
| cthulhlu #494703 10 months ago |
DONT MAKE ME CHOOSE, I LOVE THEM TOO MUCH!! |
| Kein #494725 10 months ago |
You were trolled so successfully guys, haha:
|
| HeinousActsZX #494742 10 months ago |
@Kein Thanks for ruining what was a civil discussion. |
| Eriko #494749 10 months ago |
LUNA. |
| geacu #494773 10 months ago |
luna,although i gotta say discord is the grandest troll iv ever seen on tv |
| NormandyCommand #494776 10 months ago |
Needs more Luna |
| Hsere #494795 10 months ago |
I'll agree with Adrian & co. and go with Luna, just because we've already gotten a pretty sizeable (and awesome) dose of Discord. |
| Anonymous #494842 10 months ago |
Tom must do a epic comeback somewhere in season 2. |
| Ichijoe #494860 10 months ago |
I much as I love Nightmare Moon, and had been a fan of this "New Lunar Republic" thingy from S01.
I'm gonna have to turn 'round and say a BIG F YOU to Luna. If anypony is to make a reappearance it had best be DisQord. Barring that, Flutterbitch, and yeah S02E02 finally sold it Fluterbitch KILLS PINKIE Ponystats as of 24.09.11: Fluttershy/bitch Pinky Pie New Rainbow Dash (i.e. Spike) Rainbow Dash Rarity Applejack And Twilight can go read a Book.... |
| Ichijoe #494866 10 months ago |
For the DisQord Continuum
Besides with Discord come Chocolate Rain... CHOCOLATE RAIN!!! |
| Anonymous #494869 10 months ago |
Luna. Discord is the most villainous dick-hound in all of Equestria. Because of him I wanted to punch Fluttershy in the face in episode 2.
I do NOT like Discord. |
| thatguy #494970 10 months ago |
I would be quite satisfied if Luna never returned so... |
| YenaMuffin #495050 10 months ago |
I want Nightmare Moon back :( |
| Anonymous #495189 10 months ago |
I want Discord back. He's the best thing to happen to MLP since Lauren Faust. |
| Anonymous #495636 10 months ago |
Discord definitely. second best character only to Pinkie |
| Anonymous #495642 10 months ago |
Discord, of course... |
| Anonymous #495711 10 months ago |
#494869 I agree with this. Though I'd never punch Fluttershy. Discord would be on the receiving end of mine. |
| John #495713 10 months ago |
I would choose Discord... but I want to hear cry of disappointed Luna fanboys when she will appear and be nothing like they expected! I can't wait. |
| Kanashi1kage #495869 10 months ago |
I await Luna's show of what is her character, but even I have to admit Discord is a safer bet. He's established himself as an awesome villain and an entertaining personality.
Luna is unpredictable. Sure their is the chance she could blow Discord away in debut and character, but its more likely what with all the fanon out there that she will dissapoint or just have a whole lot of "meh". |
| Anonymous #495870 10 months ago |
luna..... she can fit in as a celesita type character but if discord was a great villain but he could only work as a 1 time villain. if he came back every other week to fuck things up and got defeated he would be much less badass. |
| d715 #496143 10 months ago |
Luna if only because I want to see what she's like canon wise |
| Anonymous #496210 10 months ago |
Discord. The only reason anybody gives a shit about Luna is waifu value. |
| jionunez #496517 10 months ago |
BOTH |
| -flood- #496645 10 months ago |
CURRENT VOTES:
Discord - 19 Luna - 17 Both - 1 -.- |
| Vicron #496752 10 months ago |
I can't decide! I still say Discord probably taught Celestia her entire troll arsenal. But Luna is so adorable. Adorable, troll, adorable, troll, adorable, troll, trolldorable. I want both!!! |
| Lancer #496858 10 months ago |
Luna is a given. She was healed in season 1 and has taken her place as co-ruler of Equestria. Discord is a cheap one-shot "Mary-Sue" villain suitable for a first-episode but not as a regular character. |
| Anonymous #497274 10 months ago |
Discord. He was SO AWESOME, and luna had like two lines. Easy choice. |
| Anonymous #499267 10 months ago |
Screwball |
| Failflank #499705 10 months ago |
FFFFFFFFFFUUUUUUUUUUU!!! |
| Anonymous #500192 10 months ago |
Can't it be both? |
| YoyoTripleThree #500558 10 months ago |
Damn it! What kind of sick bastard forces me to make a choice! Discord is awesome! But Luna is Woona! I can't choose! |
| Anonymous #550699 9 months ago |
Discord!!! |
| Kanashi1kage #550749 9 months ago |
WTF is a mary sue villain? We can't have a villain show off how badass and above the previous villains they are without them being a Sue now?
Oh and if I had to choose. Discord. Just to be safe. Discord was a hoot. Luna was 2 lines. Ultimately, I want both because I can't deny being curious on how Luna will be. |
| Anonymous #564380 9 months ago |
Discord, mainly because I just love his voice! |
| Anonymous #564392 9 months ago |
Discord, I mean have you heard his voice!? |
| Anonymous #688083 8 months ago |
Luna but possessed by Discord. Would not that be amazing? |