
| Nomeg_Stylus #159715 1 year ago |
I can never see Twilight as anything but black, now. |
| feather #159720 1 year ago |
inorite? |
| Anonymous #159721 1 year ago |
What's with all the black Twilights? If she was supposed to be black, she would be zebra like Zecora. |
| Anonymous #159724 1 year ago |
She does have a darker pelt (fur?) than the others so why not? |
| Anonymous #159734 1 year ago |
Mrs. Faust herself stated long ago that color of the coat can't be indicator of race in the world where ponie can be green, pink, grey, yellow etc. |
| Obscure #159745 1 year ago |
I accept an asian Twilight due to her studiousness and my racism. |
| Anonymous #159747 1 year ago |
she's too smart to be black. YEAH! i went there! whatcha gonna do!? |
| feather #159756 1 year ago |
no more then being a zebra makes Zecora black :P
human twilight is black because human twilight is black, brah |
| Tibberly #159759 1 year ago |
Black skin goes nicely with her purple hair *shrug* Other than that, I'd say she looks nice as any race :D |
| flashfox466 #159763 1 year ago |
@Obscure I've always seen Fluttershy has the asian one. She'd fit in quite well in Japanese society.
Non-confrontational, doesn't step too far out of her bounds. The whole senpai system would probably leave her a wreck, but... yeah. Twilight's pretty cute as a black girl. She doesn't act like a black girl or talk like a black girl, but then again, not all black girls act like the stereotypes. |
| Anonymous #159769 1 year ago |
With her hair as straight as it is, I thought she might be Indian. |
| Anonymous #159771 1 year ago |
judging by the eyes in this pic she is clearly JAPANESE. |
| Anonymous #159774 1 year ago |
But black people have very distinctive voices and Twilight doesn't sound like them at all... |
| Yeoseo #159780 1 year ago |
She could also be either Indian or always-outside-Thai.
Or, yeah, black. |
| Zarkanorf #159791 1 year ago |
You know what Twilight is?
American. Now stop arguing. |
| Anonymous #159792 1 year ago |
^you mean equestrian |
| Anonymous #159793 1 year ago |
no wait. youre trolling. dammit |
| Anonymous #159795 1 year ago |
^^Fuck yo america and yo God. I'd take Equestria and Celestia every day. |
| Eden #159810 1 year ago |
I like dark skinned Twilight, but the face just reminds me too much of Shinji Ikari or some other generically faced anime character. |
| feather #159819 1 year ago |
^ the pic I recolored is a generic anime version, so yea. |
| Anonymous #159866 1 year ago |
She's purple, you eugenicist fascists.
PURPLE POWER!! *hoofraise* |
| Skipta #160096 1 year ago |
@Tibberly: Really? I think they don't work together at all. Purple+blue and Brown/black colour-schemes look horrid to me when stuck together. Although here she looks more Middle-Eastern with such a muted shade (still doesn't really work colour-wise, though). Of course this is an edit to impose their own view of Twi, that is not how the artist coloured her. I have that pic uploaded from earlier.
And to note: >Mrs. Faust herself stated long ago that color of the coat can't be indicator of race >If she was supposed to be black, she would be zebra like Zecora. You're just wrong about her being black and that's not "racist" (You can't just scream that and magically be correct). It's as dumb as that idiot who kept criticizing the show for showing "White Power" as a positive because Celestia has a white-ish coat and the Guard Ponies were darker. >She doesn't act like a black girl or talk like a black girl, but then again, not all black girls act like the stereotypes. So essentially "We have nothing that indicates it by her behaviour, voice or character. We have confirmation that having a darker coat-colour has absolutely no relevance and there's clearly a group already on the show representing black people (Zebras).... But screw that, we'll keep pretending she is anyway!". I also don't see how having an accent that is influenced by the group around you is "stereotypical" in a bad way. I'm Swedish, so obviously I'll speak English with an accent and it isn't racist for you to point out that it's a noticeable difference. Nor is it for us to point it out in people from Gotland, Skåne and what-have-you. :) |
| Skipta #160100 1 year ago |
To clarify to Tibbs, only that first bit before the "And to note:" was directed at her. :) |
| Anonymous #160114 1 year ago |
I've always thought of her as maybe tanned since Canterlot is sunny (because Celestia is there!) |
| WORST_PONY_EVER #160335 1 year ago |
I always assumed that she was Indian, primarily because Yamino's humanisations explicitly made her so. =| |
| Kohdok #160347 1 year ago |
I still vote Asian, due to her almond eyes, Hime-cut and the fact that she's a grade-A honor student. |
| Skipta #160416 1 year ago |
Yeah, of the Subcontinent (to include Pakistanis & Co), Asian, Middle-Eastern, Hispanic and all that stuff can all work pretty well. I don't care if she's white or not, that'd be silly. I just find the Colour coordination to be very poor in most cases and that it goes directly against the actual show. Wouldn't make her native American either, since they also have a corollary (I do find the PC term for it a bit annoying, though, just because english isn't smart enough to tell them apart. In Swedish it's Indianer for Nat-Am. and Indier for Indian-Indians. One word is superior to a whole phrase. :| ). |
| Anonymous #160638 1 year ago |
You know Twilight, there is here some stupid discussion which skin colour you would have if you were human, but I can't concentrate on it it because you have such a small skirt.
Please do this only when you want horny bronies. For the rest of the time, use some less sexy clothes. We love you as you are. |
| Anonymous #160969 1 year ago |
I can't support schoolgirl Twilight. She's a college student. |
| D_Pony #164380 1 year ago |
Personaly i see Twi as the youngest of the group (or maybe second to dash... but still close)
and i personally see her as a High School Senior |
| D_Pony #164393 1 year ago |
As for the Skin color... honestly i think is deppresing the ammount of discussion it causes, seriously.
In my opinion, it should only be considered as "Does she look good on it?" if the answer is yes, then what's the problem?, if not, well just try with a darker/ligther tone or mabye change her clothes i've seen some pics of dark Skined RD and Rarity, and they also seem good on some of them, so i just save them, mark them in my favorites, the ones that not simply ignore them and continue with my life lurking for more pictures of ponies also remember bronies LOVE AND TOLERANCE accept her on any form she comes |
| Anonymous #167404 1 year ago |
Twilight acts like the oldest a lot though. |
| Anonymous #168406 1 year ago |
It's weird. Human Twilight only works for me as a brown girl -- but any shade of brown seems to work. |
| D_Pony #171836 1 year ago |
^^ I Atribute that to the fact that she Studies on Celestia's School for Gifted Unicorns, where probably most Pony Aristocrats send their sons/daugthers, so probably they may also teach them proper behavior and modals, as well as leadership skills, all of wich will translate into a "Mature Personallity" Aura around the character...
althoug i see AJ and rarity as more mature that twilight,thought |
| Anonymous #268937 1 year ago |
she's a latina
...boy that makes her even hotter! |
| Anonymous #298679 1 year ago |
Twilight isnt black. She's purple. Duh. |