Blotter updated: 06/17/12Show/Hide Show All

Image

Tag History
(edit info)
Rating

Prev | Index | Next

Comments

Anonymous
#408479
11 months ago
Watching people rage over a popular fanfic is quite funny. For the record, Past Sins is better than 99% of all the other fanfics out there. You don't like it, don't read it.
Anonymous
#408487
11 months ago
If that's the case, I'm glad I don't read fanfics.
No rage, no hate.
Some folks just don't like artificial sweetener to mingle with their sugar.
Anonymous
#408491
11 months ago
>a generic Suefic is better than 99% of all fanfics
>not exactly something to be proud of
Come back to me when a fanfic is better than John Dies at the End or World War Z or something and then we'll talk.
The point of the post is now, you don't HAVE to read it, and you can still know what the fuss is about. Everyone wins!
Anonymous
#408501
11 months ago
The abridged needs to be abridged..
Oh-noes
#408503
11 months ago
Thanks anon, now I don't need to read the rest.
It started of so nicely...and then it turned so suehorror.

Funfact, this fic was a tribute to a crossover fic of Alan Wake, which I highly recommend 8I
d715
#408572
11 months ago
Also Luna thourghout the whole fic is really just Celestia- night time edition
your_waifu
#408627
11 months ago
i haven't read it but it sounds like an admirable effort in the least
d715
#408656
11 months ago
^ It was but it went to shit by chapter 10 wend the cult took over. its been reedited (twice) but they didn't fix the problems the story has. Nyx is still a sue, everyone's still stupid ect and the whole theme of the story is broken because the only reason why the Cult was formed and evil is because what's left of Nightmare Moon is like a virus of evil, which is the same stuff used to make Nyx.
Anonymous
#408691
11 months ago
Needed moar "THEN THEY ALL FUCKED".
Draconaes
#408926
11 months ago
Well that last post there has some inaccuracies, and what a lot of what is left is pure opinion. The previous posts are fairly accurate, despite some simplifications.

In the interest of being factually accurate I'll correct some of that last post.
Twilight is retarded: pure opinion, she does exhibit a quick temper and jumps to conclusions a few times, she is somewhat illogical. Of course, if you accept the premise of seeing Nyx as her daughter, this makes more sense.
RD is most wisest character: pure opinion. I am assuming this refers to the debate over Nyx's punishment. What side you take on this is entirely dependent on your fundamental stances on vengeance, punishment, and rehabilitation. So if you prefer punishment to rehabilitation, yeah, this statement may be accurate. I don't, so yeah. Pure opinion.
No idea what the third line is trying to say. But yeah Celestia apologizes to Twilight for the pain she put her through. Beyond that it was HER actions that brought Nyx to the cult anyway, so showing a little remorse for that and for hurting her favorite student, not so out of character in my opinion.
Twilight didn't find it hard to forgive Celestia. The complete opposite, really: she found it too easy. She stated she wasn't sure that she really wanted to, but she did.
The rest is accurate even if I disagree with the implications behind them.

Sorry for the wall of text. I dislike inaccurate information. I suppose upon analysis, Nyx does have sue characteristics, but who gives a damn about that? It was an enjoyable read for me, that's all I care about.
Anonymous
#409004
11 months ago
Even though I personally enjoyed it (yes, I'm retarded and have shit taste in shit) I'm so glad that it is over. And, what's more, in a few weeks people will be to tangled up in the season 2 they won't remember this shitstorm of a fanfic and an OC.
Anonymous
#409495
11 months ago
It sounds like this fic outran itself. It seems like it kinda dragged on longer than it needed to or was originally intended to. I mean, it seems well written, but by the end it seems to be trying to hold on to a thunderous beginning with overdone cliches in place of good ideas.

Of course, I should probably read it before making that judgement, buuut... I'm lazy.

Time to work on my own overdone too-long story!
Anonymous
#409613
11 months ago
i read all the story and is epic

and haters gonna hate

that's all im gonna said
Fanloser
#411673
11 months ago
@ If that's all you care about, then why the fuck are you complaining? And if it's because, "it's inaccurate informations," here's a news flash for ya fanboy/girl, it isn't. It's actually highly accurate.
Fanloser
#411682
11 months ago
^@Draconaes
hernycwo
#411694
11 months ago
Thanks anon, I was too lazy to read it.
Anonymous
#1104914
4 months ago
Fuck Nyx