
| ThePowerofANON #461142 10 months ago |
Umm... I'll go with Nyx. That Pinkie filly image makes me think she's a G3 pony instead. |
| Anonymous #461147 10 months ago |
I'll go with the pink thing. It looks stupid but it's still better than a Mary Sue. |
| Anonymous #461150 10 months ago |
Pinkie Baby is fail.
Nyx Filly looks cute (And I don't have read the fanfic, so whatever) |
| Marfikent #461151 10 months ago |
A strange game.
The only winning move is not to play. |
| zanzibar #461154 10 months ago |
Id choose Nyx, even if she really is Mary Sue, still better than a soul stealing abomination borne in the deepest pit of human intellectual depravity.
Id read the fanfic and find out, but its just not my kind of story *shrugs* |
| Lance #461156 10 months ago |
I agree w/ANON. It just kinda... Puts me off...
Besides, we gotta get the Nyxlove in here before people come in bringing in the hate. |
| NightJack #461159 10 months ago |
I choose the logo, ha you didn't think of that did you. |
| Rasrap_Smurf #461167 10 months ago |
Neither are canon in g4 so I chose either |
| Anonymous #461179 10 months ago |
NYX
NYX I CHOOSE NYX |
| JohnFreepony #461185 10 months ago |
I'll take the Choose One sign. |
| G1rules #461188 10 months ago |
I choose you Pinkie Pie! |
| WhiteLycan #461189 10 months ago |
Meh. Go with Nyx. What's the worst that could happen...? *suddenly thunderclap* |
| NightJack #461198 10 months ago |
^ You fool! Don't you to never say that! |
| NightJack #461202 10 months ago |
*ever |
| -flood- #461204 10 months ago |
I choose Nyx.
to go die in a fire. What now? |
| Anonymous #461209 10 months ago |
Pikachu! I choose you! |
| thatguy #461218 10 months ago |
no |
| sargesprinkles #461236 10 months ago |
pinkie |
| Anonymous #461270 10 months ago |
I'll choose nix.
If you get it you'll get all my internets of this week. |
| Turin_Aramaia #461309 10 months ago |
Real cute, Anon270.
"Nix" means "nothing" |
| marioandsonic #461312 10 months ago |
I pick Nyx. At least she doesn't remind me of G3.5...*shudder* |
| Anonymous #461327 10 months ago |
Nyx!
Please excuse me.... i gotta scratch out my right eye... |
| Anonymous #461329 10 months ago |
...Both >_> |
| Zarkanorf #461355 10 months ago |
How about, "No"? |
| Pegasi #461363 10 months ago |
Nyx, because Past Sins is awesome.
COME THE FUCK AT ME! |
| zralf #461371 10 months ago |
if i have to , i choose nyx, mostly because i haven't read the fanfic. |
| Anonymous #461490 10 months ago |
Choose to live? The pink abomination. A million times the pink abomination. If the pink abomination ate my family and kicked me in the nuts- repeatedly, I'd still choose the pink abomination. |
| Kein #461547 10 months ago |
> past sins
> awesome choose one xD |
| Anonymous #461579 10 months ago |
Pinkie Pie., because it's Pinkie Pie and it's a baby so I can raise her to become the G4 Pinkie Pie. |
| Ezhik #461652 10 months ago |
Nyx |
| daishizen #461704 10 months ago |
Nyx or brain damage? I pick Nyx. |
| Anonymous #461780 10 months ago |
Hmmm...OC character that is some kind of resurected form of Nightmare Moon that is from a fanfic series that at worst was a decent read (I thought it was pretty good, myself, not OMG godlike spetacular, but not the worst thing I've ever read), or a horrifying Pinkie Pie that looks like G3.5 all over again.
I'll take the OC. She may be somewhat of a mary sue, but she's CERTAINLY not that gay MLP crap. G3.5 MLP crap, I mean, since G4 Pinkie is awesome. |
| Anonymous #461785 10 months ago |
Hmm...I'd ideally pick Nyx because she'd be more developed mentally. That way, I could play with her, take her to events, such and such.
With Baby Pinkie, I would have to spend more extensive time with her. If raising a baby is anything like that high school health class, then I'd need to find somepony to help me out, because I'd have to balance my occupation with the baby's needs. On the other end, it would be selfish of me to simply take the older one out of a desire for more spare time, so the moral option would be to take Baby Pinkie. Then again, Baby Pinkie would probably drive me insane. As she grew older, she'd need constant attention with each and every party she'd throw. She'd talk a lot, so I'd need to listen in to each one of her rambling speeches. Failure to do so would lead to her becoming depressed, and as she grew older, she may become a nihilist and evolve into the Cupcakes persona. Therefore, I'd need to keep her happy all the time. On the other end, it would be really comforting to help her out through tough moments, like any depressing material in her literature classes. However, if one were to ask me which one I thought would be better as a character, I'd have to say Nyx. Young horses do not look like human infants. |
| Elysiaa #461791 10 months ago |
I'll chose g3ish pinkie pie... that's how much I hate OCs |
| Anonymous #461841 10 months ago |
Nyx may live. DEATH TO THE MUTANT. |
| Anonymous #461844 10 months ago |
Definitely that Pinkie Pie. As bad as it is, it's still better than Nyx by a long shot. |
| JamesCorck #462128 10 months ago |
Nyx, definitely.
That comic strip somepony made a few days ago where Lauren Faust and Doctor Doom beat the fuck out of Nyx has made me pity and like the character. Well done guys :) |
| Anonymous #462214 10 months ago |
No babies, no children. just Pony's! |
| Anonymous #462247 10 months ago |
Definately Nyx. |
| Anonymous #462273 10 months ago |
I'll choose a nuke. One weapon; gets them both. |
| Anonymous #462445 10 months ago |
The pink one. Hands down. |
| Anonymous #462552 10 months ago |
Let's see...
I'm not really into fanfics(just don't have any real interest in there one way or the other) and I forced myself to watch Twinkle Wish Adventure against my better judgement so... I choose Nyx. While the Baby Pinkie Pie is G4, it still reminds me too much of G3.5 and it's videos. |
| Anonymous #462568 10 months ago |
I'd compare this to Sophie's choice, but Sophie had it too easy compared to this. |
| Some_Anon #462604 10 months ago |
Just what the fuck is that Pinkamena Diane Pie is supposed to be? |
| Anonymous #462936 10 months ago |
Nyx all the way. |
| KiyoshiKouzen #463152 10 months ago |
Ill read the damn fic just to see what's all the fuss is about. I mean honestly, One FanFic can start a shitstorm of hate and lov-err um less hate. |
| Anonymous #463242 10 months ago |
Left. |
| Anonymous #463308 10 months ago |
Ok, one is chosen. Now what? |
| Anonymous #463487 10 months ago |
Nyx! |
| Anonymous #464004 10 months ago |
Nyx FTW!! |
| MrNitpick #464009 10 months ago |
Nyx, yeah. No doubt there either. |
| Kiki_Foxkitty #464188 10 months ago |
Nyx! |
| Anonymous #464897 10 months ago |
Nyx. |
| Anonymous #465474 10 months ago |
nyx, because id rather beat up a sue then i would beat up a 3rd gen.... |
| Bronyboy #467267 10 months ago |
Bronyboy shall pick the tiny alicorn filly mister computer. |
| Vree #467316 10 months ago |
You wrote "one" with only one N. |
| TheHighway #507824 10 months ago |
I dislike Nyx a lot, but that Pinkie Pie is so creepy I have to choose Nyx. |
| Anonymous #523473 9 months ago |
Why can I only choose one? Why can't there be a Newborn Cuties doll of Baby Nightmare Moon? |
| Anonymous #582556 9 months ago |
Nyx I choose you! *throws pokeball* |
| Anonymous #582566 9 months ago |
That's as easy as anything.
Nyx is fucking ignorable, being not part of the property, but the overhyped OC of a stuttering, overhyped, questionably constructed fanfic. |
| Anonymous #587962 9 months ago |
...I'll choose the Pinkie Pie baby. |
| Anonymous #588006 9 months ago |
Is suicide by self-immolation an option? |
| XD-385 #607697 9 months ago |
I'd take Nyx any day over.....that. She may be flawed, but then again, who isn't? |
| Anonymous #622699 8 months ago |
NYX, OF COURSE! |
| Anonymous #648773 8 months ago |
Two bullets. |
| Anonymous #707007 7 months ago |
Kill me now. |
| Unicron #712906 7 months ago |
nyx nyx nyx I chose nyx I love nyx |
| Anonymous #752805 7 months ago |
Easy choice
definite Nyx. In my version of reality there is still room for another winged unicorn. If it was a normal a pinkie Nyx does not cut it. But that Hasbro monstrosity should be destroyed and since i have read way worse fan fiction than (past sins and creeping darkness which was fair but still readable). |
| Anonymous #756945 7 months ago |
I CHOOSE NOTHING. I LOST. GOOD DAY, SIR |
| Takashi_0 #761423 7 months ago |
Duh, Nyx. |
| FishFlavoredFrenchFries #814728 6 months ago |
NYX. NYX DAMMIT NYX. |
| Anonymous #826170 6 months ago |
Nyx, definitely.
Why does everyone hate her so much anyway? |
| Anonymous #1038160 4 months ago |
Fuck Nyx |