Posted originally on the Archive_of_Our_Own at https://archiveofourown.org/
works/5860300.
  Rating:
      Explicit
  Archive Warning:
      No_Archive_Warnings_Apply, Underage
  Category:
      M/M
  Fandom:
      スタミュ:_高校星歌劇_|_Starmyu_|_High_School_Star_Musical
  Relationship:
      Hoshitani_Yuuta/Ootori_Itsuki
  Character:
      Hoshitani_Yuuta, Ootori_Itsuki, Inumine_Seishirou, Hiiragi_Tsubasa,
      Nayuki_Tooru, Kuga_Shuu, Tengenji_Kakeru, Tsukigami_Kaito
  Additional Tags:
      First_Time, Anal_Fingering, Cheesy, Cuddles
  Stats:
      Published: 2016-01-31 Words: 1727
****** Star Clover Birthday ******
by umbreonblue
Summary
     Sequel to Birthdays and Mistletoe! It's Hoshitani's birthday, and
     Team Otori is celebrating. However, Otori, his boyfriend, has
     something special in mind for today while Hoshitani proves just how
     surprising, and interesting (and cute) he can be.
Notes
     *blushing* This is my 1st time writing something like this. plz go
     easy on me.
See the end of the work for more notes
Hoshitani was entering his room when, Pop! Pop! "Happy Birthday!" In front of
him were his team mates armed with party poppers, presents and a cake.
Hoshitani blinked for a moment before smiling. "How'd you guys know?" Tsukigami
responds, "Otori-senpai told us." "How could you not tell us, yabosuke?"
Hoshitani responds, "You never asked."
They all sat round the table, and had their cake. When it was time for
presents, there was a knock and a bark at the door. "Come in, Inumine!"
Hoshitani says. Opening the door, Inumine walks in with a gift basket and
boxes. "~This is from Team Hiragi and the Kao Council~. Happy birthday,
Hoshitani!~" He sings, then he grabs a slice of cake, and goes out the door,
shutting it behind him. Smiling, Hoshitani opens his gifts.
He got tickets to a play from Tsukigami, tickets to a kabuki show from
Tengenji, some tea packets from Nayuki, and a handmade (bad) card from Kuga.
From Team Hiragi, he got coupons for the Bow-Wow House, a card, a manga, and a
handmade carving of a puppy with a bear.
From the Kao Council, he got a book on martial arts, a book on advanced origami
techniques, and new headphones. However, there was one present left. A box with
a note attached. It's from his boyfriend, Otori. 
Once Hoshitani opened the box, there was a white feather on a silver chain
coupled with an emerald along with a four-leafed clover inside. Eyes tearing
up, he tries not to cry as he smiles. Wiping away stray tears, he reads the
note. It says:
Happy Birthday! This is from me and Hiragi. Think of this as repaying you for
our birthday presents last year.
XOXO
Otori Itsuki
P.S. Meet me on the Outdoor Stage. I've got another surprise for you.
Lighting up, Hoshitani excuses himself, his team nodding in understanding and
telling him to go already. Then he starts running to the Outdoor Stage to meet
up with his boyfriend.
Once there, he sees Otori, and tackles him, his arms hugging his waist (while
discreetly taking Otori's phone). Otori grunts then pets his boyfriend's head,
smiling at his enthusiasm, "Calm down. I'm not going anywhere." "You said you
had a surprise for me?" Hoshitani says curiously, letting him go.
Laughing, Otori replies, "Yeah. Hoshitani Yuta..." He gets down on one knee and
gets a black box out of his pocket. "Will you promise to stay with me?" Opening
the box, he revealed two simple silver brand rings. Surprised and blushing,
Hoshitani says, "Did you really have to ask? Of course I'll stay!" He takes one
of the promise rings and puts it on, Otori putting on the other.
Smiling, they both grab each other's hands and start dancing. Just in time for
it to rain too. They dance like that for a while, getting wet in the process.
Eventually, they stop, just holding each other, and staring at each other's
eyes for a minute. Then, they kiss. Chuckling, Otori says, "Let's get out of
this rain. I don't want either of us to catch a cold." Nodding, Hoshitani lets
Otori lead him.
They end up in Otori's room, the door locked, kissing and grabbing at each
other, the ribbon holding Otori's hair up falling to the floor, while slowly
making their way to the bed. Their wet clothes (except their boxers) falling to
the floor.
Hoshitani managed to push Otori onto the bed, before pouncing on him. Grunting
at the weight on top of him, Otori stared, perplexed at Hoshitani, who had a
determined and lustful look in his eyes. "Ne, can we do 'it'?" Hoshitani asks
excitedly.
Blinking in surprise, Otori asks, "Right now?" "Yes, right now," Hoshitani says
impatiently. "But, what about school tomorrow?" Otori asks, trying to get out
of it. It was then that Hoshitani got his phone out as well as Otori's, and
sent an email. "There. I just emailed the guys and Hiragi-senpai. I told them
that we're skipping school tomorrow and to not to disturb us," Hoshitani
answers smiling, putting the phones aside.
Surprised, Otori was speechless for a moment before laughing. "You definitely
are interesting, Hoshitani. But," Otori sighs, "there's something I have to
tell you. I'm..." Hoshitani stops him before he can say anything else, "I
know." Otori stared in shock, "You do? But how?"
"Black feathers. I saw black feathers that day two years ago, and saw them
again when I danced with you. Black feathers always remind me of you, and only
you," Hoshitani answers, a longing and sentimental look in his eyes. Otori's
eye softened, saying in a low voice, "Really? Because white feathers and four-
leafed clovers always remind me of you." Blushing red is how Hoshitani responds
to that.
Then, Otori flips their positions, asking, "Are you sure?" Looking straight at
him, blushing and a little breathless, "Yeah." Taking this opportunity, Otori
kisses him, biting his lower lip, thrusting his tongue in as he gasps, nudging
in his cock with his knee. "Mmm," Hoshitani moaning in pleasure, kissing back,
their tongues clashing. Breaking the kiss, Hoshitani was gasping for breath.
Otori moved up, nipping his ear, then slowly moved down, kissing and biting his
neck and collarbone. Hoshitani moaning all the while, his body wracking with
pleasure.
Moving lower, Otori sucks one of his nipples while his hand plays with other.
"Ngh. Ah," Hoshitani groaning. Moving even lower, he palmed Hoshitani through
his boxers. "Ah!" Smiling, Otori pulls down the boxers, Hoshitani kicking them
off, before stroking his cock. Hoshitani moaning and bucking against his hand.
He strokes harder, his cock getting hard and slick. "Aahh! I-I'm gonna..."
Then, the pleasure stops. "Why'd you stop?" Hoshitani says pouting and panting.
Otori only smiles as he opens the nightstand, grabbing a bottle of lube and a
condom. When Hoshitani sees the items, he only blushes bright red, eyes
widening slightly in fear. Noticing this, Otori kisses his forehead in
reassurance before opening the lube, and slicking his fingers. Trying to be
brave, Hoshitani opens his legs wider, giving Otori more access, poking a
finger to his entrance, circling it before pushing it in and out slowly.
Hoshitani was just getting used to it when another finger was pushed in,
groaning in pain as they scissored and moved inside him, stretching his
muscles. Suddenly, "Ah! Mmm," they hit his prostate, sending waves of pleasure
throughout his body. Raising an eyebrow, "Hmm...here?" Otori strokes his
fingers inside, on that spot, Hoshitani arching his back, moaning and pushing
back against the fingers, "Ahh! Yes! Right there!" Otori pushes a third finger
in, stretching and thrusting deep inside, hitting that spot while preparing him
for something larger.
Withdrawing his fingers (and leaving Hoshitani feeling empty), Otori takes off
his boxers, his erection hard and dripping. Hoshitani looks, and his eyes
widen, thinking 'It's so big! It's not gonna fit!' Taking notice of Hoshitani
and guessing what he was thinking, Otori kisses him again before putting on the
condom and slicking it with lube.
Gulping, Hoshitani grabs onto the sheets underneath him, bracing himself as
Otori slowly pushes inside him. Once all the way in, he pauses, groaning,
waiting for the other to get used to it. After for what seems like forever,
Hoshitani pushes back against him, trying to get him to move, and he does.
Slowly, trying to set a steady pace. Eventually, he hits that spot, causing the
other to moan, so he keeps hitting that spot again and again.
"Ah! Hah. Harder! Faster! Deeper! Ahh!" Moaning in pleasure, Hoshitani wraps
his arms around his boyfriend's back, clawing at it, while his legs wrap around
his waist, pulling him closer. Otori complies, groaning, "You're so tight and
hot. You're squeezing around me and your walls are so soft," as he thrusts
harder, deeper, picking up the pace. "D-don't say that...Mmm...out loud! Ah!
It's...Hah...embarrassing!" Hoshitani moans out, pushing back against him,
blushing. As the pace kept getting faster, the thrusts harder, penetrating
deeper, and the pleasure getting higher, they kiss, trying to keep their moans
in.
"Ahhhh! I-I'm gonna cum! Ahhhh...!" Hoshitani screams as he cums on their
stomachs, Otori covering his mouth with his own to muffle the screaming,
groaning as he thrusts to completion, feeling the tight heat constrict him even
tighter, cumming deep inside him. Falling back against the bed, both of them
panting, Otori pulling out, and disposing the condom.
Then, he gets a box of tissues from the nightstand to clean up the mess, wiping
the other down. Hoshitani yawning with hazy eyes as he waits for Otori to
finish. Once done, Otori climbs back into bed, arms wrapping around Hoshitani,
Hoshitani snuggling into his chest and wrapping his arms around Otori's waist.
They give each other a kiss goodnight before falling asleep in each other's
arms.
The next morning, they slept in, as promised, and cuddled a lot due to
Hoshitani's insistence and puppy-eyes. Otori insisted that they take a shower
together however, Hoshitani was either too embarrassed or turned on just
thinking about it, so he refused, saying that he wasn't ready for something
like that, and that he doesn't trust him in the bathroom. Otori stared at him,
then laughs. He finds it ridiculous that while Hoshitani's not afraid to have
sex with him, he's afraid to take a shower with him. Deciding on a compromise,
they took turns taking a shower.
Eventually, they had to get dressed, so Otori put on a shirt, boxers, and sweat
pants. He picked out what Hoshitani was gonna wear though. Hoshitani ended up
with boxers, sweat pants, and an over-sized shirt, much to Otori's amusement.
"You're so cute in that," he says smiling as he attempts to take a picture on
his phone. Hoshitani just pouts at him, glaring, and slapping the phone out of
his hand before trying to ignore Otori on the bed.
Otori just laughs, and tackles Hoshitani, only to tickle him. Hoshitani starts
laughing too, pleading for him to stop, and eventually he does, leaving
Hoshitani panting on the bed. Taking this opportunity, Otori lays down next to
him, wrapping his arms around him for a second round of cuddle time. Hoshitani,
too tired and out of breath to complain, lets him. Smiling, he thinks that this
was the 'Best birthday ever.'      
End Notes
     tell me how I did? this is embarrassing enough as it is. I can't
     believe I wrote it.
Please drop_by_the_archive_and_comment to let the author know if you enjoyed
their work!