Posted originally on the Archive_of_Our_Own at https://archiveofourown.org/
works/5287646.
  Rating:
      Explicit
  Archive Warning:
      Rape/Non-Con, Underage
  Category:
      F/M
  Fandom:
      South_Park
  Relationship:
      Kenny_McCormick/Butters_Stotch, Karen_McCormick/Kenny_McCormick, Karen
      McCormic/Butters_Stotch, Butters_Stotch/Kenny_McCormick/Karen_McCormick
  Character:
      Butters_Stotch, Kenny_McCormick, Karen_McCormick
  Stats:
      Published: 2015-11-26 Words: 3692
****** Chaos Rises ******
by Kreton
Summary
     A call is made for the return of Professor Chaos. But will he be able
     to preform the terrible acts requested?
Notes
See the end of the work for notes
Butters sat in front of his computer playing an entertaining flash game he had
found, when his cell phone started to ring. Distracted by the game, he picked
up the phone and answered, “Hullo?”
A faint female voice called out from the phone. “Butters?”
“Yes, this is Butters.”
“Hi, this is Karen, Kenny's sister. I... I need to talk to you. Can you meet me
somewhere?”
Butters paused his game and paid full attention to the conversation, “Well sure
I can. Is everything all right?”
Silence was Karen's initial reaction. “I just need to talk to you. I'll explain
when I see you. Meet me down by Stark's pond as soon as you can. I'll be
waiting.” Karen hung up before he had a chance to respond.
Butters had only met Kenny's sister a handful of times. From what he knew of
her she was a shy girl that Kenny was very protective of. If she was calling
him it was probably something important. “Huh, I'd better get down there.”
It didn't take him long to get ready and make it down to the popular meeting
place. Stark's pond, probably one of the most recognizable spots in all of
South Park. People come here to play, jog, unwind, and some people come here
to...make out. It was this last reason that probably kept Butters from visiting
Stark's pond more often. He did find it to be a very relaxing and beautiful
spot. While he was thinking about how nice the scenery was he spotted Karen
standing next to the water, looking down at the small waves. The sunlight
glistened off the water, making the sight almost surreal. He slowly walked over
to her trying not to disturb her. As he got closer his footsteps gave him away
and Karen turned toward him.
“Hey, I want to talk to you about something. Care to walk with me?” Again she
didn't wait for a response, and began walking around the edge of the pond.
Butters felt he had little choice but to follow.
“So, is everything okay with Kenny?”
“Kenny? Yeah, I'm sure he's fine. But he's not really what I wanted to talk
about.”
Butters felt more confused than ever. “Wull you can talk to me about anything.”
His earnest desire to help out kept him attentive to her every word.
Karen continued walking around the pond. Watching her feet as she figured out
just what she wanted to say. “You know how people have two sides? A side that
they show to people and a secret side. A side that they keep hidden away,
because it's seen as different or wrong?”
“Yeah, I guess that can be true. Like Eric Cartman. Most of the time he's a
giant jerk who just uses other people to get what he wants. But when he's not
around a lot of other people, well...no, he's still a big fat jerk.”
Butters' failed attempt at explaining his understanding made Karen giggle. “Why
do you hang out with Cartman so much when he's so mean to you?”
“Ah, he's not that bad most of the time. People should help each other out. And
he needs more help than any other person I know.”
“I agree that he needs help, but I don't think it's the kinda help you can
give.” Karen looked over at Butters and smiled. “You really seem like a nice
guy. So, can I ask you something kinda personal?”
“Sure.”
“Why did you become Professor Chaos?”
Butters stopped in his tracks. It was a name he had not heard in a long time.
“Why do you want to talk about...him?”
Karen turned to face him. Her tone became more serious, “Because I need your
help Butters. To be more specific, I need Chaos' help.”
 
                                       2
“Are you sure we have to do this?” Butters set the bag of supplies down in
front of the storage door, and pulled out the key.
“I have to do this. I have to see him again. It's the only way I know of that
might work.”
“But what if Mysterion doesn't show up?”
“He will. He has to. He's always shown up when I was in danger.”
Butters knew that Kenny was Mysterion, but it seemed that he never told his
little sister. And if Kenny never told her then he must have had a good reason
to keep it from her. On the other hand, his own alter ego wasn't much of a
secret to anyone. “But I don't want to hurt you.”
“Don't worry. We'll make it plenty obvious that it was you that kidnapped me.
And he'll be sure to stop you far before you could do anything to hurt me.”
“Well, okay.” Butters unlocked the padlock and raised the door, reveling his
old secret lair. As the two of them walked inside he felt embarrassed by the
childish look of the place. Several cardboard boxes were spread around and made
to look like computers and other props that a villain might have. He had long
since abandoned this place, and was a little surprised that no one had ever
come to clean the place out.
“Grab the stuff. We need to get started.” Butters obeyed and brought the
supplies inside as Karen pulled the door down, enclosing the two inside. “I
think over there is a good place to handcuff me.”
“Can't I just threaten you? Do I really have chain you to the wall?”
“We have to make it as real as possible. If we don't then he might not show up.
Don't worry so much. They're my fuzzy handcuffs, so they won't hurt me. Now get
started on your costume while I start making the ransom notes.”
His old outfit didn't fit anymore so he had to make a new one. He was feeling
self-conscious about once again going with an abundance of aluminum foil. He
wondered to himself why didn't he go with a new look. He just sighed and
started creating the familiar design he knew.
As he was finishing his costume, Karen handed him a piece of paper with several
letters glued to it to keep the identity of the author anonymous. “How does
this sound?” He took the paper and read it aloud.
“I've had it with people calling me gay. I have taken Karen McCormick back to
my lair where I shall rape her to death.” Butters looked frantically to Karen,
“Rape you!? Gee wiz, we never agreed to something like that.”
“We have to do something that will make Mysterion respond. This is that
something. I thought you wanted to help me? Don't you want to help me?” She
batted her eyes and pouted at him. “Please?”
He quickly gave in, “Well if you're sure it's the only way.”
She gave him a quick punch to the shoulder. “You bet your sweet ass it is.” As
he was rubbing his shoulder she walked over to his other side and gave him a
quick peck on the cheek.
“Golly, you didn't have to do that.”
“It's the least I could do. You're really helping me out here. And if you
follow through with the plan, I might give you a real kiss.”
 
                                       3
The two had decided it would be best to launch the plan during the weekend.
Everything was set and ready to go. All that was left was for Professor Chaos
to show up and “kidnap” Karen. She sat in her room with her window open waiting
for him to burst in and make a commotion. This would let everyone know
something was wrong. And when they came to check on her, they would find one of
the many ransom notes that had been left. She didn't want to take any chances,
so she had also left notes in other places.
She sighed while staring out the window. She should have told him to show up at
a specific time, instead of 'sometime Saturday.' It was already past 11:00am,
and he might wait until dark before showing up. It was actually a good idea,
and if she had thought of it before, she would have told him to show up after
dark. This, of course, was when Mysterion was most active, and it would reduce
the chance of someone else interfering. But of course they had left the time
open. Partially because Butters didn't know when he would be done with his
chores. If they had a working phone Karen would call and tell him to wait until
tonight. But like most of the time their phone had been disconnected due to
lack of payment.
Although she didn't like the waiting, she was excited for what was about to
happen. If she got to see Mysterion she was going to do what she should have
done when she realized what he meant to her. As long as he showed up, she
wasn't going to let anything stop her. No matter how hard and awkward it might
be. She had thought long and hard about this, and she was sure this was the
best course of action.
A knock at her door brought her out of her thoughts. “(I'm going to finish off
the milk. You didn't want cereal or anything did you?)” Kenny's muffled voice
was a comforting distraction.
“No, I ate some pop-tarts earlier. But thanks for asking. Could...could you
come in for a second?”
Kenny opened her door and stood in the doorway. “(What's up?)”
“Do you have any plans today? Or are you going to be hanging around the house
all day?”
“(I'm probably going to go hang out with Stan and the gang after while.)”
“Oh, well have a good time.”
“(Do you want someone to stay with you today?)
“No, I'm okay. I was just wondering what you were going to be doing.” Karen
gave him a little smile to show that everything was fine. He just nodded his
head and closed her door as he headed back to the kitchen. She wondered if she
should have asked him to stick around to make sure someone would hear when
Professor Chaos showed up. It was probably better this way as to not arouse
suspicion. She didn't realize it at the time but her heart was racing in her
chest. Everything was working out the way she had planed.
 
                                       4
Butters was more nervous than ever putting on his costume. Why this was worse
than when he had to join Stan's dance group. Or when they made him dress up
like a girl and sneak in to a slumber party. Or when he and Kyle had to fight
an alien wizard that had put a curse on him. Well, maybe it wasn't as bad as
those times, but it's pretty bad, he thought to himself. It had been so long
since he had needed to become Professor Chaos. This was different. He wasn't
doing it to get back at those that had wronged him. He was doing it because
someone needed him. He wondered to himself, does this make me...a hero?
He put aside his introspection and started thinking about what he had to do.
Getting out of the house wasn't going to be a problem, but making it over to
Kenny's house without being seen would prove more difficult. He would have to
cross by Eric's on the way, and if he was spotted then he would be in a sticky
situation. Whatever the difficulties he had to at least try, for Karen's sake.
As he slipped on the final piece of his costume, and looked at himself in the
mirror. He felt a rush of power and confidence he had not felt in a long time.
He had forgotten the freedom that being Professor Chaos afforded. Grinning at
himself he started to laugh, as he let this feeling overtake him. A voice from
the other side of his door asked, “Are you all right honey?”
“Yeah mom. I just remembered a funny joke I heard. I'm going on to bed. Love
you.”
“I love you too, honey. Good night.” And with his iron-clad alibi established
he leapt out of his window and into the night.
The trek to Kenny's house was uneventful. What was concerning to him was that
he had no idea which window was Karen's. He quietly crept around the house
spying onto each window he came across. The most obvious was the living room,
where Kenny's brother and father were watching TV. The next window he peered
into was the master bedroom. As he approached it he caught the scent of
something he wasn't familiar with. Inside he saw Kenny's mother on the bed
smoking something out of small glass tube. He watched her for a few moments
reveling in the feeling of doing something wrong. After inhaling from the tube
she would just stair up at the ceiling. It didn't take long for Butters to move
on. The next couple of windows were dark. He was pretty sure one was a
bathroom, and the other was Kenny's room. The next window was open, he
approached it with caution, but was hopeful that it was Karen's. He peered
inside seeing the young girl lying on her bed reading a magazine. He was just
about to call out when he noticed that she was gently rubbing her crotch from
outside her pants. The magazine she was looking at seemed to be an adult
magazine. Possibly one of her brother's. She was just staring at a single page
while she touched herself. Butters kept watching wondering if he should just go
home. He didn't want to disturb her, but at the same time he wondered if she
was going to go even further. That's when a familiar feeling started overtake
him, and it filled him with dread. He had to sneeze. He quickly shoved his face
into his armpit, as he learned in school, the sound of the aluminum foil
preemptively giving him away. “Chuu...chuu!”
“Butters?”
Butters turned toward Karen, “Hey Karen. Sorry, I had to sneeze.”
“So I heard.” Karen got up from her bed and walked to the window, “Enjoy the
show?”
Butters blushed bright red. “Wull, I didn't mean to peep, but you wanted me to
come to your window, and that's just what I did. How was I suppose to know.”
“It's alright Butters. Are you ready to do this?”
“Well sure I am. Should I come into your room or should I just take you from
the window.”
“I'll just come out the window. Don't worry about making a commotion because no
one here would even care. And don't worry about Mysterion, I'm sure he'll know
I'm in trouble.”
The two walked down to the storage units, entering Professor Chaos' secret
lair. “Are you sure Mysterion is going to show up? No one saw me kidnap you.
Couldn't you have come here on your own.”
Karen placed her hand on Butters' shoulder, “I know I didn't explain every
angle of the plan. Trust me, you picking me up was important. Now it's time for
you to attack me.”
Butters rubbed his knuckles together. “I...I don't know if I can do this. Can't
we just pretend? It's not like anyone's going to know.”
Karen's eyes widened and she practically screamed, “No Butters! We have to do
this or he won't show up. Now take the cuffs, lock me up and try to rape me.”
“I'm really sorry, but I can't do this. I just can't.”
Karen tightened her grip and pushed him against the wall. “If you're not
willing to do this for me then I'll have to do it myself.” Before Butters
realized, she had slipped the handcuffs around his wrist and locked them.
“What are you doing?”
“I've gone this far, I can't stop now.” Karen knelt down and unbuckled his
belt.
“No Karen. Don't do this. I don't want to rape you!”
Karen pulled his belt free and looked at him in bewilderment. “No stupid, I'm
the one who's going to rape you.”
“Then how is Mysterion going to know you're in danger.”
“I left notes, remember? He'll be here in less than an hour.” She pulled his
pants down and tossed them to the side. “Now prepare yourself, because I'm
going to rock your world.”
 
                                       5
Mysterion raced toward the storage units on the edge of town. He didn't know
what kind of game Professor Chaos was playing, but he'd be damned if he was
going to risk his sister's well being on the assumption that Butters wouldn't
hurt her. Taking his sister was something that he never saw coming. The two of
them had become much closer over the past few years. What could have come over
him? He suspected that Eric Cartman might be behind this, but he didn't have
the time to corner him and question him. He had to make sure his sister was
okay.
Mysterion stood in front of the door that used to hold Chaos' secret lair. He
didn't know if this was where they were, but it was the best place to start.
Giving himself just enough time to catch his breath, he slung the door open and
braced himself for whatever trap might have been laid.
He was not prepared for what he saw.
As his eyes adjusted to the light. Kenny saw his sister, naked, on top of
Butters. She was moving up and down, rocking her hips as she rode on his cock.
Kenny could clearly see Butters' dick penetrating his sister. As she rose up,
her juices flowed down the length of his shaft. Kenny looked up to Butters'
face. He had his eyes closed with a look of deep concentration. This is when he
noticed that Butters' arm was handcuffed to the wall. “What the fuck!?”
Karen turned her head and excitedly called out to the new presence. “Kenny!”
Butters opened his eyes and looked to Mysterion outside the door. “Oh
hamburgers. Now look Kenny, I'm sorry but...” It was his own mention of Kenny's
name that caused him to realize that Karen had also called him by name. “Wait.
You knew Kenny was Mysterion?”
“Of course I did. I'm not an idiot. He came out publicly on the news years
ago.”
“Then why did you want me to kidnap you?”
Kenny stepped inside, pulling his mask off. “You?! This was your idea? What the
hell Karen, what the fuck were you thinking?”
Karen raised up, letting Butters' rocket slip out of her, slapping against his
belly as soon as it was loose. She watched Kenny's face as she did this, making
note of where his eyes were looking. “I needed to talk to you. I had to
confront you about something in a way that I couldn't back out of.”
“What was so goddamned important that you had to make me walk in on you having
sex...having sex with Butters?” Kenny's eyes began to tear up.
Butters yanked on the handcuffs to bring attention to himself, “Guys, could
someone please let me go?”
Kenny and Karen spoke in unison, “Shut up Butters!”
Karen took a deep breath to prepare herself for what she need to say. “I found
your journal.”
Kenny turned and pulled the door shut. “What journal?”
“The one you kept with your dirty books. I was...borrowing a couple of them,
and when I first saw them, I thought you had been writing your own fanfictions.
That's when I learned your secret.”
“Karen, don't do this. Please don't do this.” He kept looking down at Butters
sitting against the wall, “Not here, not now.”
“You're in love with Butters!” She cast her gaze to the blond next to her, “You
hear that? He loves you Butters! He loves you more than anyone else.”
Butters sat confused and confounded. “Well, that's nice.”
“Why Karen? Why are you doing this to me?”
Karen closed her eyes and clinched her fists, “Because I'm in love with you
Kenny. I know it's wrong, but I can't keep it inside anymore.” A stunned
silence fell between the three. No one knew what to say.
Kenny wiped his tears, and stepped over to his sister, removing his cape and
draping it over her shoulders, “I... I didn't know.”
“Of course you didn't dumb-ass, I couldn't bring myself to tell you. But when I
read about your feelings for Butters, my heart couldn't keep quiet. I had to do
something.”
“But why have sex with him?”
“Because...well honestly, because most of the fantasies you wrote about
involved you and him having a three-way with some random girl. Or...about
Butters being a girl. Anyway, I figured I could be that random girl.” Karen
turned her back to the boys. “That way we would both be happy.”
Kenny wrapped his arms around his sister and hugged her gently. “I understand
what you were trying to do, but what about Butters' feelings? Did you take into
account that he might not want to be pulled into this?”
Butters spoke up, “I'm okay with it.”
Karen and Kenny again spoke in unison, “What!?”
“Well, I learned something today. What Karen was doing felt real nice, and I
like you a whole lot Kenny. I'm okay with the three of us doing more of that
sex stuff. And it makes me feel really happy knowing Kenny feels that way about
me. I...well, I kind of feel the same way, but it would make me sad if Karen
couldn't be with the one she loves.”
Kenny and Karen looked at each other for an extended moment until Kenny broke
the silence, “This is a lot to take in, but I want you to know, I really truly
love you both. Why don't you two get dressed and we can talk about how we'll
make this work.”
Butters pulled against his shackles, “Can I be let free now?”
Kenny smiled, “After we get this figured out, I have a feeling you'll be right
back where you are.”
End Notes
     I wrote this a while back and never gave it a proper ending. I
     slapped on something passable so I could upload it, but it still
     feels incomplete. If there is enough interest then I might add the
     three way sex scene that it was suppose to end with. Either way I
     hope you enjoyed.
Please drop_by_the_archive_and_comment to let the author know if you enjoyed
their work!