Posted originally on the Archive_of_Our_Own at https://archiveofourown.org/ works/10064669. Rating: Explicit Archive Warning: Major_Character_Death, Rape/Non-Con, Underage Category: M/M Fandom: Harry_Potter_-_J._K._Rowling Relationship: Sirius_Black/Remus_Lupin, Remus_Lupin/Severus_Snape Character: Severus_Snape, Sirius_Black, Remus_Lupin Additional Tags: Explicit_Language, Slash_sex, Self-Harm, Sexual_Content, Angst, Tragedy, First_Time, Horror, Supernatural_-_Freeform, Mystery, Suspense, Pre- Slash, Romance, Science_Fiction_&_Fantasy Collections: HPFandom Stats: Published: 2009-06-25 Completed: 2010-01-09 Chapters: 3/3 Words: 5198 ****** A Lesson in Fear ****** by Isy_25 [archived by HPFandom_archivist] Summary Remus Lupin was loath to bring up the tales of his life. The differences between light and dark, fear and hate, love and distrust. They all had to do with them. Each of them. Follow Remus through his life, the time of the Marauders, and a sealed fate. Notes Note from SeparatriX, the archivist: this story was originally archived at HP_Fandom, which was closed for health and financial reasons. To preserve the archive, I began manually importing its works to the AO3 as an Open Doors-approved project in August 2016. I e-mailed all creators about the move and posted announcements, but may not have reached everyone. If you are (or know) this creator, please contact me using the e-mail address on HP_Fandom_collection profile. ***** Prologue: Rome ***** Prologue In time we hate, that which we often fear. William Shakespeare I was once told that power is all about your fate. It controls your destiny, puts it on a path that only you can own up to. It can seep into your blood, and give you ultimate release. Or, it can trap you and make you its prisoner, twist you, mold you into its slave. I never believed any of that. Fate? Destiny? What about safety? What about love? I believe, power has very little to do with it. RLRLRLRLRLRLRL October 10, 1969 When I was just five years old, I'd already learned how to read most of the books in our house. My twin brother Romulus, and I would storm our way through the house as the kings of my favorite stories. I couldn't wait until I got home from preschool to read my new favorite masterpiece. Back then, I was never made fun of for knowing how to read better than anyone else. My mother considered it a gift. Magic. My father told me to keep it hidden, to not be proud, it would make my brother feel bad. As soon as I found I could, I'd read aloud in the best pronunciation I could muster, every quote, and every cry I could muster, to my parent's dismay. My mother encouraged my behavior. My father quickly hid the heavier books to the higher selves. Unfortunately, my brother, who could not read as well as me was often asking mother how to read to him at bedtime. Once, he found Hesiod's Works and Days. Mother, stupidly told him it was about wizards, and Father was furious for days. Father hid most books from him after that. He wouldn't understand why Prometheus was bound by the gods anyway. “Fire!” “Alert the townsmen!” I ran, as fast as my feet would carry me, out of the back door of our house in the English countryside. My brother was far ahead of me, always running faster than me. His feet seemed to float as he ran and leaped, his laughter ringing out like bells on Easter Sunday. Romulus was a vision, my twin. He, who couldn't write his own name. He, who didn't have a gram of magic in him, still laughed and played, and called me Remmy. Romulus kept running, and then, suddenly, he stopped midway to the edge of the Lupin Estate. He turned to smile at me, his brown eyes were sparkling in the late afternoon sun. “Chu are the mighty knight, I give you my sword! Save the peoples!” Romulus shouted to me, holding his stick out. He turned swiftly, with his cape swaying in the wind. His was body stiff as he headed towards the forest. I knew by his posture that he was pretending to be a king, and I smiled, despite the foreboding in my heart. “Rommy,” I called after him carefully. “What are you doing! Mommy said not to go that far!” Romulus turned to, his eyes still ablaze in some fantastical amazement. “Chu always do what mommy says. It's fun, don't be a wuss, Remmy!” I started to yell that I wasn't, but my brother took off in a sprint towards the edge of the forest. I could see the sun was going down, and his cape floated and sparkled in the sunset. I was mesmerized by my inability to resist following him into the woods. My brother's eyes sparkled with poorly contained glee as he grabbed my hand, and led me into the forest. The sounds of creatures I would never lay eyes on were in the distance. In my little hand, I held a small stick. My only defense against the one creature who was waiting on the both of us, so long ago. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ No, see, I believe power has very little to do with any of the horrible things that can happen to you. Because, all I've ever known is powerlessness. September, 1985 “Remus!” I gasped sitting up in bed, I was covered in blood again. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ I hope you like it so far. Review please, I love feedback. Still needs a beta, and so I'm sorry for any incongruences or typos. Next up, we meet the Marauders plus Lily. ***** Ch1-Hamlet is for losers ***** Italics are Remus' thoughts or the voices of memories. Chapter 1- Hamlett is for Losers   In my dreams, I always ended up covered in blood, with screaming in the background. There was always a shroud of tree covering darkness, and a voice in my head saying, “I'm so sorry, mummy! I tried.” “Remus?” The voice of one James Potter broke into my estranged thoughts. “Did you have a dream again? About... about the night it...happened?” Trust James to cut straight to the thick of it. James Potter's soft brown eyes looked at me almost imploringly. It was times like these that I forgot how stupid he could be. And, even underneath the act of the school bully, all-star Quidditch player, James Potter was a good guy at heart. However, tact or even subtlety were his weaknesses. “I'm fi-..,” was all that I could manage. My mind was fuzzy, and I was unable to force the fake words out of my mouth. They all knew. James, Peter, and Sirius. My nightmares were nothing that they were unaccustomed to. “I'll get you some water,” said Peter, a round sandy haired boy with a nervous twitch, and always eager to please. When Pete left to fetch the water there was a thick silence in the room. I felt a set of eyes on me and, I glanced to see Sirius sitting on his bed with his back up against the headboard. I noticed that Sirius hadn't commented yet. He just stared at me with sad, but curious gray eyes. His black hair was sleep tousled as he put an uneasy hand through it. A sign of nervousness. I shook it off. I had no time to reassure him that I'm ok at that moment. Sirius Black never talked about anything serious, no pun intended, but fine I'll take it. If it was about him, or his family, it was off limits. His brother Regulus was off limits to conversation, and so were his nightly escapades with half the female population. Not that James, Pete, and I couldn't guess that his brother, the little Slytherin understudy to Lucius, hated his guts. And, the whole school knew that he was, what my mother called, a Casanova. I'd read that book, and I found Casanova to be bellow my Sirius. Sirius, who cared, Sirius who would never use anyone. In all of my miscalculations about my best friend, I dumbly ignored the pained glances and the constant diversions. Queen, was unimportant, and who exactly is John Lennon anyway? I was oblivious. I, who should know a pained glance when I met it, and I, who should know a dark secret when smelt it.   Breakfast on the first day passed by rather slowly and uneventfully. The tradition of the Marauders, as we called ourselves since third year, was to sit at the end of the table. James, closest to the center aisle, and Sirius on his right. I faced Sirius, and Pete next to me, by the aisle. I hated it. I thought it was stupid that we all had assigned seats. But, I never told anyone this. I felt lucky enough to have friends that wanted to sit near me anyway. It was time to go to the first class of the day quickly, since we were late on account of my nightly fright. As I was scrambling to get all of my books together, I noticed Sirius jot something quickly down on parchment and begin to fold it. It was a note. I had an unpleasant jolt, and swallowed my discomfort. I stood by myself, breaking with the tradition of us walking to first classes together, and hurried out of the Great Hall alone. I could feel the eyes of my friends on me, and I felt an extra set of black eyes near the Slytherin table, as I left. I ignored them all and hurried down the corridor. But, predictably, I didn't make it far before the Marauders caught up to me. “Hey Moony wait up!” James called out. Several students nearby turned to look as he shouted, particularly a group of girls. They all swooned and a few waved as we walked by. Many of the girls wanted to date Prongs, but he only had eyes for one. Not to mention Pete would point out, not so tactfully, that they were all damaged goods since Sirius had bedded nearly all of them. I noticed, as we walked, that Sirius was giving me that sickeningly sad look again, so I pulled out my course schedule in favor of a distraction. Professor Marcus Hamlett was our Defense Against the Dark Arts teacher this year, since our teacher of 6 years, Professor Xavier Bartholomew, was tried and found guilty of child molestation by the Wizengamot. It seemed that, other than having a dreadfully bad name, he had horrible taste in sexual partners as well. But, Professor Hamlett, according to James and Pete was bound to be a crackpot too, because he was a Muggleborn. “A bleeding obvious one at that!” James said, as we were making our way down the corridor. James, of course, was pointing out his Muggle clothing, a brown tweed suit and a red tie. Plain, but not horrible, by my poor tastes. Sirius pointed out that in a flurry of cloaks and robes, he was a sore thumb. “I like his name.” I knew at that moment that I should not have said anything, when I noticed the sets of eyes looking at me with confusion evident. I could appreciate good Muggle humor, but even Sirius, who seemed to, suspiciously know what I was talking about, shook his head at me which belied the recognition in his eyes. I thought quickly about pointing out the misspelling on the syllabus, but some things are funny only in my head. We all came to a halt in the doorway of our classroom, and there she stood. Her red hair glittering in the sunlight from the window. Her green eyes, smiling. Lily Evans. Even James, in all of his Anti-Muggleborn hype, could not escape her addicting beauty. And, her brilliance. Where my love for literature stopped, her love for art began. She created just about anything with her hands, paintings, sculpture, music, and her recent love for photography imbued her fiery charm. Though I was hesitant to notice, her beauty lay not only in her abilities. She was very pretty, and I was very blind. “You're late,” she said to the three of us. I didn't see the point in being early to a morning class with a perfectly good breakfast in the Great Hall, and I wanted to point this out, but I knew it was not the real reason we were late anyway. We all filed into the classroom despite the scowl Lily was giving us. Pete waved shyly at her and James cracked a grin. Her gazed softened when I walked by, but I was distracted from saying anything when I felt Sirius' hands on me. A note was discretely handed to me as we made our way to our seats. Suddenly, in a woosh of air the all of the window curtains in the classroom were immediately closed. The door creaked open, and who I supposed was Professor Hamlett, walked in. I caught his scent through my heightened sense of smell-- sandalwood and parchment. “Hello class,” he said brightly, though the dimness of the classroom betrayed his humorous tone. A girl beside me who was also a Gryffindor named Alice Langley, shivered. In an eerie quickness, Professor Hamlett glanced in her direction. “Ah yes,” he said and his wand flickered to the many candles that littered the room. “Ah that's better.” He smiled a quirky smile, and I could tell, since there was finally light in the room, that he was a bit young. Though, he had laugh lies around his eyes that were accentuated by the candle light, his smile was welcoming and denoted youth and open friendliness. I immediately liked this Professor. “Hello I'm Professor Hamlett,” He said as he wrote his name on the bored. I noticed begrudgingly that he spelled his name with two T's. “Welcome, welcome! This class is Defense Against the Dark Arts, level 7 for the OWLs and NEWTs, but I don't want to bore you all with that. Ugly business is it not?” Hamlett waved his hand waspishly as he talked and begin to pace in front of the class. “You will find, that your willingness to learn, grasp, and apply the knowledge of DADA cannot be measured by tests.” I thought I heard Lily scoff at this, but didn't get a chance to glance over as the candles flickered simultaneously in unison in the room. The Professor was speaking again. “What are the dark arts? What is dark? Darkness...is only a product of light, or the lack of light. Without the light, there can be no darkness.” The were various degrees of whispering throughout the room as some seemed to disagree. I could hear the slight hitch in Alice's breath beside me. “Yes, yes you may all find it a strange concept. Indeed some of you may disagree,” Hamlett stated, with an upward quirk of his mouth that relayed what he thought of those people. Alice shifted in her seat beside me, and James, two seats over looked skeptical. “Darkness, is offset by light. We are taught this at an early age. That if we only learn what it means to produce the proper light magic, we will not be soiled by the dark.” That quirky smile flickered this time across his face, but didn't stay long. “I am here to teach you that it there is not such thing as “dark” magic.” There were certainly gasps that time. I found myself unable to close my mouth. “Magic, is magic. It comes from the earth, to us, to space, through time, and so forth. But, is not light or dark, good or bad. It is a life force. Only we can decide what to use it for.” Only half of the class seemed satisfied with this answer, and it sparked a lively debate as hands flew up everywhere. I found myself wondering, still with my mouth agape, what Albus Dumbledore would have to say about this. I feared Professor Hamlett would not be around much longer. The class went by quickly it seemed. I, who was never inclined to say anything out loud in my classes, even felt like I had something to add. This was a thirst. I wanted to ask an endless source of what ifs. I made my way out of the DADA classroom to my Astronomy class. As I walked I reached inside the pocket of my robes, and opened the note Sirius gave me. I felt Sirius' eyes on me as I was walking away, and I paused in my steps, as I read the scribbled handwriting. “We need to talk. Meet at same place?” I nodded quickly at the floor and shuffle down the corridor. He wants to talk, does he? Does he think that a heart to heart will make me feel better about him leading Snape to my wolf form! On my way down the corridor and up the stairs, I pulled out my schedule again. I was not looking where I'm walking as I ran flat into a body stopped in front of me. I would know that smell anywhere. Severus. “Lupin,” I'm am at awe at how he can draw out the syllables of my name. A practiced skill, no doubt. I found myself face to face with him, though I still felt as if he was looking down at me, his black eyes seeing something dirty in me. “In a hurry, oblivious to others in your path. How very typical.” I smile a bit and side stepped him. “Better?” I smiled though he did not. It made me feel ambivalent. The wolf rolls around in my head, happy and satisfied. Then he marches close to me again, this time invading my space more, if possible. “I am amazed at how you possess all of these “senses,” yet your clumsiness is still legendary. Or, are you just hoping to run into me?” His eyes are glittering and his mouth is tight as he says this. I am loath to admit that I am drawn to his gaze, and the wolf is still, and waiting. However, I back up quickly, only to notice Peter staring at me strangely behind Severus. He was waiting for me outside of the classroom. “Remus,” he says. “Class is about t-to start.” Severus turns and scowls at him and walks by him and into the classroom. “Are you ok?” Peter asks, but I don't answer. I am trapped in my own thoughts. Since the previous year and the incident with Sirius leading Severus to the Whomping Willow, Severus Snape had gone through I range of conflicting emotions about me. Dumbledore, in all of his infuriating calmness made Severus promise not to tell a soul about my “condition.” It made me furious at Sirius for being to childish and careless. And it made me furious at Severus for knowing a secret that he was never supposed to know. The latter scared me. Severus was already drawn to me. My kindness, amongst the teasing of my best friends caused him to question me. Why did I care? Why did I talk James and Sirius down on more than one occasion? Whatever, conclusion Severus had come to, it involved following me around for the most of my 5th and 6th years. We actually met on few occasions when I acknowledge him following me, and all he did was mock me for my strange ability to sense his presence. And, now that he knew I was a werewolf, it seemed his curiosity was peaked more and more. When I finally made it into the classroom, Peter was pointing me to a table with two chairs. I placed my bag fitfully onto the table that Pete had picked. He glances at me, but wisely says nothing. He knows Severus has been following me, and I would rather he didn't. It was only a matter of time before James and Sirius cottoned on. As my bag hits the table the note from Sirius falls out. Thoughts of what Sirius will want to talk about distracted me throughout the class. Who was he to demand we talk! The nerve! He lost that right when I led Severus to that tree. I was still fuming after class, and as I walk down to meet him, my heart skips a beat when I see him. ***** Ch2- A Dream ***** “Each time, I let him further inside me, into my soul. Maybe soon he would meet the wolf...face to face.” Chapter 2- A dream “I thought you'd prefer the outdoors. Beats the bloody hot castle, yeah?” Sirius was leaning against a tree, smoking a cigarette, and I tried not to kid myself into thinking that he'd choose the outside for non-selfish reasons. I shuffled my feet and stared at the Quidditch pitch, which looked empty and deserted for the time being. “I do,” I say, though my eyes are now focused on the ground. Sirius draws in smoke and lets out a sigh. His focus is dead on me. I can feel his gray eyes boring into me. He seems to have the effect of looking straight through me. And, each time he looks into me, I let him in. “So what was the dream about this time?” “Same,” I realize that I am being short. I didn't want to go further. Sirius and I had many things to discuss, and none of the things were about my poor sleeping habits. The topic of the Whomping Willow accident, since he betrayed me to Severus... well... Severus Snape, was another story as well. “I thought you said you weren't having those anymore?” Sirius' husky voice is ladden with guilt and suspicion. I didn't want to conform his miscalculation. Last year's accident was fresh on both of our minds, and I was loath to talk about it, especially with Sirius. I look up at him sharply. “No, not about that...It was the one with the blood.” Sirius' face lights up, and then darkens to a scowl. I close up automatically, awaiting his outburst, that is sure to come. “You told me you didn't have those anymore, not since...dammit Remus...I--,” I cut him short. My voice is low and I breathe deep to calm my rising anger. “I lied!” Sirius looks even more unreleased by my saying this. It was a verdict. My statement was a verdict to him. “You--” “No you,” I hiss. I'm trying to clam my “anger.” I'm calling it that these days, but even Sirius can see the wolf in my eyes. “you” “I can't believe that you thought I would just suddenly stop having nightmares because I didn't tell you about them anymore...” I trailed off, surprised by my sudden honesty. But, I take a breathe and start again. “I have them almost every night. I try to put up a silencing charm, but last night we were all partying, celebrating the start of the term and...I forgot.” Sirius was no longer looking accusatory, but saddened. I felt the bile rise in my throat. I didn't want pity, especially not from my friends. “Moony...” I cringe at the use of my nickname. The wolf inside me snarls. But, I can't help but notice he'd stopped using it last year, after the accident. “Was...was your brother there?” I looked up at him confused. Then I realized that I'd never told him. I didn't know that I had kept them all at a distance. None of my friends knew much about that night. They knew that I had nightmares about it, but they didn't know much detail. For that, I was sorry. I will always remember what I told him next. “It w-was my brother's blood. Not mine. In the dream too. It's all the same. That night, the dream...all the same. I was little, we both were. We didn't know that there was danger in the forest. Mom and Dad... they only told us little lies. They told us it was haunted and stuff. Ghosts can't hurt anybody can they?” Sirius shook his head, a little in response, but more in disbelief. I sighed and continued. “I remember very little about that night. Romulus,” my voice breaks as I say his name. “He and I were playing in the yard. He was so far ahead of me. I only remember saying not to go in the woods. Then things speed up. My head hurts to think about it.” Mommy! Help us! Daddy! I felt Sirius' long fingered hand on my shoulder. I must have blanked out. “Sorry...anyway, I remember seeing it. The wolf. It was standing there near the clearing. Too close to the clearing, come to think of it... And then we saw it. We must have stared for ages. The three of us. Romulus was the first to move. He took my hand. After that...I don't really...I don't remember. I just remember waking up in the forest, covered in blood.” Sirius stares out at the distant lake, his eyes are haunted. I can't bear to tell him the rest. It was getting late, and it was probably time for lunch anyway. I turn to look at the sun in the sky and then to Sirius to see that his head is down, and I am secretly happy about that. His eyes seemed reach out to me and each time, I let him further inside me, into my soul. Maybe soon he would meet the wolf...face to face. I was not to be thrilled at the meeting, but I knew he couldn't escape me it seemed, even back then. I look back to him and my heart sinks. His beauty could be easily measured by his physique. It could be measured in his eyes, his hair which is waves and black softness. I cannot pay any mind to it as I turn to make my way towards the castle. Leaving my fallen angel to wallow in his indiscretion.   “This Hamlett guys is off his rocker!” James said as we stormed into the Gryffindor common room later that night. He threw his bag down and collapsed in the nearby couch. “The whole school is talking about him! They say that his nutter ideas are revolutionary! Load of bollocks!” Pete is nodding his head emphatically. “He may not be around long. Once word gets out-- Oi!” I realized belatedly that I stole the seat that Pete had deemed his own. “Tradition” and all. “Sorry Petty,” I say though, I don't make to move from the couch. Sirius, I realized is sitting in the straight chair by the fire, despite the heat of the castle lately. He is quiet and staring out, his eyes, unfocused. I feel briefly guilty for pouring my old troubles on him. It is easy for me to sweep things under the rug, but I'd forgotten that Sirius was so very young back then. All of my friends were. They joked at me for being 15 going on 30, but there was too much truth in it. I was much younger than those in my year, but being roomies with a wolf had aged me. Sitting behind my eyelids, scratching away at every bit of my youth. I even have little strings of silver hair to prove it. “No, no, no Red, that seat is Pete's he'll be right back!” James' voice breaks me from my thoughts. Lily is back form her last class of the day. I can see that her and James are about to start a row, but Sirius was recently startled from his thoughts too. He grabbed her by the waist and plops her down into his lap. She giggles, but a glance at James makes her pause. “Snooze ya lose Paddy,” Sirius is easily back to fun and games, like an addict to the bottle. Irony again. I would refrain from using such references and puns that fit him too well, but I'm a victim of the euphemism. Sirius will always be a source of conflicting words for me. I sat back into the comfy chair and cracked open my latest novel, and pushed the voices of my friends out of my ears as I jumped into my only escape. Back then, it was so easy to slip into nothingness, numbness. It is a welcomed escape as I swallowed the sense of dread. Because, even now as I stand here in my house watching, remembering and re-living my life. There are things that I am leaving out...things that I haven't seen, that may help explain everything that happened later. A year ago... “Don't Black, I'm not in the mood...” Severus Snape had his back pressed up against the wall facing one intimidating Sirius Black. Both boys were tall in stature, though one-- the one who was standing was built of a more muscled build, and the other, who was pressed against the cold castle wall was of a slight build, with hunched shoulders and delicate hands, which were currently clutched in a fist. “You think that I haven't noticed you watching him!” Sirius was furious at this moment in time, and his only regret is that he couldn't have James there to back him up. This matter was too delicate... “You think that I don't know that you...if you had only the opportunity--” “--I would slice you into pieces!” Snape was snarling at Black. Though he was slouching against the wall, he was still intent on posing a threat. Sirius did not think him a challenge, in any fashion. “Snape,” the name was spoken with intense loathing, and a curious hint of teasing. “What were you doing here...in this corridor...at this time of night...” There was a breath of silence, except for Snape's harsh breathing. Sirius continued. “Are you following Remus again?” There was still no sound. Severus Snape was trapped. Black would not let him go without an answer to his questions. Snape was not sure of his answers. He'd found Remus strange for a long time. The quite boy was exceptionally smart, such that he was brought to school when he was two years younger than those in his year. He was also strange in that, he'd had quite a few illnesses in the past. It seemed like every month the boy was in the infirmary! However, the strangest was that Lupin's eyes, which were a less noticeable feature to be sure. But they had this glow. Whenever Snape noticed, he couldn't help but look away. They frightened him at first. However, Snape could only glance back a second later, and they'd been only a figment of his imagination right? But, Snape had a knack for unsolved mysteries. Remus Lupin was the first on his list to solve—Potter and Black be damned. “Would you like to see him...now?” Sirius had become distant. Snape hadn't know the exact time that Sirius had started pacing the area between them. He seemed thoughtful, in a sarcastic mockery of the word, since Snape didn't believe Black had a thoughtful bone in his body. But, as Sirius stopped pacing and turned to him Snape saw all traces of false pondering gone. He was faced with a manic. The one he knew well. Silly, uncouth, demeaning, hurtful, Black was incapable of a looking more lost than he did at that moment. Snape wanted to just apologize and leave, but Blacks gray gaze kept him prisoner. 'See Lupin? Do I want to see him now?' Snape's two halves of his brain split apart. The side that knew his heart led him to believe that he wanted to see Lupin everyday. It knew that he hoped one day Lupin would be able to also see him, as well-- the true Snape, not the one who was shamed by his friends. But, a distance scream broke him from his dreams, as other half of his brain-- the more in tuned side knew that something wasn't right. “S-see... L-lupin?” How could he stutter at a time like this?! And, what was that screaming noise?! Sirius' manic eyes were wide as he said, “Yes, I mean it! Follow me.” -------------------- I hope this makes some sense. Maybe some of you are beginning to realize that this is all a memory. But, we all know memories are flawed, because they only show one side. Well, I'm helping Remus out with the flashbacks(in italics). Review! Let me know what you think so far... Please drop_by_the_archive_and_comment to let the author know if you enjoyed their work!