If you find the Search page (Find a story) useful at all, would you please review at least one story (Review a Story)? Any Story! Maybe I'm getting frustrated with it, but it seems like there are somewhere in the neighborhood of 5 to 10 thousand searches per single valid review that doesn't come from an Author's page (Edit: New stat is 2000 Searches/Review, thanks all and keep up the good work, Lix). Maybe that's normal, but it means one new story is currently being added every two to four weeks (Edit: Approx. 1 per week. Lix). So, if you find this system useful, please review a story every now and then so the system will continue to grow and become more useful to you.

Search and Review System

Table of Contents: Database Stats:
Recent Updates 2003-07-24 Total Records: 1883
Overview Last Update: 2003-07-09
Automatic Emails for Authors 2003-07-18
Bulk Additions
Self-Healing
Tripod Pop Up/Under Warning 2003-04-27                          
File Locations
Review Archive Links 2003-07-31

Recent Updates: top

2003-07-24 The new domain name has been bought and a hosting server is being selected. Database updates (barring a bulk update) and all other changes will be non-existent until the new server comes online and the programs are moved to it. In older news, a semi-reliable statistic of 1 email per 1000 page hits has been computed (see Automatic Emails for Authors for details).

2003-07-08 Tesseract's changes have been made, 200 more bulk additions have been processed, and the database has been updated.

2003-06-26 Tesseract has provided some valuable input on reformatting the Search Results page. No real expected completion date, but it is on the list. Thank you Tesseract! Also, thanks go to the person making the Bulk Additions of the 30 Anoninsac stories on 6/16.

2003-06-15 Okay, so it is just my frustration, the actual number so far is 2,443 Searches per Review being submitted. Which still seems abysmal as that equates to one new review every 10 days or so. Don't you want others to hear your voice? Squick criteria is still on the agenda, current lack of time is the issue.

2003-06-01 Thanks go out to the person who sent the Bulk Additions on May 26th. About 100 entries of the authors Uther_Pendragon, arrowchild, and eskimo1958. The more the merrier and many thanks, Lix.

2003-05-21 Database updated, yeah. I'll crack open a mySQL manual and see if I can get the mods done now.

2003-05-20 Volunteer projects, what can you say? Lack of time on my part has delayed the Database updates and modifications. Currently there are 8 entries needed to be updated to the database; best guess is Wednesday or Thursday. Modifications are on hold for a bit, any Review that uses the missing codes will be saved and processed when the mods are done. Daily reviews are't going to happen in the short term either. *sigh*

2003-05-06 Database still needs to be fixed for X-Men and Zoo, so far no one has entered one of those codes, so my lack of time to get to it doesn't seem to be an issue :) I'm also toying with the idea of publishing to ASSTR daily reviews/summaries, same format as the Weekly Reviews, in a static location.

Overview: top

Help people find the works they are looking for.

After reading the multitude of Story Code flame wars and hearing the pitiful cries of readers that they didn�t have a way to find stories that met their reading criteria, I decided to build something that might solve both. And so I started, and then it grew, and grew, and grew. And it�s not even close to stopping it�s growth (i.e. scope creep). The overriding thought for this system is that it is "self-healing" and allows people to share their opinion on stories they read or write. The current thought is this system will merge with the ASSTR shs-header and review systems that are being planned. This system is currently slightly broader scoped than the ASSTR systems, we allow non-ASSTR sites to participate (see the AUP at the bottom of this page), but that probably won't be an issue.

The system currently:

Automatic Emails for Authors: top

If you are an Author and wish your readers to be able to send you (anonymously if they desire) comments and reviews of your stories you may use the Author's Rate/Review button. Go to the Author Snippet which will give instructions on how to set it up. This system will work with proxies that strip referrer information.

The Search and Review system was designed to rate (and later modified to email comments to authors) singular webpages. Which in general meant that each chapter of a story got its own entry. I have also now noticed that some entries are pointing to a webpage that contains a summary (table of contents, author comments, etc.) for that specific story. Either usage is fine.

The best results in getting comments to authors has been by making it as easy as possible for the reader to find and click the Review Button. With that in mind, there seems to be a sliding scale on where and how many Review Buttons to use.

To gather the most absolute number of comments, put a Button at the top and bottom of each individual chapter and a Button next to each story link on the rest of the site. Another method is to place a single Button at the end of each chapter. And another way is to place a single Button on the summary or table of contents page for the story.

-- Statistics, Thoughts, and # Emails per Page Hits --

It seems there is approximately 1 fan email per 1000 page hits, with the caveat that this seems to only be valid for brand new stories.

The data being collected isn't that conducive to extensive analysis, but a pattern of existing (and older) stories getting zero (or one) fan emails seems to be emerging. This may be because new stories are getting 5 to 10 times the number of page hits than older stories. Also, there does seem to be an ASSD effect (i.e. if the story is talked about in ASSD the number of hits and fan comments goes up), which might say something about the number of lurkers in ASSD?

-- For Archivists and Collectors --

Within the guidelines above, placing a Rate and Review Button on the stories you are hosting for others is great. Please do get their permission first and tell them that you are creating Buttons for them. That way they will not be startled to start receiving emailed comments from a bogus email address. (The email they receive is from @dev.nul and has an appended comment about where it actually comes from.)

Bulk Additions: top

Someone a week or two back added a couple hundred stories through the standard add a Review form (Review a Story) And while I heartily thank them, and did so in ASSD, I can only think that their mouse finger has got to hurt! So, in the vein of trying to not be blamed for someone's carpal tunnel, I've made it much easier to add large numbers of stories all at once.

If you will put "bulk" submissions in the below format and paste it into my Email Kluge, I'll go manually process it, so your click finger doesn't fall off :)

Author Name
URL,Title,code,code,code
URL,Title,code,code,code
URL,Title,code,code,code
. . .

Example:
Anais Ninja
http://www.asstr.org/files/Authors/anais_ninja/wander/wander10.txt,Wanderings Ten - Homecoming,F8f,m8f,M8f,F8mm,inc
http://www.asstr.org/files/Authors/anais_ninja/wander/wander11.txt,Wanderings Eleven - Babes in Toyland,FF8ff,inc,ws
http://www.asstr.org/files/Authors/anais_ninja/wander/wander12.txt,Wanderings Twelve - Insatiable,M8f,F8f,F8m,inc,gang

Please use either MF, M/F, or M8F notation for singles and F+/m+, FF/mm, FF8mm for multies. Or just try to keep the codes as close to the recognized code list as possible. If nothing else, try to be consistent with however you are coding, so I can use global search and replace for corrections. (for example, stick with one of: Best, Beast, Bestial, or Bestiality)

Codes are here: http://lixdw1192.tripod.com/codes.txt
Email Kluge is here: http://lixdw1192.tripod.com/emaillix.html

And thank you to the people that have already added large groups of stories.

Self-Healing: top

This system will become "self-healing" over time, at least from the standpoint of statistics. Eventually stories will receive enough reviews so that any "mistakes" in story codes will become outliers and thereby these mistakes will be easy for the human searcher to ignore. Further additions to Search formats will allow the selection of "cut-off" points to programmatically exclude outliers in Search results.

The second thing is this has to be a living breathing document and system that is self-healing. It is a large collection of data that no one will ever have the time to go into to correct if "codes" are deleted or changed. So, deleting and changing things is out, if individual elements are no longer used, no problem, no one codes for it, no one searches on it, so everyone can just ignore it. It disappears from non-use.

Tripod Pop Up/Under Warning: top

Either Tripod has recently added Pop Ups and Pop Unders or I've had Pop Ups in Opera turned off for months. I'm not sure which it is, but I don't remember Tripod having Pops in late December 2002 when I setup the Tripod account to run the Search and Review system. If your browser allows you to turn them off, my suggestion it to do it prior to clicking on any link going to Tripod.

I'm open to suggestions to a less intrusive hosting service that fits the requirements of free, allows Perl CGI, anonymous account creation, and will work through a proxy. (Also, it would be nice it if had mySQL capabilities.) Drop me a note with their name and I'll see if they will work.

File Locations: top

Find a story
Review a Story
Author Snippet (a.k.a. Author's "Rate/Review" and anonymous email Button)
Story Codes & Links
Project Notes
Email Lix

Review Archives: top

For the full list of all prior archives search in the ASSD newsgroup for the subject "{ASSD} Weekly ACRRS story review submissions." Archival postings to ASSD ceased on 24 May 2003, as mostly I don't have the time to manually post them in two places. Once the Search and Review system is moved off of Tripod, an automated mechanism will be built for ASSD posts. The continuing, manual, archive on ASSTR is here:

Weekly Review 4/11/03 Searches per Week
Weekly Review 4/18/03 Searches 1552
Weekly Review 4/25/03 Searches 1849
Weekly Review 5/04/03 Searches 1664
Weekly Review 5/09/03 Searches 1684
Weekly Review 5/16/03 Searches 1236
Weekly Review 5/23/03 Searches 2346
Weekly Review 5/30/03 Searches 2242
Weekly Review 6/06/03 Searches 1487
Weekly Review 6/13/03 Searches 1768
Weekly Review 6/20/03 Searches 3031
Weekly Review 6/27/03 Searches 1773
Weekly Review 7/04/03 Searches 2130
Weekly Review 7/11/03 Searches 2838
Weekly Review 7/18/03 Searches 1448
Weekly Review 7/25/03 Searches 1802
Weekly Review 8/01/03 Searches
Weekly Review 8/08/03 Searches


Standard Footer:

Find a story    Lix Web Site
Review a Story    Lix's Favorites
Story Codes & Links    Email Lix
Author Snippet (a.k.a. Author's "Rate/Review" Button)   
Project Notes    Back to Top

First Published: 2003-04-12 Last Update: 2003-07-31
- End of Search and Review System - -- http://www.fastmail.fm - Access your email from home and the web