Eric Stewart drove carefully home on the evening of Nov. 8. If he got a
traffic ticket, he would pay it, but the others in his office might find
out anyway. When you prosecute in traffic court, a ticket could be an
embarrassment. With the weather blustery and wet, driving carefully was
a good idea, anyway. When he got to his apartment, the answering machine
was blinking. The third message was from Carolyn. They were in choir
together, and he was godfather to one of her sons.
Eric? This is Carolyn Pierce. I've something related to your job. Could
you call me at home after 5:00? Thanks."
'Why me?' he thought. Everybody in Chicago had a friend who could fix
things. Want a tree removed from in front of your house or a pothole
fixed? You didn't call the city, you spoke to a friend who had a friend
who could get the job done. Well, if cop fixed a traffic ticket, it was
a minor offense even if someone interested in stopping it found out. If
a prosecutor fixed a traffic ticket, it was a conflict-of-interest
violation of legal ethics. Guys did it, but he knew he'd be caught if
he did it. When there was no other way out, he paid his friends'
fines rather than take the risk of fixing their tickets. He just hoped
it wasn't DUI. That required court appearance; you couldn't just pay the
fine. Well, he called Carolyn and she answered.
Who has the ticket?"
Nothing like that," she said. "I have a student in class who was raped.
She needs to talk with somebody. She's balking at cops, but she said
okay when I said I knew somebody in the States Attorney's Office."
'Why me?' He was in the States Attorney's Office, but not in the sex-crimes section.
Raped in class?" That didn't sound possible. "Your class?"
No. She's in my class three days a week, but she wasn't there when she
was raped. Apparently, it was after a dance." That sounded more
possible, if less attractive to prosecute.
Date rape?"
Yeah."
It's not really my department, Carolyn."
Yeah. And my job description for teaching doesn't involve law
enforcement, either. But she came to me, and I tried to do something.
Can you talk to her? I thought here." Well, Carolyn had asked him to be
Paul's godfather. He enjoyed the boys, and he could do something for a
friend of a friend after all.
Well, the longer it waits, the worse it looks. When did it happen?"
Saturday."
Ouch. You want it there? Tonight?" He might not prosecute rape cases,
but he heard gossip from guys that did. The ideal victim screamed while
it occurred. Preferably the victim was a white girl on the way home from
church; the perp was a black stranger with a record; the location was a
dark alley.
I don't think I could get her tonight. Tomorrow? I'll serve you some
dinner."
And twin time?" Might as well get something out of it.
That's no problem. Tomorrow, Bill will go to the finance-committee
meeting." Bill tended to prefer dealing with the kids himself. Carolyn
was always willing to have somebody else deal with them.
Okay. Six?"
Thanks, Eric. I owe you one." Or he owed her one less.
Tuesday, he considered raising the issue with Margaret Murphy, the head
prosecutor for rapes. He didn't, however, have any firm information,
even the name. He'd speak to Murphy when he could tell her something. He
left the office on the dot. When he got to the Pierce home, he couldn't
see which cars, if any, were in the garage. He parked on the street
instead of blocking the driveway. Before he got to the door, though, he
heard kids' screams. That sounded like Bill was home. He rang the bell,
and Bill came to the door while carrying John upside down.
States Attorney's Office," he said. "We have reports of serious child
abuse here."
Well," Bill said, "they abuse us horribly, but nobody here is serious."
He came in and closed the door. "This is Miss Wharton." Carolyn had
said that she had a student, and she'd said that the student had been
raped. She hadn't said that the student was a stunning beauty.
Eric Stewart. I'm sorry for the humor. I didn't know you were here yet.
I'm Paul's godfather as well the position you've heard about." He was
babbling, and he hung his parka in the closet to hide his confusion.
Well, there were the boys as a focus of attention to avoid the other
problems. Soon, there was a dinner, too. Bill sat at the head of the
table. Carolyn, as usual, sat with her back to her picture and the boys
sat between them. Miss Wharton sat between Bill and him. She had a
lovely profile, and she turned her attention from the food to the kids
and back again. She barely looked at him.
After Bill left for the meeting of the finance committee, he took the
boys into the downstairs john to wash their hands. Then they all sat on
the sofa to read some books. Miss Wharton stayed to help Carolyn clear.
Then they both came in to watch him and the boys. Finally, Carolyn
called time.
The boys kissed him good night, and then kissed Miss Wharton good night.
He was a little jealous of them. Miss Wharton called the boys by name. A
lot of people got them confused. It seemed to him that it was more myth
than experience. 'They're twins. So there is no way to tell them apart.'
There were all sorts of ways to tell them apart, even physically.
Behaviorally, it was even easier. His godson was the leader. He kissed
Miss Wharton first, which meant that he saw that kiss as desirable.
Well, Uncle Eric agreed.
She wants me down here before the conversation gets serious," Carolyn
said. Well, they should discuss something else while the boys dawdled.
'have you always been such a beauty?' might not be appropriate. He
finally thought of something.
Well, Without getting into anything substantial, maybe I could get some
background. You're a student of Mrs. Pierce?"
Yeah. Freshman Economics."
You're a freshman?"
Yeah."
18?" The age of the victim -- especially a teen-age victim -- was
important in rape cases. That wasn't a personal question.
19. I had my birthday this September. You're a states attorney?"
Finally, an answer which didn't feel like pulling teeth. And while it
was generally more polite to talk about the girl than about himself, she
probably dreaded the talking about herself which would come up all too
soon.
An assistant states attorney. The States Attorney is Carey. Illinois is
divided into judicial districts, most of them covering more than one
county. Cook is nearly half the state, population-wise, and the district
court is about the largest court of first instance in the nation. The
States Attorney's office handles all the prosecutions for any criminal
cases in the county, not counting federal prosecutions." He was sounding
like a civics text, but he didn't know what else to say. "We go from
parking tickets to murder. There are one hell of a lot of us, and we
mostly specialize. I don't handle..." She had specifically asked to
avoid the subject of rape until Carolyn came back. "That is to say, I
prosecute traffic cases." What else was there to say? "When I'm not in
the office, I sing in the church choir with Mrs. Pierce and am godfather
to Paul." She wasn't going to help. Maybe he should read Horton
to her until Carolyn got back.
What other courses do you take?" he asked finally. She looked
comfortable answering his factual questions as long as he stayed off the
recent past. Finally, Carolyn started down the stairs. Well, how should
the questioning be set up. They damn-well didn't want Miss Wharton --
what was her name anyway? -- facing a panel consisting of Carolyn and
himself.
Look, you want her present. Do you want her close?" She nodded. "Why
don't you and she take the sofa while I get a chair?" When he was well
away from the sofa, she went to it. He got a dining-room chair and sat
in it. Carolyn sat down far enough from Miss Wharton to establish the
latter's independence, but close enough to be available.
Look," he began, "this is painful. I know it. But it's not going to get
less painful with more delay."
Mrs. Pierce tells me that you were raped, he continued. "Tell me about
it."
I was stupid..." That was the wrong way to begin. She was blaming
herself, and the defense -- in the unlikely chance that this got to
trial -- would be blaming her. She should start out blaming the perp.
You were, are, a college freshman," he explained. "That's not being
stupid; it might be being less cautious than an older woman might be.
That's not the point. Where were you? Who was with you? What did he do?
Start where you want. If I need more details, I'll ask for them."
I was at a dance with this boy. He had taken me there on a date. On the
way home, he invited me to his apartment for a drink. I said yes.
Anyway, one thing led to another. We were making out. I wanted him to
stop, but he wouldn't." He could picture it, but she hadn't articulated
the key details.
Did you tell him to stop? When?"
When he took my panties off, and my pantyhose." He could see it, and he
wished he couldn't. "He ignored me. Then, later, I found that he was
naked, too. I tried to stop him, but I couldn't."
He wouldn't stop?"
No."
You told him to stop?" That was one of the requirements.
Yes."
There was intercourse? He was inside you?"
Yes."
Okay. That's rape. Unless, of course, you're married to him."
I'm not." She was serious. He'd been too lawyerly.
I didn't think you were. It's just the law. If you don't like that,
write your state legislator. Anyway, you've been saying 'he.' What was
his name?"
Jerry Lambert."
BMOC," Carolyn said suddenly.
Like Prof. Pierce says, he's important." She started to tear up. Well,
he had enough to take to Murphy. He wouldn't push her, except maybe for
her first name. But she didn't know he wasn't going to push. She cried
and Carolyn held her. After a bit, Carolyn looked like she was shielding
the girl from him.
Look," he said, "I'm not the enemy."
I didn't say you were."
No, but Mama Bear was protecting you from me. Anyway, this isn't the
end. Did you report this to the police?"
No." Well, Murphy would talk to her on what he had. Speaking of a mama
bear, that woman might appear for the state, but she felt like the
advocate for the victims. Well, this girl needed an advocate.
Well, you're going to have to tell this all over again. At least you'll
be telling it to a woman. Can I make an appointment for you?"
If you have to."
Look, I repeat. I'm not the enemy. This MF, Jerry, is. Nothing's going
to happen to him if you hide yourself away. We're not putting you
through this because we're evil. He's putting you through this because
of what he did and because that's the only way that he'll suffer at all.
Anyway, I know the woman at the States Attorney's Office you should talk
to. I don't know whether she's on trial tomorrow. How do I get in
contact with you? And when? Are you going to be home tomorrow?"
I don't want to be home. I haven't told Mom." This didn't sound good.
Well, sometime, you'll have to. Why don't you give me your phone
number, and when you'll be home tomorrow. We'll assume an appointment
sometime Thursday. I'll call you tomorrow night with the time and the
room number. You know the County Building? It's really the same building
as City Hall, only we have the east side." She wrote down the
information she asked for and handed it to him. He checked it out of
habit before pocketing it. It was a phone number and evening times.
Take my work phone, too." He gave her his card. "That way, if you call
me in the early afternoon, you can learn the appointment without my
calling you and raising questions at home."
Anyone want more desert?" Carolyn asked. Carolyn wanted to end this,
and who could blame her? He wasn't sure how to offer Miss Wharton a ride
home. "Somehow," Carolyn said, "I don't think this is the night to
suggest a few hands of gin rummy." She was being really heavy handed,
but Miss Wharton probably needed it.
You have been awfully kind already," the girl said.
I could drive you home," he said.
Really, I can..." She was scared, scared of him. He should defuse that
as much as possible.
I won't take it personally if you would rather ride in the back seat.
You have a damned good reason to be off men, but don't think of me as a
man; think of me as a driver." That got her moving. When she got
outside, though, she went to the front seat.
She was named Candy, and she lived in Belmont-Cragin. He got on the road
west, figuring to turn south at Central. Then it was time for more
conversation. He decided that the Carolyn he new was too distant from
the Carolyn she knew. The kids seemed safe, and they both liked them.
Besides, she'd separated herself from the herd there.
You really can tell the kids apart? Or was that a lucky guess?"
I can tell them apart when they're both present and standing still.
Can't you?"
That's the easy part. And they're seldom standing still, as you might
have noticed. I can tell them apart. It's just that lots of people
can't. After all, I'm Paul's godfather. I can't wait 'til the boys see
the movie. I'll hear about it then. As I said, the hard part is getting
them to stand still."
You seem to have had no problem getting to stand still -- sit still --for their books. Prof. Pierce seems proud of them." And that was an
understatement.
She is. She has been from their birth, if also a tiny bit overwhelmed.
You saw the picture?" She'd been sitting facing it for the meal. Bill
had taken Carolyn to the portrait studio with her doctoral robes and the
twins.
Yeah."
She wrote her dissertation while carrying twins. Bill is proud as punch
about that accomplishment -- those accomplishments. Bill was notorious
in the church for cuddling other people's babies. Then she gave him two
of his own. He hasn't quite given up other people's infants, but he is
still a hands-on parent. I may tease him about abuse, but the boys not
only love him, they love his treatment of them."
Yeah. He was holding them upside-down when you came."
Carolyn," -- that wasn't a good name for discussing her with a student
-- "You call her Prof. Pierce, don't you?" She nodded. "Prof. Pierce
would really prefer a little less roughness. The boys love it, though.
They try to get me to pick them up that way. I don't trust my strength
enough. They're head down over a floor, and they wiggle like mad.
Theologically, I'm supposed to have a special relationship with Paul.
Actually, I try to treat both the boys equally." He did, sometimes, spin
around while holding one boy right-side-up. That was the extent of his
physical play. They knew he did better at reading books to them.
They continued in that vein. The conversation was fine, great
considering the occasion, and the trip was uneventful. Parking was
scarce on Fletcher, her street, but that only meant that he walked her
to her door.
That night, he had a wet dream starring Candy. This was disturbing, but
he showered the evidence off in the morning and went on with his day.
Before going to court, he managed to get a short conversation with Miss
Murphy.
Last night, I spoke with the victim of an unreported rape. I sort of
promised her that I would get her an interview with you."
When?"
The rape was Saturday, Saturday night almost certainly."
She should have reported it earlier. Do you know what a defense
attorney would make of that."
I know. She definitely should have taken advice of counsel. These girls
never take lawyers along on their dates. I can't see why." Murphy
glared, but then she relented. She wouldn't piss on him if he were on
fire, but she would go out of her way for any victim.
Okay. I'll see her. At least, we can get it reported. You know what's
hell? The best thing that you can do to lower rape occurrences is to get
them reported. Getting them reported raises rape statistics. Politicians
are loathe to do that, for obvious reasons. I'll see when today I can
clear my schedule."
I'm not in good contact with her. Can you look on your schedule for
tomorrow?"
Don't you have a phone for her?"
She's a student and at college now, Circle. I have her home phone.
She's skittish as hell."
Yeah. The victims feel a lot more guilt than the perps."
Well, I haven't seen the perp. She's feeling guilt, and shame, and
fear."
And anger?"
I didn't see any." Candy was a good woman, and a frightened girl. He
would have been happier to see some anger. He gave Murphy what he had,
including Candy's address and phone.
When he got back from court to the office to eat his lunch, the time of
the Thursday appointment was on his desk. Candy called soon thereafter.
She said that she would keep the appointment.
Sunday, Carolyn and he didn't discuss the matter in choir. He still
hadn't heard anything about Candy. When he got back from court Tuesday,
he decided to ask. The woman cop outside Murphy's office, said she had a
negotiation with a defense attorney. She'd tell Murphy that he wanted to
talk with her and call when she was available. The call came about 5:20.
The sex-crimes section worked late more often than traffic did, but he
got caught up on some reports while he waited.
Sorry to keep you, Margaret," he said. "But I started this, and I
wanted to know how it came out. Is there anything you can tell me about
the Walton case?"
There is now no Walton case. The perp denied it, claimed consent."
You believed him?"
I never talked to him. You know the issue isn't what I believe, but
what I can prove. I'd catch hell if I went before a grand jury with
this."
But you believed her?"
What wasn't to believe? She said she went back to his apartment with
him. She drank with him. She had foreplay with him. Look, we don't see
many false claims. Maybe daddy comes home too soon and darling daughter
tells him it was rape, but that doesn't get to the cops, much less here.
There is damn little upside for a false police report of rape. And, if a
woman is going to lie about it, she'd lie about saying no much earlier
than this woman claims to have said no."
Yeah, Her first words to me were that she'd been stupid."
Yeah, Truer words were never spoken. Hell of it is, what she described
sounded smooth. It wasn't fumbling which didn't stop soon enough. It
sounded like the perp had planned to rape her. Probably I put that too
brutally, but he planned to have sex with her willing or not -- had
considered how to deal with her unwillingness. Now, if I can't prove
rape with him denying it, I sure can't prove that degree of
premeditation. She doesn't even allege it, and if she did, she wouldn't
have any grounds."
Smooth operator. Sheet?"
Traffic is all -- your section." If the guy was a serial rapist, he
hadn't been reported before. For all the pain that Candy had gone
through reporting him, that would be one thing she had done. "That's
part of why we can't take it to the grand jury. No priors, he fucking-well took her home afterwards."
He did?"
Smart perp. Girl had been raped; she was in a section of town she
didn't know; it was after midnight. Her choice was accepting his ride or
catching a bus. Were the buses in that neck of the woods still running?
If so, where were they? If she was carrying cab fare, she still would
have to had find a cab in a strange neighborhood that might not, for all
she knew, have many cabs. He offered, and she accepted. But play defense
attorney with that fact: 'Now, Miss Walton. You say that you and Mr.
Lambert had sex late Saturday night or early Sunday morning. After that
sex, did Mr. Lambert drive you home? About how long after the sex act
would you say that you got in his car with him?' The jury, assuming we
got an indictment, would never believe she'd been raped."
Well, thanks."
For what? And I should thank you for what? You did the right thing, at
least sitting on it would have been the wrong thing, but it's not going
to do the perp any harm unless a second girl reports him. I heard one
more sad story I'm not going to be able to do anything about."
He left Murphy to her bitterness and drove home. He was fairly bitter
himself. The prettiest girl he'd seen in a long while, the prettiest
girl he'd really met as an adult, was now out of his life. And she was
frightened of him, had good cause to be frightened of men. He had her
address and phone number, but not the slightest excuse for calling her.
Thursday night, he got back from court to find a note. Carolyn had
called from her office. He called back.
Economics, prof. Pierce."
Carolyn?"
Eric. They said you were on trial. I didn't even know that you'd been
arrested."
It means involved in the courtroom. Not only defendants are on trial;
so are counsel." Was he being pedantic?
Anyway. What's going on at your end with the Candy Walton deal. I'll
tell you somebody's throwing some weight around at my end. Are you
feeling the heat there, too?"
No. Get some perspective." Things could get fixed. This was Cook
County. A Thompson relative, even a Daley relative despite the politics,
was likely to walk. But a basketball star of a second-rank basketball
school? "He might well be a big man on campus as you said. He's
not a big man in the county. Fixing a rape is as hard as fixing a
murder, maybe harder considering Miss Murphy. Anyway, there is no reason
for anyone to throw his weight around. She spoke to Murphy, and then she
filed a police report. The perp denied it, and there wasn't much else
the cops could do. Some people are bad witnesses, and Candy is one."
They didn't believe her?" That wasn't what he'd said, and that wasn't
what he wanted her to believe. In the first place she should
believe Candy; Candy needed her. In the second place, if she thought
that the States Attorney's Office was doubting Candy, Candy might get
the message and think that he doubted her.
Oh, they, that is to say Murphy, believed her implicitly. What she
didn't believe is that she could convince a jury. Some very bad people
are good witnesses; some very good people are bad witnesses. Anyway,
there is a police report on file. The next time he rapes some woman, the
cops will pull the file and know that neither report is bogus."
Assuming, of course, that the next woman reports it." Carolyn had hit
the nail on the head.
Yeah. Murphy thought that he was a repeat offender, and Candy was just
the first girl brave enough to come forward. This was, however,
speculation. She would never go to the grand jury with that."
The weekend and the next week went without any communication about
Candy, however second-hand or however negative. Wednesday, he took out
Candy's phone number. He had not one God-damned excuse for calling, but
he stared at the phone for an hour before putting the number away. That
night, he saw the rape in vivid detail in a dream. It was a wet dream,
and he awoke covered with sweat as well as other fluids.
Sunday, though, she was in church. Carolyn hadn't been in choir, and
Gladys had said that she had a guest in church. From the choir loft, he
saw her and Bill with several women, and one of them looked like Candy
from that distance. After the service, he stopped on his way to the
choir room to see if he were dreaming, and he wasn't.
Uncle Eric, Uncle Eric," the boys said. Paul held out his hand to be
swung around.
Now, you're in your church clothes, and so am I. Church after service
is not the time nor the place."
I owe you an explanation," he said to Candy. "Let me get this robe back
to the choir room, and I'll drive you home. I can explain on the way."
We're taking her to lunch," a girl said. She was Claire something, a
grad student whom he'd seen at coffee hour.
Well, I can do that." Indeed, he would be happy to take Candy to lunch.
But Candy turned to Claire.
You are?" she asked.
The 3 of us." There were 2 other girls with Carolyn and Bill. One of
them was Jane, another grad student. He didn't know the other.
Thanks," Candy said to Claire. "Sorry," she said to him. She didn't
sound particularly sorry. He watched the group leave, and went to trade
his robe for his parka. Well, he'd blown that one. On second thought, it
wasn't too awful. He had established that he expected to give her an
explanation.
Maybe he could call her. If he did, though, she would want the
explanation over the phone. If he called her to set up a time to give
her the explanation in person, she would suspect that he wanted the
meeting more than he wanted to give the explanation.
The next Sunday, Candy was back in church. He hadn't seen her from the
choir loft, and he almost missed her. Normally, he went out the outside
entrance from the basement with others who didn't have family waiting
upstairs. Today, that entrance opened onto a mushy puddle, and he went
up the inside stairs. There she was, waiting for him at the top.
Actually, she looked vaguely startled when he greeted her. She had
probably been waiting for Carolyn, but Carolyn had 3 family members to
greet, and he could deal with Candy.
Miss Wharton." He finished climbing the stairs and walked closer. "I
still owe you an explanation. Do you have something else scheduled for
this afternoon?" Was Joan going to invite her to lunch again? The girls
looked at each other.
Well, if you have something to tell me..." Candy said. That was the
acceptance, now for the practics.
Wait here. My car's two blocks away, and the weather's miserable." He
got the car and turned on the heat before driving to the spot in front
of the church. The loading zone was always busy on Sunday noon, and he
had to wait for Charlie while his family piled into the sedan. Then he
pulled into the spot and went for Candy. As she was already out the door
and coming towards him, he merely opened the door for her. He pulled
out, marshaling his thoughts.
"Just a second," he said. Traffic was tricky, if slow, and he was
heading north. He got them in the right direction and stopped for a
traffic light.
The short answer, he began, "is that the office has decided not to
prosecute."
She didn't believe me?" Her voice sounded ashamed, and she was taking
this as further punishment -- punishment from his side, too.
Miss Murphy believed you 100%. 'What,' she asked me, 'is there to
disbelieve?' What she doesn't believe is that she could convince a jury.
And, to be fair to the jury, they're supposed to require evidence beyond
a reasonable shadow of a doubt. You say one thing; the perp says
something else, and unless all 12 are convinced beyond a reasonable
shadow of a doubt, the perp walks."
Perp?" He'd been using the office term.
Sorry. Professional jargon. Perpetrator, the guy who did it. Anyway, do
you eat Chinese?" If Claire could take her to lunch, so could he. She
was thinking, not rejecting it, but not accepting it yet. He doubted
that she would have accepted faster if he'd said Italian. "I gave you
the short answer. There is a longer one, and you deserve it."
Well..." Another long pause. "Thank you." So he got them to the
restaurant. She was out of the car before he came around, but she let
him seat her at the restaurant. The order was a more comfortable topic
for both of them, but his excuse for the time with her was his report.
Okay." he resumed when they had ordered. "The Perp said it was
consensual. Do we believe it? Does Miss Murphy believe it? Not by a long
shot, but what lawyers believe and what they can prove are two very
different things."
What should I have done differently?" She was still feeling guilty.
Murphy was probably right. She was feeling guiltier than the mother
fucker was.
Aside from not going on a date with the guy in the first place? You
should have definitely acted on legal advice." He was trying to show her
how ridiculous her guilt was. "If you'd had a lawyer with you on the
date, he would have told you that when you said 'no,' you should have
screamed it. At least the second time you said 'no' should have been a
scream. When you got up and got dressed you should have knocked on all
the doors of other apartments and asked them to call the police. You
knock on a stranger's door late at night, and they're reluctant to let
you in. They'll usually call the police.
I'll be blunt," he continued. It wasn't Candy's fault. It was the
mother fucker's fault, and it was a little the police's fault, too.
"You're robbed and you report it the next morning, they'll investigate.
You're raped and you report it later, the police are more reluctant to
act. In that, for all you waited too long, for all that I'm a weird guy
to talk to, you finally got to Miss Murphy. An ASA asks the cops to
investigate, and they investigate. And, from her standpoint of course,
there's always the chance that the perp will break down. 'I didn't mean
to do it. I don't know what came over me. I'm terribly sorry.' The weird
thing is that the guys with consciences are serving time while your sort
of perp is walking."
My sort?" Not 'her sort' her sort of perp.
Well, the guy who attacked you. Others like him." Okay, let's get this
more general. "You ever watch a TV show with a murder trial?"
Yeah."
Well, in any prosecution, you have to prove two things. You have to
prove that the crime occurred, and you have to prove that the defendant
did it. Usually, not always, one of those is a piece of cake. The TV
shows don't handle the dull part. The guy is blown nearly in half by a
sawed-off shotgun. The ASA calls witnesses to testify that the guy is
dead and that the death was violent. The defense attorney says, 'No
questions, your honor.' Date rape, the issue is whether there was a
crime. 'The victim has misidentified my client as the guy with whom she
had the date,' isn't likely to fly. You know who you attended the dance
with."
Yeah." She was agreeing with something, maybe that she knew who she
dated.
So, he has two chances. He can claim that no sexual relations occurred,
or he can claim that they were consensual. The first has all sorts of
possible problems. He doesn't know what you did after you left him. So,
the smart perp goes with the second. He might have had legal advice,
though I doubt it. Generally, you don't quite tell your lawyer that you
did the crime. Most of them know, but you don't tell him."
If they know, don't they have to tell?"
Not really. Lawyer-client confidentiality. On the other hand, there are
ethical problems with bringing somebody to the witness stand when you
know that he is lying. So, you tell your client to not tell you
outright. 'If you can produce someone to testify that you were somewhere
else when the robbery occurred, that will counteract the eyewitnesses --
somebody who knows you well.' So there is an alibi. You haven't told him
to lie about the alibi, but you wouldn't bet on the accuracy, either."
Sounds cynical."
Is cynical. Prosecutors play defense lawyer all the time, but we don't
like them. On the other hand, they don't like us, either. And the rest
of the world doesn't like any lawyer. 'I practice corporate law, but I
tell my kids I'm a pimp so they won't be ashamed of me.'"
You have children?" That had been a lawyer joke, and she hadn't got ii.
He definitely spent too much of his time with lawyers.
No, and I don't practice corporate law either. That was a silly joke.
Sorry." Then the food came, and they talked about that.
Thank you, Mr. Stewart," she said after the meal. Well, he was still
'Mr. Stewart.' He'd had one meal with her. That meal had used up his
excuse, and he really doubted that he could make up another. She was
happy talking about the twins, but she would think him weird to suggest
a meeting to discuss them. Go for broke; he didn't have anything to lose
but his chains.
Look, as I said, the case isn't going forward, right?"
Yeah."
That means you don't have any business with the States Attorney's
office any more?"
No."
So, you don't have any business with Mr. Stewart." He took a deep
breath. "Do you think you could call me 'Eric'?"
Thanks, Eric." And 'Eric' got less formal wording than 'Mr. Stewart'
did. Well, push forward.
I know you're not the greatest fan of the male sex, right now. Do you
think that you might be ready to go out to eat with a guy sometime?"
And the guy you have in mind?" She got it.
Yeah. I was thinking of me. You already had one meal with me, and I
didn't crawl over the table to attack you." While she had reason to fear
and distrust men, he was somewhat safer. On the other hand, she went to
a school full of guys closer to her age and interests. On the other --
maybe the third -- hand, she didn't know how the younger guy would react
to the news she'd been raped; she didn't have to worry about telling
him.
Is this because you think...?" Shit! She thought he was setting her up.
That was the other side of not having to tell him; he knew and she
thought he was judging her as a fallen woman. Did women fall in 1979?
I might not be the brightest guy in the world," he said, "but I'm not a
total idiot, either. If I were after sex, you would be the last woman in
the world I'd pursue. Nuns and married women would be more available. I
know that. It's just that you're quite attractive. I feel a total heel
pressing you right now. I know I met you for the absolutely wrong
reason. But I did meet you. You came into my life. If you're going to go
out of it, it's fucking well not going to be because I didn't try." She
didn't respond. He'd lost her, but he'd never really had a chance with
her.
Now, I've offended you," he finished. He'd finished his statement. Had
he finished the relationship?
Well, no," she said. "It's nothing about you. I'm just not ready, yet."
Well, that was clear.
I'll tell you what. I don't want to be your stalker. That's something
that you don't need right now, and I don't think they ever win, anyhow.
Sometimes you go to Aldersgate." He was really grasping at straws, now.
"Why don't I give you my card again. I'll write my home phone on it. The
next time you want to go to church, if you want me to drive you to
church, give me a call. I'm on trial much of the day, but I'm home most
nights, and the answering machine is on the rest of the time." She
didn't agree, but when he wrote his home number on the back of a card
and gave it to her, she took it. He walked her to her door and watched
from the bottom of the porch stairs as she walked through the door and
closed it behind her. That was closing the door on him, probably
forever.
That night, she starred in another wet dream. That would probably be his
relationship with her for the future -- she'd be in his dreams, but not
in his waking life.