0 comments/  39131 views/  6 favorites

Caitlin's Choice Ch. 01

By: PrincessErin



Caitlin walked into the outdoor chapel and was led to one of the fold out chairs on the side of the bride. She actually knew both the bride and the groom but figured it was easier to sit with the bride's family. As she looked around she was probably the only single woman at this wedding and she regretted even showing up. Mark and Sophie had been dating forever and it was only assumed that they would get married. However, it was a surprise that they chose to get married on Mark's father's island resort. Mark's father had never been a part of his life and when he chose to come back home, two years ago, everyone was surprised.

Caitlin looked around and realized that all her high school friends had grown up. It had been five years, but it seemed like an eternity. As everyone else was seated, she looked around and realized that this weekend wasn't going to be too bad. Everyone had arrived by boat on Friday afternoon and most of the guests had rushed to the beautiful beach to suntan and frolic in the water. Caitlin had chosen to settle into her room and then walk around the grounds. Her pale white skin was not used to the sun and, being a redhead, she was prone to burn, not tan like those blonde bimbos. 

It was a beautiful island with 20 small cottages circling the beach and 3 large buildings in the middle. She knew that one building had a large hall and kitchen facilities since that was where they had eaten dinner the night before. She also knew that the building on the hill was Mr. Hudson's residence. It was hard to use the word house or mansion since it was an architectural masterpiece. The third building was the staff quarters. Running an island of this size needed many workers. 

Before she knew it, the wedding began. The bride was beautiful and the groom was looking nervous, yet happy. They had written their own wedding vows and Caitlin tried hard not to smirk, wondering why it had become classy to change the way her parents and grandparents had pledged their love to each other. The bride and groom kissed and everyone clapped. It was the perfect wedding and as she made her way to the reception hall, she took one more look around. He wasn't here and she was relieved. She knew he had been invited, but Sophie had told her he hadn't accepted. Caitlin had felt like such a bitch when she had discussed this with Sophie weeks ago.

"If he's invited I'm not coming. I do not want to ever see that man again."

"Oh, come on Caitlin! I want you at my wedding. It's going to be beautiful. The Hudson estate is amazing. He has his own island in the 1000 Islands and Mark's dad said everyone can stay until the Monday."

Caitlin pouted. She knew she was being difficult, but she was stubborn like a horse.

"Has he accepted or declined?"

"He hasn't responded and I doubt he will. Mark says he's off in Australia surfing and probably won't be home for another five months."

"O.K., fine."

Caitlin sighed and realized she was being a big baby, but it didn't matter because he wasn't here and she was. She was going to enjoy the rest of the weekend.

Even though the wedding ceremony was unconventional to Caitlin's tastes, the reception was somewhat normal. It was a sit-down affair and Caitlin was seated with the wedding party's significant others. The table sat 8, yet there were only 6 at the table. To the left of her were Matt and Danny; boyfriends of the two bridesmaids. They were both lawyers. They were funny, loud, and started to get a little annoying as the night wore on and the drinks flowed freely. On Caitlin's right were Deanna, Susanna, and Marianna; the wives of Mark's groomsmen. She had gone to school with all of them and they had been the typical cheerleaders. She had remained friends with them, though she didn't approve of their lifestyle. Caitlin remembered them chatting a week before graduation and explaining that their boyfriends had better propose soon, otherwise they'd have to waste time at college. Their boyfriends had come through and all had married within the year. They were now bored housewives who spent their days together while their husbands actually worked for a living.

After the traditional cake cutting, bouquet toss, and first dance, Caitlin decided she was going to take a walk along the beach. She smiled at Sophie on the way by as she nuzzled her new husband's neck, cuddling close.

Caitlin went outside and took a deep breath of the cool crisp summer air. It was exceptionally hot this summer and she was glad she was wearing a knee length summer dress with sandals. As she got to the beach, she took off her sandals and holding them in her left hand, started to stroll along, her mind wandering to a different place. She thought of Logan and wondered if he was having fun in Australia. For some reason knowing he was so far away made her want to think of him.

"Oofff" 

Caitlin cried out as she tripped over something and landed face first in the sand. Sputtering as she sat up she looked at what she had stepped on. Lying in the sand was Logan, stretched out, as he looked up at the stars.

Caitlin's Choice Ch. 02



"Jesus Christ, woman! Watch where you're going!" 

Logan had been minding his own business and enjoying the nighttime stars when suddenly this woman had practically run over him. She was sprawled on the sand and he instinctively grabbed her and placed her in his lap, brushing off the sand from her back and arms. The woman looked at Logan and screamed.

"Get the fuck away from me."

Sitting on his lap was his ex girlfriend from high school, Caitlin. Both were attending a friend's wedding and he had tried very hard to stay away from her since he had arrived on the island this morning. He had succeeded up until this point.

Caitlin and Logan had dated all through high school and everyone thought they were going to get married. Two days after graduation he had called her and asked her to meet him at their special place. She had gotten so excited, thinking that he was going to propose. Instead, he had broken up with her. She had run home crying, packed her bags, and gone up to her parent's cottage for the summer. She had spent one day at home packing up for college and hadn't been home since.

She stood up and stumbled, but regained her balance as she looked down at Logan. By this time Logan had stood up, more to get out of the way of the fiery redhead who he knew all too well.

"You're supposed to be in Australia."

"There is no way I was going to miss Mark and Sophie's wedding. I have been trying to stay the fuck away from you and I was successful until you practically ran me over."

Caitlin scowled. She hated when he was right and that made her even angrier. 

"You shouldn't be lying on the beach in the dark."

"Well you shouldn't be walking down the beach in the dark."

Before she had a chance to respond Logan had stormed off. She stood there stunned and confused. She thought five years of keeping herself busy would make her forget, but it didn't. The moment they were together it was as heated and angry as always. Caitlin walked slowly back to her cottage and tried to figure out why she had even fallen in love with Logan. All she could remember were the fights; the yelling and screaming.

As she walked towards her cottage, her heart began to race and she could feel her temper flaring. Logan was standing on the doorstep. Before she had a chance to say anything, he spoke.

"You have a two bedroom cottage and this is the only room free on the island. Mark told his dad it was O.K. since we know each other. Lets just get inside and go to bed. I'm leaving in the morning so if you sleep in, like you always do; you won't have to see me again."

"Fine."

Caitlin unlocked the door, marched right to her bedroom door, and slammed it shut. Logan rolled his eyes as he got ready for bed.

***

Caitlin rolled over and opened her eyes. Instead of the bright sun entering her window, all she saw was dark clouds. She could hear the rain hitting the ground outside and as she sat up and rubbed her eyes, the events of last night flooded back into her head. Getting up she opened her bedroom door to go to the washroom. The first thing she saw was Logan sitting in a chair reading a magazine.

"Before you say anything the storms created waves that were so bad they damaged the boat. Until the storm clears and the boat is repaired no one is going anywhere."

Logan didn't wait for Caitlin to respond. He looked back down at his magazine and continued to read.

Caitlin got dressed and attempted to make her way to the dining hall without getting totally soaked. As she entered the building, she could smell the eggs, hash browns, and waffles. Finding an empty table, she began to eat.

"Hey Caitlin. Sucks that we're stuck here and it's raining."

Deanna took a seat across from Caitlin and they began to chat. Caitlin realized that Deanna wasn't that annoying and she was actually pretty smart. Once she finished breakfast, she excused herself.

"I think I'm just going to go back to my cottage and do some writing."

Deanna nodded. Caitlin did up her rain jacket and ventured out into monsoon. By the time she got to her cottage, she was soaked. She entered the cottage and saw that Logan was still in the same spot, but instead of reading a magazine he had his laptop open and was doing some work. Caitlin got her laptop out and did the same. They worked for hours without speaking. Finally Caitlin looked up at Logan.

"Why did you break up with me?"

Logan closed his laptop and moved to sit next to Caitlin. His eyes were full of sorrow and his mind was trying to figure out the best way to respond.

"Do you really want the truthful answer?"

"Of course I do. Don't be silly. I'm an adult now. I think I can handle the truth."

"I got Stacey pregnant." 



Caitlin's Choice Ch. 03



Caitlin sat stunned on the couch and tried to process what Logan had said to her. She had been invited to her friend's wedding and was now stuck on the god-forsaken island until the boat was fixed. Of course the only reason it was god- forsaken was because her ex boyfriend, only ex boyfriend to be precise, was on the same island and as luck would have it, had been assigned to share the same cottage.

"You did what?"

"I got Stacey pregnant."

Logan was sitting on the coffee table facing her as he waited for a response. This was a secret he had kept for five long years and he really wasn't sure what made him finally tell her. He had gone off with some friends one weekend and although he would have liked to blame the beer, it really had been how seductive and slutty Stacey had acted. He didn't remember a lot about that night other than waking up the next morning with Stacey cuddled close to his side. He had left quickly and when Stacey approached him, he had admitted what a big mistake she had been. Two weeks later she announced she was pregnant and Logan knew there was only one thing he could do.

"I broke up with you because I knew you'd take off to the cottage and that way you wouldn't have to deal with the evil gossip."

"Oh so you did that for my benefit. You broke my fucking heart, Logan."

Caitlin's bottom lip was quivering and he knew she was close to tears. He was always a sucker when she started to cry. He did the only thing that he knew to stop her from crying. He kissed her.

Caitlin responded by kissing him back. His warm lips felt so good on hers and before she knew it he had picked her up and placed her on his lap as he sat back on the couch.

"I hate you."

Caitlin hissed these words as her hands fumbled to undo his shorts. Logan groaned as she did this and was trying to undo her bra without success. They had only had sex a few times before they had broken up, but the most intense sessions were when one or both of them were angry. It was like they were getting their frustrations out by cumming so hard. Most times it worked and they had laid breathless and sweaty on her parents basement futon or the single bed in his room.

"Fuck, you feel good."

Logan was grinding against her hard as he finally undid her bra. Pulling off her shirt and bra he latched onto her light pink nipple and sucked. He had always loved her breasts. They were larger then normal, soft, and so sensitive. Finally getting his shorts undone, her hand wrapped around his cock and stroked hard. Logan arched his back and tried desperately to hold back. It had been years since anyone had done that to him and he was trying so hard not to cum.

Logan and Caitlin looked into each other's eyes. They stared at each other and saw pure animalistic lust. Caitlin was the first to come back to earth and realize what she was doing.

"We shouldn't. I hate you."

"You're right. Or we can and forget it in the morning."

Both nodded that Logan's suggestion was better and he stood up, carrying Caitlin to his bedroom. Throwing her on the bed, he stripped naked; revealing his hard throbbing cock. She was undressing as fast as she could and the moment they were both naked he was on top of her, kissing her soft warm lips. She didn't even notice him guiding his member into her until he pressed hard and filled her fully. She cried out and moaned as he started fucking her senseless.

It was rough, hard, and exactly what both of them needed. Flipping them over, she dug her teeth into his neck and bucked wildly on top of him. Logan closed his eyes and let this red haired vixen work her magic. His cock throbbed and he wanted to cum inside her.

"Baby, I'm close. Tell me where to cum."

Logan hissed as she bucked down harder and didn't stop her grinding. He threw his head back and orgasmed hard.

"Fuck me until I cum."

Caitlin hissed at Logan, demanding he keep going. Realizing she hadn't cum yet he grabbed her hips and yanked her back and forth. Caitlin cried out as she came, her whole body shaking.

They lay panting on his bed, trying to recover. Caitlin finally looked up at Logan.

"I still hate you, but god that felt good."

"I know. Now get off me. I have work to do."

Caitlin smirked and rolled off him, letting him get dressed and get back to work. She did the same and before long they were sitting in the living room working on their laptops. They didn't speak to each other, but the sexual tension that had been building was gone.

Later that day they received a call announcing that the boat was fixed and anyone wanting to leave the island could do so. The rain had not stopped since early that morning and the majority of the guests, including Logan and Caitlin, took the boat ride back to the mainland. As they stood in the parking lot, Caitlin bit her lip nervously.

"You still broke my heart Logan. You're not forgiven."

With that, Caitlin walked off towards her car and drove off. If she never saw him again, it would be too soon.

Later that evening, as Caitlin was unpacking her toiletries, she opened her medicine drawer and gasped. She bit her lip as tried to think carefully. Lying in the drawer was the unopened package of birth control pills. 



Caitlin's Choice Ch. 04



Caitlin paced her bedroom as she glanced at the bathroom door. It had been four weeks since Mark and Sophie's wedding and she wished she could forget the disaster of the weekend. She had been told her ex boyfriend Logan was in Australia, but he had shown up anyway and instead of meeting in a respectful way, she had fallen ass over teakettle over his legs as she tried to take a nice walk on the beach. They had been assigned to share the same two-bedroom cottage and she really didn't remember the details, but she knew that in the past, when the two of them were angry and frustrated -- watch out because the sex was hot and intense. They had agreed to pretend that afternoon never happened and they had gone their separate ways. It wasn't until she got home that she realized she had forgotten to take her next set of birth control pills.

Caitlin looked at the clock and walked into the bathroom and stared at the test on the counter. She hated how cutesy those pregnancy tests looked and she sighed as she saw the 2 dark pink lines. She had known she was pregnant before she had taken the test but at least this was proof. She turned and walked to grab her cell phone, dialing his number.

"Don't hang up. It's important."

She knew that Logan was rolling his eyes as he answered his cell phone. She had no idea where in the world he was, but she needed to talk to him.

"What do you want Caitlin?"

"I was wondering if we could get together next time you're in Sandford."

Sandford was the city that Caitlin had been living in since she went off to college. The college was located in town and she loved it so much that she had stayed. Of course, not wanting to go back to her hometown and face Logan was a pretty good motivator as well.

"I'm in Sandford now."

Caitlin's blood pressure went up as Logan said that. She was trying hard not to freak out.

"Can we meet for dinner tonight. Joeys at 7pm."

"Fine."

Logan hung up and wondered what the hell was going on. He wondered if she had spoken to Stacey and found out the truth. He had wanted to tell her the whole story back at the resort, but he had chickened out. He really didn't want to relive that part of his life when he was conned out of a large sum of money from some stupid blonde. He also didn't want to tell her that he had accepted a job in Sandford and was just settling in to his new apartment.

Caitlin sat on her couch and dialed Stacey's number. She wasn't sure why she was doing this but she needed to know the whole truth from Stacey before she told Logan her news.

"Hello. Can I speak to Stacey Moore?"

Caitlin heard the phone drop and the man who answered the phone called out for Stacey to pick up the phone.

"Yah, what?"

"Stacey, I'm not sure you remember me from high school, but this is Caitlin Anderson. I know this is personal, but a month ago I met up with Logan at Mark and Sophie's wedding and he told me about you and him. I just want to know if he's taking care of you and the baby."

"What the fuck are you talking about? It wasn't Logan's baby. I just tried to milk him for some money since my fat assed boyfriend was being a dope head. He gave me $5000 and then, when Angel was born, he was smart enough to ask for a paternity test."

"Oh."

Caitlin apologized and hung up the phone. Her mind was racing as she tried to figure out what to make of this. She had been spending the last four weeks thinking that Logan was selfish and stupid and had purposely hurt her. Now she realized that he had broken up with her to shield her from his mistake and that by the time he found out it wasn't his mistake, it was too late. Caitlin knew exactly what she needed to do.

A few hours later Caitlin was seated at a table for two at Joey's, a nice seafood restaurant that she loved. She was wearing a black sweater with black pants. Her red hair was in a ponytail and she was nervously chewing her bottom lip, waiting for Logan to show up. She smiled as he entered the restaurant and made his way to the table. He was wearing gray slacks and a button up shirt.

"Hi Caitlin."

"Hi Logan. I have something to tell you. Do you want me to tell you now or wait until after dinner?"

"Tell me now."

Logan leaned back in his chair and crossed his arms over his muscular chest. Caitlin looked down at her hands and began to speak.

"I called Stacey and found out what she did to you. I feel so bad and feel like a complete bitch for thinking you were selfish and mean. I have no idea how to say sorry and I know that even at the wedding I was rude and selfish. I'm pregnant. I was on the pill, but I guess with going to the island and everything I forgot to take some of the pills. I don't expect you to do anything and considering what Stacey did to you___"

Caitlin was cut off as Logan slid his hand over her mouth.

"I never stopped loving you. You know that and I accept your apology. We're going to have a baby?"

"Yeah. Aren't you mad?"

"Let's eat dinner and let me think about it."

Caitlin and Logan ate dinner with only small chitchat about random things. She could see he was thinking and she wondered what he was going to say. After paying for dinner, they walked towards the parking lot where he had parked his silver sports car next to her red sedan. Leaning against his car he looked at Caitlin.

"I love you."

Caitlin's eyes filled with tears as the roller coaster of emotions she was feeling explode. She collapsed in his arms and sobbed. Logan wrapped his arms tight around her and held her until she had composed herself.

"You're coming home with me."

As they walked into his small apartment, he guided her to the bedroom and sat her down on the bed.

"We never made love together. It was always sex or fucking. Tonight, let me do this."

Caitlin nodded and they slowly undressed in front of each other. Once naked, he leaned her back on the bed and kissed every inch of her body. His lips brushed her collarbone and nibbled down between her breasts before capturing each nipple in his mouth and sucking softly. Caitlin moaned and whimpered, not used to this speed of seduction. Logan nestled himself between her legs and slid his tongue up and down her pussy lips. He tasted her juices and opening her wider, flicked his tongue against her clit which was hard and throbbing.

She was thrashing around, begging for him to be inside her. He continued his assault on her pussy, bringing her so close to orgasm and then slowing down. Just as she was on the peak, he stopped and sat up. Her eyes said it all. She was in love and full of complete lust, desperate for him. He guided himself inside her and held himself there.

"I love you."

"I love you more."

They kissed as he thrusted slowly, but forcefully, in and out of her pussy. Suddenly she was cumming and it was so intense that she brought him with her. Both of them were moaning and panting. Their bodies shaking as they experienced such a high, they could barely speak.

As they lay intertwined on the bed Logan looked over at Caitlin.

"So where do you want to get married?"

"What!"

Caitlin sat up and her eyes were burning with anger.

"After all that, you propose to me like that. As if!"

Caitlin sat up and started grabbing her clothes. Logan let her storm off since he knew that anything he said would make it worse and for once he did the right thing by letting her cool off.



Caitlin's Choice Ch. 05



Caitlin waited at the park. She was sitting on a park bench and had to lean back a bit since her jeans were snug. She was only three months along and she was refusing to buy any maternity clothing for at least two more months. Her boyfriend Logan had told her to meet him there and he was 15 minutes late. She rolled her eyes and realized he was never on time.

If someone had told her three months ago that she would get back together with her boyfriend from high school and that she would be pregnant with his baby, she would have laughed. After breaking up, she had hated him, but she figured that old age had mellowed her and she realized that he really, truly, loved her.

Caitlin looked up and watched Logan stroll through the park. He was wearing jeans and a sweatshirt. His blond hair was long enough that the ends were starting to curl. He had a big grin on his face and she knew something was up. Logan walked over to Caitlin and, without saying a word, got down on one knee and held her hands in his. Caitlin bit her lip to control her emotions. These pregnancy hormones were driving her crazy and she cried at the drop of a hat nowadays.

"I love you Caitlin with all my heart and want to spend the rest of my life with you. You are gorgeous and smart and witty and the fact you are carrying our child makes me love you even more. I want to marry you and be with you for the rest of my life. Caitlin will you marry me?"

"Yes."

Caitlin could barely speak as Logan slid the sparkling diamond ring onto her left hand ring finger. They kissed softly and giggled.

"There. Did I do it right this time?"

"Yep."

Caitlin laughed as they hugged. The last time he had proposed it was a disaster and they had never mentioned the word "marriage" since then. She had moved into his apartment and was eagerly preparing for the birth of their son. She tried not to think of how untraditional the whole set up was. She had spent her whole life judging others on their decisions to be untraditional and here she was doing something similar. She was either going to be getting married with such a round belly that it would reach the altar before her or she was going to be getting married with her son or daughter present at the wedding. As she looked into Logan's eyes and felt his large hands caressing her belly she realized she really didn't care anymore.

***

Caitlin walked down the aisle towards her soon to be husband. She grinned as he held their son Evan in his arms. Standing in front of each other, they said their vows.

"In the presence of God, our family, and friends I offer you my solemn vow..."

"... In good times and in bad, and in joy as well as in sorrow..."

These were the same traditional vows that their parents and grandparents had said to each other. As the priest let them kiss, Caitlin first kissed Evan and then kissed her husband Logan.

After a romantic evening, they made their way to their honeymoon suite. It was their first night alone since Evan was born three months ago and they had practically run to the room once all their guests had left. Logan grabbed Caitlin and carried her to the bed, unzipped her dress, and let it fall to the floor. He moaned when he saw that she was wearing a white lace bra and matching panties with thigh high stockings. He pushed her onto her back and, after undressing quickly; he rolled her on top of him and rubbed his throbbing cock against her lace panties.

Caitlin pulled her panties to the side and let Logan slide deep inside her. They had spent her entire pregnancy making love each and every day and had just recently been given the "all clear" to have intercourse again. The first few times hurt, but it got better. Caitlin pushed down hard and felt him inside her. She always loved that initial feeling of the fullness of his cock and she smiled as she rested her hands on his chest.

Logan grabbed her hip and thrusted hard and fast. He loved the feel of her pussy against his cock and he was panting hard, trying to hold back. Shifting his hands a bit he pressed his thumb against her clit and rubbed. This drove Caitlin over the edge as she started to cum. She cried out and bucked wildly on his cock. Logan grunted, flipped her over, and grabbed her hips to thrust back inside her. He watched as his cock slid in and out of her pussy. He was holding back and had it all under control until she reached and tugged his balls gently.

"Oh Fuck!"

Logan pumped hard and fast, letting all his hot fertile cum unload deep into her pussy. He grabbed her and turned her around, wrapping his arms around her body.

"You happy, baby?"

"Now I am."