2 comments/ 2857 views/ 3 favorites Two Smiles with the Same Story By: loveyou18 One smile can hide so much. ~ Two Smiles, Same Story ************** I sighed and huffed heavily as I released the heavy bar from my grip once again, making the entire floor shake. The burn and the ache grew deep inside my muscles, spreading from my shoulders to my forearms. I breathed heavily as the feeling slowly passed through me. I mouthed the lyrics to the song blasting in my ear from my earbuds, wiping off the thick layer of sweat from my face. I filled my lungs with another gasp of air, bending down, lifting the bar once again and repeat. **** I walked into the gym, heading for the treadmill. I placed my water bottle in the holder attached to the treadmill and stepped on. My ponytail swung back and forth as I started with a quick jog, escalating into a sprint. I alternated back and forth, my breathing hard and rapid and sweat dripping from my temple. I slowed down, returning into a slow walk. I looked at that same guy that I've been seeing here for a few weeks now. My mind wandered as I walked slowly on the machine, grabbing my bottle and squirting the water into my mouth. I want him. I watched as he moved to one of the machines, adding more weights to it then sitting down on it. Looks like it's shoulder day. The veins in his neck became extremely noticeable and his face reddened as he thrusted his arms out back and forth from the machine multiple times. He only seemed to gain more force each time. I would do a lot of things to him. I'd love to explore his body. **** Nine... Ten... I counted in my head as I finished my last rep. I looked up, my tank top drenched in sweat. I was met with that same girl who started coming here a few weeks ago. She's beautiful, and I've been trying to build the nerve to talk to her. I just can't seem to find it. She's probably taken, and if she isn't, she probably has tons of guys on hold for her. I'll just be another one of those guys. **** I headed to the showers. It looked like she was on her way to that as well. Should I talk to her? Or at least smile? Just to see what happens? I mean, I've been single for almost three years now. She probably isn't single. I'll just make a fool of myself. **** I closed the curtain of the shower and stood under the hot running water. I let the water run all along my chest, down my navel and to my legs, washing off the sweat from my body. I wonder what his name is, what his voice sounds like. I can see it; him in my bed, me on top, taking full power, making him moan. I have to have it. I drained the water from my hair and turned off the water, stepping out onto the towel. The steam from the shower filled my vision, and I encased myself in a fresh towel. **** I dried off my body and got changed into my fresh clothes. Maybe I will see her on the way out... Maybe I'll... I got cut off from my train of thought as I banged into... I looked up. It was her. 'Oh, I.. I'm so sorry about that,' I said, bending down to pick up my fallen wallet. She bent down with me to pick up her car keys. 'It's okay, it was my fault,' she said, picking up my wallet for me too. We both levelled out to face to face once again. Oh my gosh... She's beautiful... I took this chance to take in and notice her features. Her light brown eyes have a touch of mint green swirled into them, and are shaded by long eyelashes on the top. She has little freckles sprinkled all along her face, and her skin is in a perfect tan. Her lips are carved perfectly and stand out so much. Her wavy and brunette hair frames her slim face perfectly, and her jawline is outlined perfectly. **** His face looks so different up close. I looked at his dark and thick eyebrows that hovered over his hazel and green mixed coloured eyes. His cheek bones stick out from the sides of his face, and the rest of his jawline makes almost a triangle shape around his chin. His skin is clear, and shaded with a light tan. He's hot, handsome, and quite tall. 'What's your name?' I asked him, looking at his lips. 'Oakleigh, and yours?' he asked me, looking in my eyes. 'Catherine,' I said, forcing my eyes off his lips to look somewhere else on his face. I have never heard of that name before. Oakleigh. His voice is soft and very calm. I can tell he's been working out for years. His arms and shoulders stick out from under his tank top, and I can tell his stomach is hard as rock. 'Well, thank you for picking that up. It was nice to meet you,' he said gently. **** I was so nervous. I have to leave or else I'm going to say something stupid. Then she will never talk to me ever again. 'You too, but, I don't really want to just end it here,' she said, stopping me. My heart skipped a beat. 'You don't?' I asked her, shocked out of my mind. 'No, of course not. Are you free tonight?' she asked me, letting go of my shoulder. I pointed to myself. 'Me?' I asked. She laughed. 'Yes, you. Who else?' she said in a chuckle. 'Wow, um... Yeah, I'm free. Did you want to do something?' I asked her. 'Yeah, I do. You know the café just down the street from here?' she asked me. 'Yes,' I said. 'Why don't you meet me there at 7? I'll be there at 6:30 or so because I have some paperwork to do. But I'll be there if you'd like to join me,' she said, offering a kind smile. 'Yes, oh my gosh yes, I'll be there,' I said, trying to contain my excitement. She giggled once again, then looked into my eyes. There was a sparkle in those hazel eyes of hers. 'Good. See you then,' she said smiling, then turning the opposite way, exiting the building. I watched her ponytail swing from side to side as she left. Oh my gosh... Did that just happen?... I feel like a little boy who's crush just talked to him... I wondered what her intentions were. I wondered if she would be interested in dating, or if this is just a hangout, or if I'll ever see her ever again after this. I guess I'll just have to find out. **** I got in my car and began driving back to my place. He does seem like a nice guy, but I hate relationships. The thought of dating a guy just doesn't feel right to me... I'm sure he's a quiet and respectful guy, but I just really want to have sex with him. I need to find a way to get him to my place after the date. I don't know what he wants, I doubt it's a relationship with me, but I just really want to do things with him. Sexual things of course. **** It was just hitting 6:30 and I decided to go get changed to go meet up with Catherine. I hope to have at least some kind of connection with her. I don't want this to be just a one time thing. But I'm already falling too hard, too fast. I really just have to wait and see what happens and how it goes tonight. From outside the café, I could see Catherine inside filling out papers, just like she said she would be doing. The cool September air hit me in the face, and I held my jacket close to my neck, rushing inside. The smell of fresh coffee and baked sweets filled my nose. I walked over to the table Catherine was sitting at, and sat down across from her. She removed her ear buds and looked up at me. 'Oh hey, sorry about that, I didn't even see you coming in,' she said, putting her phone and earbuds away. 'It's okay. Is that for work or something?' I asked, looking down at the table scattered with papers. 'Yeah, but I'm all done now,' she said, collecting all the papers and placing them into one neat pile, then putting them carefully into her bag. 'Well, is there anything I can buy you? Anything you'd like?' I asked her, getting out my wallet. 'Don't be silly. I offered you to come out, I'll pay,' she said, looking up at me. 'You can pay next time if you like,' I offered her. 'Next time, I want you in my bed, not here...' **** I mumbled under my breath as I got out my wallet, hoping he didn't really hear me. 'So I'm going to go get a drink. What about you?' I asked him. He sighed. 'Fine. I guess I'll just get one of those chocolate pastries please,' he said, finally giving in. 'Perfect. I'll be right back,' I said, getting up to get what we wanted. **** Stop acting so nervous Oakleigh... She's just trying to be nice by offering to pay... It's just the beginning of the date... Just calm down. I went back and forth in my mind as I waited until she came back. She returned minutes later with her hot beverage and my chocolate pastry. 'Thank you so much,' I said, smiling. 'No worries,' she said, sitting back down. I opened up the bag and began to eat the dessert as she flipped open the plastic lid and sipped from her drink. 'So, tell me about yourself Oakleigh,' she said, looking at me. 'Well, what would you like to know?' he asked sweetly. 'A lot,' I said, looking into his eyes. 'Well, I live on Vine Street. It's quite close to here actually. I've been here my entire life. I work at a technical support group close to here too. I've been working there for about six months now,' he said, explaining himself. 'Hmm, any girls?' I asked curiously. He chuckled. 'As in girlfriends?' he asked me. I nodded. 'No of course not. I've been single for around three years now... We dated for like seven months. She left me though because she ended up liking one of her exes again,' he said, looking down. I lifted his chin back up with my finger. 'Don't worry, you'll find better,' I said. **** I looked deep into her eyes. I know I hardly know her, but there's just something about her. Something that makes me think, makes me want more already. 'Why thank you... And how about you?' I asked her. 'I prefer not to talk about my past relationships... Let's just say, there's nothing to worry about,' she said flatly. 'Oh, I'm sorry I offended you, I just...' 'It's okay, you were only asking what I had asked you,' she said, cutting me off. I looked down as she drank her beverage. The rest of the night we talked about our work and family. She works at a pet store close by. She loves animals and is super close with her family which is always great. She lives quite close to me. 'Did you walk here too?' I asked her. 'I did,' she said, collecting her papers. 'Thank you for the great night. I'll walk you home,' I said, getting up. 'Sure, I'd like that,' she said, getting up too. The walk home was quiet. The sound of the fall leaves and tress blowing was what filled the silence. What do I say, or do? Do I kiss her goodnight? Hold her hand? No... Just let it happen on its own. 'Here we are,' she said, bringing me out of my thoughts. 'Oh, wow, you are pretty close to me,' I said, looking up at her house. The street lights suddenly turned on. There was an awkward moment of silence. 'Thank you for joining me tonight,' she said, smiling. 'You're welcome, thank you for the invite,' I said to her. **** Now's the chance. I inched closer to him, our cold noses brushing. **** I caught my breath. Are we... Going to kiss?... 'I... I want to kiss you...' she said, wrapping her arms around my neck. I was beyond nervous, but I can't just not say anything to her. 'Sure...' I said, placing my hands on her hips over her long jacket. She pulled me in gently from the back of my head, connecting our lips. Oh my... Her lips are smooth and soft as mine collide gently into hers. Our lips collided and brushed softly. Goosebumps formed up and down my arms, and I got chills down my spine. She slowly inserted her tongue into my mouth, and I reciprocated immediately. **** He gently placed his tongue into my mouth, and our tongues danced and moved together. I loved it, I loved the direction it was going into. I tugged on the hair from the back of his head, tangling his soft hair in my fingers. **** It keeps escalating. Does she want this? Do I want this?... 'Come inside?' she asked me between the kiss, pulling me to her door. Before I could answer, she had opened her door, stepped inside and pulled me in with her. Oh. Gosh. She closed her front door, removing her jacket, then removing mine. She pushed me up against the wall, connecting her lips to mine once again. I want a relationship. I don't want just a one night stand. 'Catherine...' I said between the kiss. She moved the kissing down my jaw then to my neck, kissing gently. 'Mmm?' she answered me softly. 'Isn't this... A bit... Too fast?' I asked her, trying not to moan as she licked up and down my neck. She pulled back. 'I'm sorry... Is this too much?' she asked me, looking me in the eyes. 'No... I mean, you seem like a great girl. But my intentions are to actually build a relationship, not just mess around...' I said, looking down. 'We can build a relationship,' she told me. I looked back up at her. 'We can?' I asked. 'Yes, of course. Doing this right now will help build it...' she said, then continued kissing and licking my neck. I closed my eyes, leaning my head back on her wall, letting out a groan. 'It can?' I asked her, trying to focus. 'Yes... Shhh... Just let me take the lead, I'll show you...' she whispered in my ear, licking inside it. Another shiver ran down my spine. If she says it will, I'm sure it will... This can help us get to know each other more for future times... Right?... Yes, that's what she just told me... She kissed back up to my lips, and I began giving back once I trusted her that this will turn into a strong relationship. I leaned my head down, showering her entire neck and collarbone area with soft kisses. She moaned, tilting her head back, gripping the hair on the back of my head. I licked up and down her neck, nibbling on her earlobe, then straight to kissing her neck again. 'Mm, I like that,' she told me. 'You like it?' I asked her, happy with the outcome. 'Yeah... Come...' she pulled back and took my hand, leading me down the hall way then going downstairs. She took me into a dark room and closed the door. A little lamp turned on, providing the room with just enough light to see. She leaned up against her wall and pulled me against her. We kissed hard, passionate, and smooth. I couldn't resist it anymore, and I picked her up, and she wrapped her legs around my waist. 'Now we're talking,' she said in my ear as I pressed her up against the wall, kissing her neck. I couldn't help but just keep going. I really want this to work with her, and she said this will help do just that. 'The bed,' she whispered in my ear, and I spun her around, laying her down gently on the bed. I hovered over her as she lay there, and I kissed her neck and chest, sucking gently on her flesh. 'Mm.. Take off your shirt,' she told me. I was hesitant, but I leaned up and removed my shirt from my body as she did so to hers as well. 'Touch my breasts,' she said, grabbing my hands and guiding them to her breasts. I was surprised at how quickly this was happening... First she was just some girl I saw at the gym who I like, to meeting with her in a café, to now being in her basement half naked. I tried to shake out the hesitant thoughts. This will make our bond stronger. This will build a relationship. Right?... She said those exact words... Yes. She moaned loudly as I slid my hands underneath her bra and massaged them gently, running my finger over her nipples. 'Agh... That feels so good...' she said, bucking her hips. **** It's happening. He's in my bed, and I love it. I unhooked my bra, and tossed it to the side. I ran my hands over and across his chest. He moaned gently. **** I was so nervous. I have never done anything like this with a girl... Never been in a girl's bed, touched her, seen her naked... My ex and I took things really slow, and it wasn't a physical relationship... Much more of an emotional connection one... My heart was leaping out of my chest. She knew exactly what she was doing. I know she's done this before, she's a pro. She slid her hand down my torso, placing it over top of my jeans, rubbing over top of my jeans. Oh... Oh my... It feels wonderful... I've never felt these things before... She sure is showing me a lot tonight... 'How's that feel?' she asked, kissing my neck, rubbing me over my jeans. 'Feels wonderful...' I moaned, rolling my head back. 'Yeah? Lay down,' she told me, gently pressing me to the mattress. Okay... Okay... Keep calm Oakleigh... Maybe she's just going to give you a back massage... But she's laying me down on my back, so it can't be a back massage... Are stomach massages invented yet?... She leaned down and showered my entire torso in kisses, moving all her hair to one shoulder. Oh my... Oh my... She grabbed my belt, removing it from my jeans. My heart leaped. She unbuttoned my jeans, dragging them down my legs. Oh. Gosh. My jeans came off at my toes, and they hit her ground. She kissed back up my stomach, licking it up and down. 'Mmm...' I placed my hands behind my back and lay on top of them, biting my lip. 'Are you enjoying this?' she asked, looking up at me, smiling. 'Yes... Of course... It's great...' I said, touching her head. She looked at my boxers, and started to rub me through them. 'Oh... Mhmm...' I moaned as she rubbed me. I've never felt these sensations, so my body is feeling so many wonderful things right now. She kissed me through my boxers. I nearly jumped. 'Oakleigh,' she said, looking up at me. I had to force myself to look down at her. I was so into it. 'Ye-yes..?' I said, stuttering. 'Are you okay?' she asked, rubbing my sides soothingly. 'Yes... Yes... I'm sorry...' I said breathlessly. She came back up to my lips, kissing them gently as she held my face. 'Don't apologize. Just relax,' she said, placing her hands over my eyes, signalling for me to close them. I closed my eyes gently, breathing in and out quickly. 'Relax... Keep your eyes closed...' she said in my ear, then continued by kissing down my chest and stomach. It was so hard for me not to tense up... I've never experienced this before... 'It's okay...' she said reassuringly, then she began stroking me up and down gently as she kissed the tip. 'Aghhhhh... Mmm...' I released a loud and deep moan. It felt so good... 'Does that feel good?' she asked me, stroking me so softly and slowly. 'Yes... Oh God yes... Catherine it feels amazing...' I moaned, telling her. **** He's moaning. That vision I had of him in my bed, making him moan, having the power, It's happening. I love how he's moaning because of me... Because I'm making him feel good... I wish I didn't turn out this way in life... But I did... Don't think about that Catherine... This is great. **** I've never felt so good before... She wrapped her lips around me, and moved them up and down on me gently. 'Oh my God Catherine,' I breathed, moaning out loud. She continued, swirling her tongue around me, kissing me and licking me gently. Wow... She is so good... Oh my Lord... She continued sucking again, moving her lips up and down gently on me. 'Ugh... That feels so good...' I couldn't stop moaning. She continued to use her hand on me by stroking me up and down while she used her mouth on my tip. 'Just like that... Oh God...' I moaned to her, encouraging her to keep going. 'Just like that?' she asked me gently. 'Oh yes... Yes please...' I breathed. I was so close to cumming. She continued exactly what she was doing, stroking me faster while she sucked me up and down. Two Smiles with the Same Story 'Oh God... Catherine... You're going to make me-' Before I knew it, I had cummed. The feeling of my orgasm smashed into me, and flooded my entire body. 'Oh my gosh Catherine... I'm so sorry...' I apologized to her. She kissed back up my stomach. I twitched as my orgasm still rode through me. 'Don't apologize... That's what I was trying to do to you,' she said, kissing my neck. Wow... I can't even describe how amazing that was... My orgasm faded somewhere in my body, and I caught my breath. 'Catherine...' 'Yes Oakleigh?' 'Lay... Lay down...' Immediately, she lay down. I had no idea what to do. I don't want her to know that either. I thought to start off at her breasts. I leaned down, and placed my mouth to her breasts, licking the nipple gently. 'Mmm... That's good...' she said, arching her back. 'Is it?' I asked her, moving to her other breast. 'Mhmm...' she mewed softly. Kiss down her stomach now? I slowly made my way down her stomach, and I looked up at her and made eye contact. Oh gosh... This is so intense... Don't look in her eyes Oakleigh... You're probably making her uncomfortable by doing that... I placed my fingers to her pants and unbuttoned them, bringing them down her legs. She tangled her fingers into my hair. Is that her way of telling me to stop? 'Keep going,' she said, looking down. Never mind. My nervous self gently kisses up and down her long legs, rubbing them as I did so. She moaned gently, bucking her hips. I hope these are pleasure responses... I kissed her gently through her panties, and she gasped. 'What? What's wrong? I asked her, trying not to panic. 'No, nothing is wrong, trust me,' she told me, holding the back of my head. I shakily continued, trembling my lips over her panties. Do I take them off now? 'Take them off,' she said, lifting her hips. Yep, it's time they come off. I grabbed them gently, dragging them down her legs. They hit her ground. 'Tell me what you like,' I told her, kissing her thighs. She nodded, closing her eyes. **** I need to feel his tongue, his mouth, his lips. I bet it will feel so good... **** I was so nervous. I could hear my heart pounding. I was afraid that she would be able to hear it too. Slowly, I brushed my lips up against her, kissing her gently. 'Agh...' she moaned, arching her neck into the pillows. I slowly inserted my tongue into her, placing her legs on my shoulders. I swirled my tongue gently inside of her, hoping it felt good. 'Oh... That feels good Oakleigh...' she said, gripping my hair. I started to get more comfortable. She will tell me what's good for her... 'Go more circular with your tongue, move it up more,' she told me. I did what she told me, and her moans escalated once I found the spot she wanted. 'Oh... Yes... Right there... Like that..' she moaned, throwing her head back. Her moans made me feel confident that I could make her feel good. 'Shit Oakleigh...' she moaned, gripping the sheets. I stopped. 'Yes?' I asked her, thinking she wanted me to stop. She immediately sat up. 'Why did you stop?' she asked me, out of breath. 'Keep going?' I asked her. 'Yes, yes please keep going,' she said, laying back down. I continued. I gently wrapped my lips around her clit, trying to suck it. 'You're good Oakleigh, that feels good,' she moaned to me, holding onto a patch of my hair. I continued to lick and suck her gently, kissing around her once in a while. Soon after, I noticed her breath started to become broken, her hips were in the air, and she was ripping at her sheets. 'Yes... Ugh yes... I'm cumming...' she moaned. **** It feels amazing... My orgasm shot through my veins, invading every inch of my body. Ugh... That was so good... I tried to catch my breath as he slowly kissed back up my stomach. 'How was that?' he asked, hovering over me. I held his face. 'Amazing Oakleigh,' I breathed, looking him in the eye. **** I smiled. I made her feel good. That makes me feel good too. I lay down next to her, playing with her hair as she caught her breath. **** I caught my breath as my orgasm disappeared. That was so good... Well... He should go home now... I turned around to face him. 'Thank you for this...' I told him, smiling. 'Thank you so much Catherine... I hope this will grow between us and build a connection,' he said. 'It will...' I said. He smiled, looking into my eyes. Don't look at him like that Catherine... This isn't a relationship... Tell him he has to go now... 'Well we should call it a night. I got to work early,' I told him. 'Oh, right,' he said, getting up and finding his clothes. I wrapped the bedsheets around me, sitting up. He became fully dressed again, and I stood up in front of him. 'Come, I'll take you back upstairs,' I said, guiding him back up. We both stood at the front door. I opened it. 'Thank you Catherine,' he said, stepping out onto the porch. 'Thank you,' I said, leaning up against the door. He closed his eyes, leaning in and pressing a kiss to my cheek. I ignored the feeling of guilt that settled into me, and smiled. 'Goodnight Catherine,' he said. 'Goodnight Oakleigh,' I said, closing the door. I watched him from the window as he started to walk away. I leaned up against the back of my door. No feelings... No relationship... Just sex... I can't do this relationship thing... I'm sure he won't want the relationship thing either... This is good, it's great. It doesn't have to be serious, it can be casual. It's great. **** Wow... I walked across the street before the passing car. That was so beautiful. I hope I can see her again. Maybe I will ask her to dinner. That should also make our relationship stronger. I arrived back home and grabbed my phone. She had given me her number while we were at the café. I punched her number into my phone, and texted her. 'Thank you so much for an unforgettable night. You are so beautiful and sweet. Thank you,' **** My phone lit up with an unknown number. I looked. It's Oakleigh. I remember him telling me that number. I opened the text, and read it. I can't respond to that... Just leave it Catherine... This isn't serious... I put my phone down, went to the shower and fell asleep shortly after. ************ How was it? Should I continue? xx Hope you're all well xoxo 'You're beautiful just the way you are,' - Kate xo