2 comments/ 45674 views/ 4 favorites Trying to Understand By: SwtCountryGirl Many thanks to EroticaSeanStyle for being a volunteer editor on this story. * "Daddy! Oh, do that again." There was laughter, male and female, then a very sexy, contented sigh and the sound of books hitting the floor. "You were finished with that, right, Sarah?" "I have this whole long weekend to finish my homework, Daddy, but Gideon will be here tonight, so I won't have the chance to this with you again anytime soon. So please, a little less talk, and a lot more kissing and, mmm, yeah that's good." Sarah giggled again. Gideon pressed his back to the wall separating the kitchen from living room, fighting to breathe normally and erase the image of his sister, half naked and sitting on the kitchen table while their father kissed her. They were so caught up in each other they apparently hadn't heard him come in. His mind was racing. What the hell had happened since he'd been home? Sure it had been over a year, but really. His father was a minister, had been for nearly 30 years, and Sarah had been in the choir, taught Sunday school, never even dated that he knew of. More moans and his sister panting "harder, faster," then screaming were all the proof Gideon needed that things had indeed changed dramatically in the Watson household. As quietly as he could he picked up his suitcase and exited through the front door. He needed a drink and they obviously needed a couple hours. He would come back closer to the time they were expecting him, and do his best to pretend he didn't know anything about any of this. * * * * * * "Gideon, you're home!" Sarah hugged her big brother tightly. One more thing to shock the hell out of him. Their family had never really been touchy feely. "It's so good to see you. Wow, you frosted your hair." She ran her fingers over the sharp heavily gelled spikes. "It looks good with those pretty green eyes." She glanced over his tight faded t shirt, jeans and beat up boots. "Where's the sharp clothes to go with the hair and fancy job?" "I've got to relax sometime," he said. "When did you get so bubbly?" "Oh, you know. I guess college is making me a little more confident, outgoing. I thought Kirsten was coming with you." "We broke up last week." He looked over her shoulder. "Dad." Gideon took the hand Seth offered and shook it. "How are things at the church?" "Good, the associate pastor will be ready to take over at the end of the year, and I'll have to find something to do with myself. Figured it was time to retire, let someone more comfortable with change lead now." YEAH, I'LL JUST BET THAT'S WHY YOU'RE LEAVING, Gideon thought cynically as he watched Sarah pick a piece of lint off their father's sweater. YOU'RE PROBABLY JUST AFRAID SOMEONE WILL FIND OUT YOUR LITTLE SECRET AND REPORT YOU. "So, you and Kirsten split. I'm sorry to hear that, from what you told me she sounded like a nice girl." "Yeah, and she decided she liked other nice girls more than guys." Gideon waited for the mini sermon on sin, but it never came. Good to know his father wasn't completely hypocritical. "Gid, are you hungry? Daddy and I already ate, but I can fix you a sandwich or heat up some leftovers." "No thanks, Sarah, I'm just going to head to bed. It was a pretty long drive." He picked up his duffle bag and headed to his old bedroom before either of them could say anything else. He needed a hot shower, a nip of whiskey from the bottle in his bag and then sleep. When he stepped out of the bathroom into his bedroom he found his baby sister sitting on his bed in blue and red striped pajama pants and a white t shirt, her deep brown hair in two braids, staring off into space. He felt self conscious standing there with just a towel around his waist, but she didn't seem to notice as she looked over at him. "Hey," she held out a silver nugget and leather bracelet to him, the one their mother had given him when he turned 18, "I guess you dropped this earlier outside the kitchen." She blushed. "I'm not sure I really want to know how much you saw." "More than enough." He grabbed the bracelet, then a pair of shorts and a shirt from his bag and ducked back into the bathroom. When he emerged again he felt much more in control, but still kept most of the room between them. "I don't know what to say, Gideon." "How long has he been doing this to you, Sarah? How long has he been molesting you? Why haven't you ever said anything. Damn it, you know it's wrong. Why are you letting him hurt you?" "You must not have seen that much if you think he's hurting me." She held out a hand as he began to speak again. "No, Gideon, just listen for a minute. There is nothing here you need to fix for me. We became lovers over the summer. I wanted it, I encouraged him. No, it's not normal, but it feels right for us, and since neither of us is seriously involved with anyone else we aren't hurting anybody." "What about me? I walk in to find my father, supposedly this great Man of God fucking my baby sister on the kitchen table and I'm just supposed to be okay with it? Go on like life is fine? The same man who grounded me for looking at girls in bikinis and masturbating in the shower was sucking your tits and fingering your cunt in this house just a few hours ago. How can you say that's not fucked up?" Sarah stood and began walking towards the door. "I knew you wouldn't even try to understand. Just please don't say anything to Daddy." "Would he stop if I did?" Sarah froze and then turned to him, her face stricken. "Yes, he probably would. And it would break my heart, Gideon. Do you really hate me being happy that much? Enough to keep the one man who loves me unconditionally away from me? I'm sorry that none of your relationships seem to be working out right now, but that is not my fault. Maybe if you were a little less focused on appearances you would meet a woman who would be good for you, who would stay." He stayed silent as she left the room, then cursed as he pulled the bottle from his bag. He had a feeling it would be a very long night with his thoughts. An hour later, mind still reeling, and more than a little tipsy Gideon found himself stumbling down the hall towards his sister's room. He didn't know what he would say when he got there, but he had to see her, to settle this. He didn't hate her, never had, but he could admit that he resented the extra attention she sometimes seemed to receive for being the younger sibling, and a girl. As he stepped into the dark room, he could make out her form huddled underneath the quilt. She was still sleeping with that stupid plush cat she'd had since she was nine. He laughed softly at that, then knelt by the edge of her bed and just watched her. Sarah really wasn't the type of girl he ever went for, even if she hadn't been his sister, but he could admit to himself that she was pretty. She was also sweet and caring, thoughtful, something few women he dated ever were, and for just a moment he wondered what it would be like to love and be loved by a woman who wasn't out only for herself, who actually cared about the well-being of others. He hated to admit it, but Sarah was right about the girls he tended to go for. Thin, beautiful and usually super needy or complete bitches. Before he realized it he was stroking her hair , trying to understand why she would willingly sin so horribly by having sex with their father. Gideon had given up on God years ago, but he knew there were still some things that were just wrong. "Gideon, what are you doing?" she asked sleepily. "Jeez, have you been drinking?" He pulled back like he had been slapped. How dare she judge him? "Yeah, are you gonna go tattle on me? Then maybe I can go tell the church elders about-." Her hand came out of nowhere, connecting dead on with his cheek and he rose up sharply then bent to pin her arms to the bed. "I think they would be very interested in knowing about this little affair." His face stung, and he was just drunk enough to want to hurt her a little. His grip on her wrists tightened and he pushed on her harder, climbing onto the bed and straddling her body for better control. "Gideon, don't." Even in the dark he could see the fear, and the quiver in her voice as she begged him to leave excited him. "Do you think you're too good for me? You can fuck your dad but not your brother? Seems like there isn't much difference, except I'm not old." "You also aren't thinking," she whispered to him harshly, her voice still strained and fearful. "You've had too much to drink tonight, and a huge shock. Please, Gideon, just go back to bed, sleep and try to forget all of this." He leaned down, and licked the side of her neck, to be rewarded with a small wiggle of he hips and groan. Dipping lower he bit a nipple through the fabric of her shirt and she gasped. "Does he ever get rough with you?" He moved his head and bit the other nipple with slightly more force. "Please don't." "Does he?" Gideon asked sharply. "No. He's always careful, tender." She winced as he thrust his erection against her stomach. "You don't ever wonder what it would be like to be used hard?" He was whispering in her ear, his voice rough and low, dark and dangerous and Sarah unsuccessfully tried to not squeal with unexpected arousal. Gideon took one hand from her wrists, still holding her secure with the other one and roughly pawed at her large, soft breasts, then cupped her chin and forced her to look at him, directly into his eyes. "I'll make you a deal, little girl. Let me do whatever I want to you tonight and I won't tell Dad that I know, and I won't go to the elders. You're little secret will be safe, and as a bonus you'll get to experience a whole new kind of sex. Unless of course you've played these games with the boys at school?" He laughed harshly. "I'm not a slut. Daddy's the only one I've been with," she said softly. "You don't want this, Gideon. You're disgusted by my being with Daddy, and you're drunk. If I said yes you would regret it in the morning. I don't want you to hate me or yourself. Just please go back to bed." Gideon's hand slipped lower and he began pulling at the waist of her pajama bottoms, tugging them down to her knees as she tried to wriggle free. "Stop. I don't want this." Sarah was panting as she fought him, trying to keep her voice low so Seth wouldn't hear them. "Then call for help. It's just down the hall." His hand slipped between her thighs and two fingers slid easily into her pussy. "Awfully hot and wet for someone who doesn't want to have sex right now." He looked her in the eyes as she continued to try pulling her hands free. "I haven't had sex in months, Sarah, and if I have to rape you tonight I will, though I think we'll both have more fun if you just give in and fuck me." "You don't know what you're doing, Gideon. Sex should never be taken lightly, especially something like this." "I don't want to hear a sermon right now." He positioned himself between her legs and thrust into her in one hard, deep stroke. "I just want to get off." He was just aware enough to see the hurt look in her eyes, battling with desire, but was still too drunk to care. He fucked her hard, kissing her often, barely even noticing when Sarah became a willing participant and her hips began to rise to meet his, her lips not only not avoiding his, but seeking them out. He groaned as she lightly bit his shoulders, arched her back so her breasts connected with his chest. The longer he went the more he could appreciate the tight sheath encasing him. Without a doubt she felt better than any other woman he had ever been with. When he came at last, he buried his face against her neck, growling deeply. He was amazed he had been able to go so long, considering the length of time since his last sexual encounter. They were both panting, lightly coated with sweat. Gideon released his sister's wrists and kissed her mouth again, much more gently as her hands rested lightly on his chest. He was starting to sober up, and as he looked down at her, eyes closed, breathing slowing to normal, he saw blotchy patches from his stubble on her cheeks and neck, small bite marks scattered across her shoulders and upper chest. He lightly touched each one. "I don't remember doing this," he whispered. "They aren't all yours, but a few are." She pushed against him lightly, and he rolled away while she wiggled back under her quilt. He could tell by her movements that she was pulling her pj bottoms up. "Oh, Jesus." A thought struck him like lightning. "I didn't plan this, Sarah, I swear, and God, I didn't use a condom." He sat on the side of her bed, elbows on knees, hands cradling his head. "I'm on the pill," she said sleepily. "Oh. Are you okay? Did you cum?" "I'm fine, don't worry about me, just go to bed." She rolled over so her back was to him and shrugged his hand away when he placed it on her shoulder. "Go away, Gideon, I'm tired." He stood and slipped out of her room and back down the hall to his. He felt guilty about what had just happened, but not because Sarah was his sister. He was feeling guilt over just taking what he wanted. Yes, she seemed to enjoy her self after a bit, but she hadn't consented in the beginning. He felt like a rapist. And a selfish bastard for not making sure she had an orgasm. Looks like he'd have to work on making it up to her later. Trying to Understand Ch. 02 Sarah lay in her bed, staring at the ceiling for over an hour after Gideon left. The sex hadn't been completely horrible, but she was definitely still on edge. Earlier when she had seen Gideon in the kitchen door through half closed eyes she had thought that being with him would be more like being with, well, like being with Seth, sweet and gentle, loving. But her brother and her father were two very different people. She rubbed her wrists, still a little sore from being held so tightly and felt a tingle of arousal low in her belly. She slipped from bed and into her bathroom, cleaning up from Gideon, then pulled her pajamas off and slipped into a robe before quietly creeping down to her father's room. She entered silently and removed the robe at the foot of the bed before sliding in next to her father, completely naked. He awoke instantly and pulled her close, kissing her for a moment. "Sarah, baby girl, you know we can't." "Gideon knows, Daddy. He saw us in the kitchen. He was shocked and left pretty fast." She took a deep breath. "Then I let him know that I knew he was there before we went to bed, and he got a little drunk and came to my room. I'm sorry, Daddy." Seth cuddled her for a while, stroking the smooth skin of her upper arm. "Was it good?" "He wasn't really thinking, Daddy. It was a little rough, and well, I'm still kind of horny. Please, Daddy?" Seth slipped a hand between her legs to play with her clit while she pressed her body tighter to his. "You never did really answer my question, baby." "It was different. He wasn't as sweet as you are." "I'm sure it was a shock to him, Sarah. And he didn't have all of the fantasies I've had about you over the years." Seth continued to play with her clit, watching her face for the signs that she was nearing orgasm. When she was on the brink he stopped and kissed her forehead. "Go to him, baby girl. Ask him to take care of you properly this time, and leave the door cracked. I want to peek in on you. Maybe I'm just a perverted old man, but the thought of seeing you with someone else is exciting to me." "I love you, Daddy," she whispered before kissing him deeply. "I love you, too. Now go seduce your brother." Reluctantly slipping out of bed, she gathered up her robe and slipped it on, then crept back down the hall to Gideon's room. She opened the door as quietly as possible, and left it ajar behind her so Seth would be able to watch. Her robe came off again, but this time she left it in the floor and walked silently to her brother's bed. He was laying on his back, and she thought maybe he was still awake. When she tripped on one of his shoes and stumbled, falling against the edge of his bed, he popped up, his chest bare and eyes bleary and unfocused. "Sarah, what's wrong?" "I'm naked in your bedroom, Gideon, what do you think is wrong? I'm still really horny. Maybe you can't keep a girlfriend because you aren't that great of a lover." She squeaked as he grabbed her arm and pulled her towards him, rolling quickly to pin her lush body beneath his. "I'm a very good lover, generally, you just had me all flustered and mad and I couldn't concentrate." Sarah giggled huskily before his lips met hers in a scorching kiss. "Can you concentrate now?" "I will do my absolute best." Gideon slid his body down hers, smiling as she shuddered, then laughing against her thigh when the first stroke of his tongue against her clit made her swear. "I thought you were the good kid," he said. "Do you use that kind of language at choir practice." "Hush and get back to work," she said, already beginning to breathe more heavily, her fingers tangling in his hair, anticipating the next flick of his tongue. Gideon was eager to pleasure his sister. He really did feel guilty about the callous way he'd screwed her earlier. He could feel the slight quiver in her legs as she braced against the mattress and the soft moans coming from her were driving him crazy, especially when combined with the sweetness of her pussy. She wasn't completely hairless like many of the women he knew, but it wasn't out of control, and everything was so soft and warm and wet. He brought her through several small orgasms before slipping two fingers deep inside her, stroking the walls of her vagina, searching. A quick catch of breath, and her fingers tightening in his hair told him when he had found the spot his was looking for, and he pressed and rubbed it until she screamed his name, and squirted. "Oh jeez," she said. "I'm sorry, I don't know why—." Sarah was on the verge of tears, and even in the dim room he could see her blushing as she pulled away and moved to take the sheets off the bed. He came up behind her and nibbled at her neck, his arms circling her at shoulders and waist. "Calm down, baby. You didn't pee, you just came really hard and squirted. It's called female ejaculation." "Mom said that was a myth." "Mom didn't know everything. I've been with several girls who do it. It's really kind of sexy to me." He kissed her, his tongue slipping between her lips to let her taste herself. "You have a very sweet pussy," he whispered into her ear as he began to finger her again. After a moment he lifted his hand to her mouth and coaxed her into sucking his index finger, cleaning her juices from him. "Do you like that? Does is taste good to you?" he asked, pushing her back down onto his bed. "Yes," Sarah whispered. She laid back down against his flannel sheets, propped on one elbow facing him. "But now I want to suck you." "You just get right to the point, don't you?" He laughed lightly again. "Gideon, don't make me beg for it." Her voice was strained and he could tell that she was getting more aroused by the second. He leaned down to give her a quick kiss on the mouth. "Sarah, I love it when girls beg for what they want. It really turns me on, so if you want to suck this cock tonight you will plead with me and promise to do what I want. I'm guessing Dad lets you call the shots, but that isn't my style. I'm in control, ALWAYS. Do you understand?" "Yes," she whispered hoarsely. "Please, Gideon, I need to taste you now, please. I promise I will do whatever you want me to, just please let me suck you." "Very good, baby. Now get onto your hands and knees facing me. Very nice," he said as she got into position. "You're going to be my little bitch for the night, Sarah." She started to pull back sharply, shocked by his words, but he grabbed her long hair and pulled roughly, forcing her head back so that she looked up at him. "I can send you away right now, horny and needy, or you can do what I say without question and I will get you off again when I'm ready. You already promised me, now are you going to go back on that?" "No, Gideon." Her voice was small and tight, and the look in her eyes wavered from intrigued lust to mild fear. She was thinking that she had definitely gotten in over her head this time. "Okay, now that you understand my position on this, open your mouth and take every last inch of my cock." The wet heat as she slid her mouth down his pole made him hiss between clenched teeth and he pulled her hair a little harder. She barely gagged as he bumped the back of her throat and began to fuck her mouth at a furious pace. As he neared his own orgasm he pulled back and shot his load all over her face. He stood back for a moment, admiring the way the thick goo slid slowly down her cheeks and forehead, then called out towards the door, "Come on in, Dad, and take a look at this sweet little slut." Seth pushed the door open and slipped inside, a sheepish look on his face and naked with a jutting erection. He came over and stood next to his son, looking down on his baby girl, as she stared up at them, lust overcoming the fear and uncertainty of what she'd promised Gideon. "She's a gorgeous little girl," Seth told his son as he stroked her hair, and rubbed his son's semen into her skin before he kissed her, moaning. "I want you both at the same time," she whispered breathlessly against her father's mouth. She looked up at Gideon. "Please, I want to have both of you in me at the same time. One in my pussy, the other in my mouth." "Such a kinky little slut," Gideon told her, pinching a nipple hard, then twisting as she moaned and leaned into him. "Please," she begged again. "Please, Sir." Gideon looked at her closely. With her parted lips, heavy breathing and unfocused eyes, and pulling back just a bit, making her tit hurt more, there was no way he could refuse her. "Okay, sweetie, you can have us both. You'll suck Daddy off while I fuck that hot little cunt again." He kissed her deeply, then moved to kneel behind her, while Seth touched his erection to her lips. Sarah kissed it, but waited until Gideon's cock was buried inside her before taking her father into her mouth. She sucked and nipped lightly with her teeth the way he liked, and rocked between them moaning in pleasure. She had never imagined being in this position before, and could hardly believe how good it felt. She loved having the two men share her body, her father stroking her hair and whispering his love, while Gideon pounded her hard from behind, smacking her ass from time to time. Seth came first, shooting his cum into her mouth for her to swallow before he sat down in a nearby chair to watch his children. He wasn't sure he liked how rough Gideon was with his sister, how he called her names, but Sarah seemed to be enjoying herself immensely, screaming as another orgasm tore through her. He loved watching her get fucked, her large breasts swinging freely, her hair mussed and mouth swollen from kisses and blow jobs. His dick tried to stir, but he was not a young man anymore, and had taken her twice earlier in the day, so he was done for several more hours. With a loud cry Gideon came at last, pressing himself tightly into Sarah as the top of her body collapsed to the bed, shoulders heaving, ass still high. He couldn't resist a few more swats as he pulled out, then helped her roll to her side, situating her on the pillows and motioning his father over. Gideon cuddled into his sister's back, as their father slid himself against her breasts and pulled the blankets up over them. "Wow," the girl whispered sleepily, "thank you both so much. Thank you, Gideon." She drifted off thinking "how lucky could a girl get, having two sexy men to snuggle with?" Trying to Understand Ch. 03 Sarah sighed contentedly as she awoke, snuggled between the two men who loved her so deeply. She had been exhausted when she finally got in for winter break the night before that she'd had to beg off the customary welcome home sex marathon she, her father and brother had all grown so fond of the past couple years, and yet still they had both insisted on sharing a bed with her. Seth, her father, molded himself to her back, on hand on her hip, the other cradling a plump breast, while her brother Gideon slept on his stomach in front of her, his hand resting on her ass and his faced nearly buried in her cleavage. She turned her head slightly, and felt her stomach begin to churn violently. "No, no, no," she whimpered, vaulting over her brother and into the attached bathroom and heaving unglamorously into the toilet. "Oh, hell," she heard Gideon say from behind her. He patted her back as she continued to puke and cry. "Please tell me this is food poisoning, or the flu. I'd rather have the flu than be a daddy right now," he said when she had finally finished, and was rinsing her mouth out with the glass of water Seth had handed her. She laughed for just a second, and then began to cry again. "I was dating someone," she said. "I didn't know how to tell you guys." "Was, but not anymore?" Seth said gently. "No, when I missed my period I went to his apartment to talk to him. His roommate said he was out with someone else. I haven't heard from him since that." "What about your birth control?" Gideon said. "I had a sinus infection right after Thanksgiving and the campus doctor put me on antibiotics. We were using condoms, but one of them broke. I really thought that it would be okay." "Oh, baby." Seth hugged her and then helped her stand before they walked back into the bedroom. He kissed her mouth gently as they lay down and Gideon joined them, his mouth hot on her neck. He lifted his head momentarily, unusually serious for their bedroom time together. "I know we need to talk about this, but I really, really need some hot sweaty sex." "Me too," Sarah said, reaching for her father's dick. "I need you both so much right now." "I can't say no to my baby girl," Seth groaned as she kissed her way down his chest and took him into her mouth. He had never truly appreciated blow jobs until Sarah had been the one to perform them. His eyes only half open he watched as Gideon moved behind his sister where she knelt on knees and elbows. The vibrations from her moans as her brother began to fuck her caused Seth to come much sooner than he would have liked, but he made sure to kiss her and stroke her hair as she came with a muffled scream. "Again," Gideon said hoarsely. Seth could see him playing with her clit as he pounded her fast and hard. His son loved to be in control of her, taking her beyond what she thought she could handle sexually. The younger man brought her to orgasm three more times before pulling out and helping her roll to her back. She was panting and sweating, shaking from the overload of sexual pleasure when Gideon buried his head between her pale, fleshy thighs, his tongue bringing her one more time. Seth was hard again, insatiable when it came to giving and receiving sexual pleasure from his children. He nudged his son away from Sarah's dripping pussy, and took his place there, burying himself deep into her heat. He looked at his son, who had lain down next to her for a moment, and leaned over to press a kiss to his lips tentatively, still not sure how he felt about the direct sexual contact Gideon had requested in one of their more recent conversations, but willing to try and prove that he loved them equally. "Oh, oh my," he heard Sarah whisper breathily as her pussy clenched around him. "The two of you look wonderful together." "It's a start, Dad," Gideon said, rising to his knees to slip his own hard cock between Sarah's lips. "Kiss her, Dad, please, while she's blowing me. Let me feel both of your tongues loving me." Seth knew how unfair he had been in his raising of Gideon, expecting so much, and never really showing how proud he was of his son. Mending the relationship hadn't been easy, and was far from complete. How could he deny such a heartfelt plea? He kissed the side of Sarah's mouth, his tongue traced her lips and brushed against the soft flesh of his son's erection. "Yesss," Gideon hissed, "so good, both of you. I love you both so much. And Dad, I will return the favor. I can't wait to kneel for you the way our girl does and take your load down my throat." With a yell he came, filling Sarah's mouth to overflowing. Seth found himself licking some of the leaking semen from her cheeks. The saltiness was surprising pleasant, and the whole situation so erotic he shot is own load into his daughter, then collapsed breathlessly to the side. "What do you think, Daddy?" Sarah asked after she had kissed him deeply. "It was good," he said softly. He looked into Gideon's eyes over her shoulder. I'm trying, son, just have a lot of seminary brainwashing to undo." "I know, Dad. I have to say you did a lot better than I expected." He nipped at his sister's shoulder. "You're a bad girl, Sarah, getting so hot over the two of us in your condition." "Shut up, Gid. I can't help liking the sight of my two favorite men together." "Well, it's good to know we beat out mystery sperm donor for the top spots in your heart." Sarah closed her eyes and groaned. "A little more a reprieve, please?" "Nope," Gideon said. His hand caressed her lower belly. "My niece or nephew is busy growing in here, and I'd like a little more information on how he or she got there." "I met Colt in the library. He's working on his PhD in American Literature." "Colt?" Gideon snickered. "Gideon," Seth said sternly. "Dad there is absolutely no way I can take a guy named Colt seriously. I may end up laughing too hard to kick his ass properly." "There will be no ass kicking, Gideon. It's not like he forced me to have sex with him, and we did take precautions." "The knocking you up part I can forgive, if there weren't the chance of nasty defects I'd love to have done the job myself. It's the seeing someone else and disappearing that I have a problem with. Especially," he glared to keep her silent as she opened her mouth to speak, "since the condom broke. He had to have known there was a chance you would get pregnant." Seth spoke up. "Sarah, I agree with your brother on this one. You have to tell him and make him accountable for his actions." "I really don't want to." Sarah sniffled and wiped a tear away. She hated that she had actually fallen in love with Colt and was now suffering a broken heart. "I don't think that I can ever even look at him again." "Don't worry darlin'," Gideon said, "I'll be right there the whole time. I was planning on surprising you, but I got transferred to the company office near your school. I've already got a house there, too. I was just going to make sure you visited weekly to keep me happy, but I think now it would be best for you to move in with me. You're going to need to save your money for the little one, and this way you can go ahead and get your Master's degree after you graduate, since I'll be able to take care of the baby while you go to class." "I, actually, I've been thinking about giving her up for adoption. Or him, you know. I just think a baby should have two parents and since..." Sarah was forced into silence as Seth kissed her. "Your brother will be there for you," he whispered. "And so will I. There's really no reason for me to continue living here, especially if you'll both be in the same town. You mind putting your old man up for a bit?" he asked Gideon. "Not a bit, Dad, it'll help us get closer." Sarah began to cry in earnest. "Thank you." She straddled Gideon and kissed him deeply, then pulled her father closer and kissed him as well. "I want this baby so much. I just wanted to do right by it." "We know," Seth said, rubbing her back lightly, his eyes on his son. "Do you think this qualifies as a special occasion?" "There's lube in the nightstand," the young man said, adjusting Sarah, so that he could lower her sweet pussy onto his steel hard shaft. She shivered as Seth rubbed cold gel around her anal opening. "Have you two been plotting behind my back?" She gasped as her father inserted a finger, moving it gently, spreading more lube around and into her before adding a second finger. "Yes, actually," Seth said hoarsely, lowering his head to nibble on her neck while he teased a third finger into her. He could feel his son's dick through the thin wall separating her vagina and rectum, and stroked him as best he could. "Mmmm, very nice, Dad, I like that. I can't wait to feel you there." Seth's breathing quickened as he slicked more lube on his cock and spread the cheeks of Sarah's pretty, plump rear. She was moaning with pleasure, making small circles with her hips as Gideon played with her breasts and nipples. He raised to his elbows and took the tip of one pale breast into his mouth. Seth took a deep breath and began to ease into his daughter's back door. She screamed with orgasm when he was only halfway in and he had to hold her hips still to keep from being dislodged. The two men chuckled as she begged for more, promising to do ANYTHING they wanted as long as they didn't stop fucking her. Seth was fully buried at last, relishing the super tight feel of her ass before he noticed that Gideon was moving ever so slightly in Sarah's pussy. It was almost like his dick was getting massaged. "As good as I promised, my sweet Dad?" Gideon asked, moving faster. "Better. This is fucking incredible." "Daddy!" Sarah said, looking back at him wide eyed. She hadn't been entirely sure her retired minister father knew how to pronounce those words. He slapped her rear playfully. "Well it is, you sexy little slut." She closed her eyes and purred her agreement, then proceeded to shift back and forth, doing most of the work for the two men. She loved the complete fullness, and though she would never admit it to them, had enjoyed doing this to herself with vegetables, and the one time when Colt had talked her into bringing her dildo to bed with them. That was the night the condom broke. She moved faster, riding the men who loved her harder to banish the memory of the one who had abandoned her. She could tell her father was very close, so she began to bite on Gideon's left nipple, ensuring the two men soaked her pregnant young body with their cum at the same time. She belonged to them, she told herself, resting between father and brother. She didn't need anyone else. Trying to Understand Ch. 04 Seth sipped on his coffee as he watched the snow fall onto the backyard in the early February evening darkness. He had thought that selling the home he'd made so many memories in would have been more difficult, but now that he was here, in a new town where no one had ever heard him preach, sharing a house with his children he felt more alive, and more himself than ever before. "Hi, Dad. Gideon bounded into the kitchen, shaking snow out of his bleached blond hair and shrugging out of his parka. He put his arms around his father and kissed him deeply with cold lips. "Mmmmm, Bailey's," he murmured, before kissing him again. The young man nipped at Seth's neck, then looked around. "Where's Sarah?" "She fell asleep working on her homework in the den, so I made her go to bed. I hate to say it, but I think we're going to have to make her take a year off from school. Being pregnant is making her so tired, and I'm worried about her." "She sees the doctor this week. Go with her, and see if he thinks she needs time off. If so, I'll make sure she withdraws. I'd rather she not have a chance to run into the sperm donor anyway." "I appreciate it, Gideon. You've got a firmer hand with her than I do, and she'll actually listen." He pulled his son closer and stroked his back with his free hand. "I watched those movies again today." Seth felt his son's cock harden against his stomach. Gideon had invested in some male on male porn to help his father get more comfortable with the idea of them being together intimately, and knew that Seth was starting to love the movies, as he had accepted several blow jobs from his son in the past few weeks, and had even fucked his ass a couple times. Gideon enjoyed being bottom for his formerly strict, pious dad, but was really looking forward to the day the older man was on his knees for him, taking his son's cum anywhere Gideon was inclined to leave it. "Good," the younger man said, "so do you want my lips or my rear?" "I want your cock, son. Tonight, I want for you to come in my mouth and my ass. It's a perfect night for it really. You want for me to be as close to you as I am to Sarah, and you weren't there for my first time with her, you came in later. I feel like the first time I take you into me, it should be just us, so I can prove once and for all that I love you both equally." Seth's eyes were tearing as he finished speaking, and Gideon had to swallow a lump in his throat in order to speak. "I'd love that, Dad. Do you need another drink to relax before we start?" "No, I just need you." He set down his cup and pulled down the zipper on his son's pants. "Anywhere you want, Gideon. Tonight I'm yours alone." Gideon kissed his father fiercely, his fingers tangling in the man's gray hair, relishing his moans, the feel of his mouth and stubbled cheeks, the taste of coffee. "Let's go take a shower. I need to warm up a little more. Whose room is she in?" "Hers. We'll all pile back into one bed tomorrow." "Good, let's take my room then." The two men kept their hands linked as they walked upstairs together. Gideon was so excited he wanted to scream, and Seth was eager and nervous. It had almost been an epiphany when he sent his daughter to her room to get some rest. He loved his son, and was willing to do anything for him. There was no reason to put it off any longer. When they reached Gideon's master suite, they quickly began pulling each other's clothes off, kissing and touching every inch of exposed skin as they stumbled into the bathroom. Waiting for the shower to heat up Gideon took the opportunity to suck his father's cock to a steel-hard erection to match his own. "I'm going to have to start working out," Gideon said once they were under the steamy spray, slicking soap over his son's lean and muscled body. I'm envious of the way Sarah drools over your abs." He knelt and kissed the six-pack as he rinsed the soap away. "You deserve to be with me looking good too." "I love you no matter what, Dad, same as Sarah, though I would love for the two of us to work up a sweat together and then get even sweatier fucking around with our girl. I bet the two of us all hot and slick against her would make her cum in no time." Gideon had braced his hands against the tiled wall, and was panting, since Seth had decided to start off with a soapy hand job. "You're no doubt right about that. You've made her such a sexual, kinky little slut. I didn't like it at first, the way you talked to her." Seth continued to squeeze and stroke his son's thick dick, his mouth watering, knowing he would soon be filled with every inch of it. "Now though, I can see how much she likes it. She's so sweet and so dirty at the same time. She's perfect." He hand slowed slightly as he looked up. "But this is about us, not her." Gideon flashed him a sexy smile and quirked and eyebrow. "That's right, it is about us. Start sucking my cock now, Dad. Take every inch of your son's dick into your mouth, and make me cum so hard I gag you." Seth shivered with pleasure at his child's take charge tone of voice, and before the last of the soap bubbles had been rinsed from the base, his mouth was on the smooth head, his tongue playing with the small opening, before he moved forward to take even more. His lips were stretched wide and he felt dizzy, acting out this secret fantasy from his adolescence with his own flesh and blood. Without a doubt, he felt he was doing the right thing. He moaned as his son slid the last couple inches in, and pulled his hair, fucking his mouth hard and sure. "Oh, hell yeah, Dad. You're such a good cock sucker. I love your mouth. Mmmm, you've got a natural talent. It's like you were born to suck big dicks. You like it, Dad, being on your knees for me?" Seth nodded and put his hands on his son's firm ass as the younger man's rod began to jerk and the back of his mouth and throat were coated with sticky cream. He swallowed every bit, and did not take his mouth from his son until his cock was limp again. The water sluicing down on them had begun to cool, and Gideon weakly turned the faucets off before they stepped out and began drying each other off. The bathroom was quiet, and they whispered to one another, praises and adoration that had formerly been reserved for Sarah. Gideon held his father closely as they stared at themselves in the mirror. "Are you sure you can handle the last step tonight, Dad?" Gideon asked, uncharacteristically tender with him. He was really the alpha of the family, determined to be in charge and get his way, but tonight he understood the gift he was given with his unconventional family, and willing to bend a little. "Yes, my son, I want you so much. Just please go easy on me to start. I hadn't gotten around to trying out those butt plugs you gave me before I made my decision today." "Virgin ass," Gid said with a cocky smile as he lightly smacked his dad's rear. "I've never had to pop a guy's cherry before, but I'm glad I get to do yours. Before you know it, you'll be every bit as kinky as your kids." They both laughed and retreated to bedroom, snuggling under the blanket and making out while Gideon's cock recovered enough to perform again. When he was nearly hard enough he pulled a tub of lubricant from the night stand drawer. As he did, his hand brushed the cold steel of his handcuffs and he got an idea and pulled them out as well. "The first time I was with Sarah, I had her pinned to her bed," he said softly. "She couldn't fight, couldn't resist, not that she wanted to for very long, and I remember wishing I'd had my cuffs so I could play with her tits while I fucked her." He took a deep breath and leaned over his father, their lips brushing as he spoke. "I want to look into your eyes while I do your ass, and would be very grateful if you would let me restrain you." Seth kissed his son deeply, and placed one half of the cuffs on his left wrist before raising his arms to the headboard. "Anyway you want it, Gideon, this is your night, and I am yours to control." Gideon looped the cuffs through the wooden slats of the headboard and finished securing his dad to the bed. Slowly, he applied lube to the man's asshole, taking his cock head into his mouth as he pressed first one, and then two fingers into his tight hole. He played for a while, teasing and relishing his father's moans. At last, he applied lube to his own cock, and settled between his father's legs. "I love you, Dad." He pressed forward slowing. "Open for me, stay relaxed," he encouraged softly, watching the older man's face. Once the head of his dick was firmly lodged he pushed a bit more and began to pulse. "Oh God, baby, please," Seth panted. "More. Give it all to me, please," he begged, his eyes locked with his son's. Gideon gently pushed his entire length into him, and gave his father a long wet kiss. They fucked slowly, neither in a hurry for the experience to end. When Gideon finally went, the feel of cum filling his ass caused Seth's own orgasm, the cum covering his chest. Gideon licked him clean again before releasing his father's hands, and nestling in behind him. "You okay, Dad?" he said softly. "Yes. That was amazing. The only regret I have is that I didn't let you do it sooner. I'm sorry I was so stubborn, son." "I forgive you, babe. All that matters now is that we can have each other from this point on. Thank you." They kissed again, and neither saw Sarah standing in the doorway, smiling before she turned to go back to her own room. Tomorrow would be soon enough for her to rejoin them. Trying to Understand Ch. 05 "Gideon, grab Dad and let's go NOW." Sarah, usually calm and serene especially at five and a half months pregnant, looked absolutely frantic as she tugged on her brother's jacket sleeve to pull his attention from the rack of fetish gear he was perusing while their father was off looking at massage oils and lubes in what was unarguably the largest sex toy shop in the state, her eyes fixed on a point in the distance. Immediately Gideon dropped his hand to her baby bump, afraid there was a problem. "Do we need to go to the ER?" "I don't care where we go, as long as it's not here, now hurry. I'll meet you in the car." She pulled away from him and took the long way, around some tall shelves, out the front door to the parking lot. He looked over to where she had been staring and saw a tall man in his mid-twenties wearing a staff t-shirt and apparently explaining the merits of a slender red vibrator to three giggling co-eds. Slowly Gideon walked by and gave the young man a sly wink, causing him to blush and stutter through his next sentence. Gideon smiled and went on to collect his father and meet Sarah in the parking lot. So, that's the sperm donor he thought to himself, stepping into the balmy spring night air. "I take it Colt didn't work here when the two of you were bumping uglies?" Gideon said, as he and Seth climbed into the front seat of the car. Sarah had already gotten into the back and slumped down low, her head bowed. Glancing in the rearview he saw her swipe a hand across her eyes before she spoke. "No, he said he didn't need to work, supposedly he has family money. Of course he also said that he didn't believe in infidelity so who knows what the truth is." Seth and Gideon exchanged a glance that spoke volumes. They had both wondered if she had felt more for her unborn daughter's father than she had let on and now they knew. Sarah played with them sexually, giving herself to them wholly and without reservation and loved them deeply and unconditionally. By letting another man into her body she had been expressing her deep feelings of love. She was a forever kind of girl, not one to have sex just for the sake of having sex and she was not over how she felt for the young man who had gotten her pregnant. "I'd still like to kick his ass. Do I get permission now?" "No, Gideon," Sarah said quietly. "Just forget him." "Why? You haven't." "Kids, no bickering in the car," Seth broke in, trying to alleviate the tension between his children. He knew that what his son said was the truth, but it was vitally important that he not push his sister too hard on the matter right now. Gideon gave him a look, but did not continue baiting his sister. Once they had arrived back at their home, Sarah went upstairs while the two men went out to the back deck. Both were silent for several minutes, until Gideon spoke. "Do you think it's real love or just the excitement of being with the first man who isn't us?" "I think we both know the answer to that one." The younger man kicked the deck railing. "Damn it, Dad, I don't want for us to lose her. When I found out she was pregnant I was thrilled because it meant that she wouldn't have to go find someone else to share her life with so she could have the children she wants and we can't give her." "I know, Gid, I felt the same way but are we really and truly being fair to her? For that matter, are she and I being fair to you? I know that you enjoy your bachelor life right now, but you might want to get married and start a family of your own someday. I hate that I didn't think of these things when we started all of this, but they are issues we need to talk about. I-." Seth's voice broke as his eyes began to tear up. "I love both of you so much, but I don't see a way our current lifestyle would allow either of you to live normal lives with spouses and children." "Who says it needs to, Dad? You'll have a grandchild in a few months, and I hope to God you're not worried that I'll molest her. The only way I would ever lay a hand on her that way is if she came to me first, and if she was over the age of consent. Or are you worried about your control?" "No," Seth said sharply, "I made the same commitment to myself. Sarah told me she wanted to be with me or we never would have started. I just want both of you to be happy." "I am happy," Gideon shouted. "I love my life right now with both of you here, and the three of us sharing a bed every night. You fix us breakfast, I pack lunches for everyone, she cooks us supper and we all sit in the family room together with you reading, Sarah working on a baby blanket and me watching a game or movie. Everything is perfect right now." "Everything except for the fact that your sister is heartbroken. I don't doubt that she loves us and what we have together, but we have to accept that she loves that boy too, that she wants to be with him." "He left her for another woman! He doesn't deserve her. There is no way in hell he can love her and provide for her and the baby the way that we can." Seth took a couple of deep breaths then leaned against the deck railing so he could look into his son's eyes. "He's been trying to call her. She thinks I don't notice when she checks her phone and ignores a call, but I do. And he sent a letter to the old house that got forwarded here. I didn't give it to her, but I did open it and read it. He said that he didn't cheat on Sarah and that his roommate lied to her." "I don't buy it." "You don't want to buy it because she might forgive him. In the letter he also said that he had a feeling the night the condom broke that he got her pregnant, and he doesn't want to be robbed of the opportunity to be a part of his child's life." "Fuck!" Gideon kicked the deck railing again and then went into the house and up to the room designated as Sarah's so outsiders wouldn't get suspicious about sleeping arrangements. Not finding his sister there he headed to the master suite, where they generally all slept together every night. He found her coming out the attached bath, wrapped in his robe, towel drying her long brown hair. Needing to hold her, to love her he pulled the towel from her hands, yanked open the robe and gently pushed her down on the bed, his lips falling onto hers with a bruising kiss. "Gideon, what are you doing?" "I need you, sweetie, right now." He leaned over and began sucking on her nipples, a hand slipping between her thighs to play with her clit. He'd made love to her many, many times and knew exactly how to get her going fast. When she bit his lower lip he only laughed and kissed down her stomach, then to her pussy. Gideon lapped at her vulva and clit, his hands cupping her ass as she writhed in orgasm. "Gideon, I need you inside me," she panted as he continued to tenderly kiss and lick her sensitized clitoris, sending aftershocks of pleasure through her. Sarah pushed herself back on the bed slightly, and carefully rolled over to her hands and knees as he stood and stripped down. He caressed the smooth skin of her back and full butt, kissing and nipping at her skin every few moments until finally she looked over her shoulder at him, damp hair wild and eyes filled with lust and love. "Please give me your cock," she begged, licking her lips. Her brother could never resist that look, and slid into her in one fluid movement, the tip of his cock nudging her cervix, eliciting the moan that drove him so crazy. He had been with a lot of partners compared to his sister, but none of them had ever matched her in terms of pure sensuality. Sarah loved having sex with him. He had dated nymphos who would fuck anything that moved, but even they never seemed to appreciate his dick as much as she did. Growling just a little, he leaned to hold her pendulous tits in his hands while he pounded her from behind. "They've gotten bigger," he said squeezing gently, knowing that with her pregnancy had come increased sensitivity in her breasts and pussy. "Don't remind me," she said almost tiredly, circling the lower half of her body as plunged deeper into her. He laughed. "I like it. I love everything about you." He tweaked her nipples gently and changed the rhythm of his thrusting, slowing it to tease her and hold off her orgasm. When she tried to speed it back up he took his hands from her breasts and moved them to her hips to control her movements. "Oh, please, Gideon," she panted. "Not yet, baby." He leaned and nuzzled the back of her neck. "Let's just take our time and enjoy it." He continued his slow, controlled pace as she let out a sexy moan. He couldn't keep that slow pace going forever though, and soon he was pounding her harder and faster as she begged for more until they both came and collapsed on the bed. Gideon was careful to not let his weight rest on her, but instead fell to one side and pulled her in close, her back to his chest. As their breathing slowed he kissed her neck and shoulder while caressing the breasts he loved so much, along with her rounded belly. "You doing okay, sweetie?" he asked. "Mmmmmm. Yeah, I'm good." Sarah yawned and snuggled back into him. "Do you love the sperm donor?" Gideon said after several moments, holding his sister tight as she tried to pull away. "Don't move, Sarah, we are going to have this conversation." He felt like a prick as she began shaking, a sure sign that she was crying, but he had to know. "If it turned out that he never cheated, would you want him back?" "Yes," she said, sobbing. "He's been trying to call, leaves at least two or three messages a day that he wants to talk to me, to explain what happened. Part of me wants to talk to him, but then I think about what I'll have to give up. No man in his right mind would be okay with his wife sleeping with other men, especially family. If he found out about us he might take try to take the baby. I'm just so torn right now. I love him like crazy, but I don't want to give up what I have with you and Daddy either." The sadness and brokenness in her voice made his heart hurt. He didn't want to, but he was going to have to find a way to get Colt back into his sister's life, even if it meant giving up the hottest and sweetest sex he'd ever have. Gideon hugged her tightly. "Don't worry about it right now, just get some rest." He tucked her in and then re-dressed as she drifted off to sleep. He was tying his shoes as Seth came in. "Where are you going at this time of night?" "Back to the toy store. I'm going to have a little talk with the sperm donor." "Gideon—" "Not a bad talk, Dad, and I'm not going to hurt him." He glanced back at his sleeping sister. "She wants him back, I just need to see if he's worthy of her." When Gideon stepped into the shop, he was pleased to see that the place was relatively empty. It didn't take him long to find Colt, replenishing a stock of butt plugs along the far back wall. "Hey sailor, what time do you get off? Work, that is," Gideon said, leaning against a display case and flashing his most charming smile. The other man coughed and blushed. "I'm flattered, but I have a girlfriend. Kind of. I only took this job because a friend of mine swears he saw her here with another guy. I'm hoping she comes back in so I can talk to her about something my idiot ex roommate told her." "I see, so what if I told you I'm the other guy?" "What are you talking about?" Colt gave him a genuinely confused look. "What if I'm the guy Sarah came in here with." Gideon ducked quickly as the other man took a swing at him. "She's my girlfriend. And why the hell would you be out trolling for dick with her waiting for you? She's perfect, all you should need," Colt said angrily as the store manager came over. "You can go now, Colt, your shift is over and we won't be needing you any longer. Sir," he said, turning to Gideon, "you'll have to leave as well. I won't have people propositioning my employees." Gideon gave the man a small salute and exited the store with his sister's lover hot on his heels. In the parking lot the two men stared each other down. As much as Gideon wanted to continue baiting him, he had to think of Sarah's best interests. "Sarah is enough for me, pretty much. I do like cock every now and then. But the thing is, I'm not enough for her. She needs someone that can be a true partner to her, and that's something that isn't possible for us." "Why? Are you already married or something?" "Colt, I'm going to tell you a secret, and if you tell anyone, ANYONE, I will take you out, got it?" The other man nodded. "I'm Gideon." "Sarah's brother." Colt looked confused for a moment, and then his mouth fell open. "You and Sarah?" Gideon nodded. "Yes, along with our dad. She loves having the two of us at once, but she still loves you, and I know she needs to be able to go out and hold her head high which is a little difficult now." "She did get pregnant." Colt slumped against the closest vehicle. "I knew it, as soon as the condom broke that we would have a baby. I got so excited at the thought of holding her, making love to her while her body changed. Then my roommate got pissed at me for wanting him to actually pay his part of the bills and told her I was out with another girl when I was actually out buying her engagement ring." He pulled a small box out of his pocket. "I carry it with me all the time, in case I run into her." He flipped open the box to show Gideon the diamond ring. Gideon swallowed the lump in his throat. "There are countries smaller than that rock. Damn it. I really wanted to hate you, but it seems like you love her a lot. Maybe you aren't just a douche bag sperm donor." The other man laughed. "I'm not, I promise. I just want to make her happy. She told me she had a secret that she needed to share but wasn't sure how. But I would hear her talk to you, or your dad on the phone sometimes, and it sure as hell isn't the same way my sister talks to me." He was silent for a moment. "She really takes you both?" "Yep, well, she did. I guess that'll change when you two get married." Colt took a deep breath. "It doesn't have to. I mean, if you were at least partially sincere in flirting with me, and not just trying to fuck with my head." Gideon grabbed the front of the other man's shirt and pulled him close for a fierce, tongue thrusting kiss. "I am one hundred percent bisexual," he said as they separated, both panting. "But I would expect you to reciprocate anything I do." "I've never been with a man before, but I have had a few fantasies, and I'll do whatever I have to do to be with Sarah." "Okay then." Gideon took the man's hand and led him to his car. "Get in and let's go surprise her." The two men walked in silence through the darkened house, stripping off clothes as they went. They'd talked on the way over and conspired to make it a night that Sarah would never forget. Slipping into the master bedroom, they saw Seth and Sarah both sleeping the big bed, cuddled together. "Wow," Colt whispered, taking in the sight of the woman he loved lying naked in another man's arms. Knowing that it was her own father holding her made him hot. Gideon had fully explained what a gift it was to be let into their family unit, and he was excited to explore with his soon to bes. Gideon went over and gently woke his father with a kiss, asking him to move without waking the girl. There were whispered introductions and brief outline of the scenario the younger men had come up with in the car, then Colt soon found himself sandwiched between the two men, being kissed and groped as his dick got hard. All of this was so wrong his brain told him, but as Seth knelt and started sucking him, his body told him that this was the most right thing in the world. He was very close to orgasm so he gently pushed Seth away, accepting a deep kiss from the older man before allowing Gideon to push him to the bed. A moment later, he held the love of his life in his arms for the first time in five months, and he wanted to cry. The other men stood close and watched as Colt began to trace Sarah's curves, lingering over the belly protecting his child. He kissed her shoulder and rubbed his erection against her bottom, finally causing her to stir a bit. "Again, Daddy?" she said sleepily with a smile in her voice. Then she realized the arms around her didn't belong to her father or to Gideon, and the familiar expensive cologne tickled her nose. She tried to pull away, but Colt held her close as the other two men settled into the bed next to them. "I am so sorry about what you've been going through since Derek lied to you. I swear I have not had interest in any other woman but you. I asked your father and brother if I could marry you, and they said yes, as long as it's what you want. I've also been invited to share the familial bed. I would never keep you from them, and any time you need to be filled by more than one man, as long as it's them I have no objections. Don't cry, Sarah, please, I love you so much." "I'm crying because I'm happy, you idiot," she said, turning to face him and molding her body to his. "But I have to warn you that Gideon will expect you to do things for him." "Yeah. He got a blow job in the car on the way here, said I needed to get some pointers from you." His soon to be wife laughed and kissed him, tasting the truth of his words as their tongues met. She then climbed onto him, looking over at her other lovers. "Are you two just watching?" "Hell no," Gideon said with an evil grin. He moved behind her and helped her seat herself on Colt's cock while their father stood on the firm mattress positioning his own tool at a perfect height for her to suck. "We're all going to be in you at once, slut." Sarah only let out a contented sigh and began riding her fiancé while her brother lubed up and fingered her ass for a few minutes to get her ready. As the head of his cock penetrated her back door she leaned forward enough to take Seth into her mouth and just like that she was experiencing the sexual trifecta. There was no more thinking for her, just the sensation of dick in all of her orifices at once, Gideon smacking her ass, her father gripping her hair tightly on either side, setting the rhythm for which to bob up and down on his meat and Colt's mouth and hands on her breasts, squeezing and suckling her tender nipples, biting down and making her scream, the added sensation pushing her over the edge for her orgasm after orgasm. There was also no sense of time, though one by one the men came inside her and pulled away, until there was only Colt, filling her pussy with his come and pulling her face down to his, kissing her and telling her that he loved her, that she was a goddess and he was never going to make her doubt him again. That was the last thing she heard before collapsing into a sated heap on him, passed out from the sexual overload that she looked forward to repeating as often as possible. Colt let her rest on him for several moments, savoring her warmth before rolling gently so they were both on their sides, face to face. Gideon took the opportunity to slip behind him, putting a hand possessively on his hip and biting and sucking on his shoulder to leave a mark, while Seth took up his usual position at Sarah's back, reaching over to grab the newcomer's hand. "You're one of us now, Colt. Welcome to the family."