7 comments/ 21526 views/ 16 favorites Three Is Better Pt. 01 By: scarlettshea86 Matt and I had been together for a couple of years and had always known we wanted to be in a polyamorous triad with another woman, but so far we hadn't had any luck finding someone we wanted long-term. We'd had plenty of threesomes with beautiful women, but most were one-night stands or just weren't looking for what we were. Until we met Amanda. Amanda was young, just turned 18, innocent and impressionable. She had been dragged to our apartment for a party with her cousin, a friend of ours. Barely 5'1" and weighing about 110 pounds, she was a tiny little thing with long natural red hair and full, perky breasts. She was beautiful, exactly what Matt and I had physically dreamed of. Amanda was shy at first, timid around people in their late twenties but once we got her talking, we found instantly that we both really enjoyed her. For a couple of months, we simply invited her to hang out with us, taking her to dinner, spending time in the park just getting to know her. Matt and I were both smitten and hoping to take it to the next level soon, so we planned a night in to explain to her about what we wanted and gauge if she might be open to trying it. I heard a knock at the door as I was stirring the pasta, and yelled, "Come on in!" Within a moment, Amanda appeared in the kitchen and came over to hug me. She smelled so sweet and her happy smile instantly brightened my day. "That smells so good, Scarlett. I can't wait to eat, I'm starving. I brought like 5 movies so we have a bunch to choose from," Amanda said, kicking off her shoes and setting her purse down. She wandered over to the living room where Matt was watching the news. "Hey, you!" "Hey yourself! Glad you could come. We've been wanting a lazy night in for a while," he said. They sat comfortably chatting about the news while I finished preparing dinner and setting the table. Once it was finished, I called Matt and Amanda in and we all sat down to eat together. It was so comfortable, the three of us, laughing and talking about school. Matt was in pharmacy school, I had just finished nursing school, and Amanda had just started her freshman year at college studying journalism. Once we had finished eating, they helped me load up the dishwasher and get the kitchen back in order before we all headed to the living room. I sat down on the couch and Amanda instantly came and sat right next to me, embracing my arm in hers. I loved when she snuggled with me like that and hoped so much that after our conversation, she would want to do that with me much more. Matt sat down in the chair across from the couch where we were and looked at Amanda directly. "Honey, we want to talk to you," he said softly. Amanda sat up straighter and took my hand in hers. I could sense fear radiating off her, but I'm still not quite sure what she was afraid of. "O...kay..." "It's nothing bad. Quite the opposite, really. Amanda, Scarlett and I really like you. A lot. We both love spending time with you. We think you are intelligent and funny and beautiful. Just a wonderful girl," Matt began. "But Amanda, you need to know that we have feelings for you." She sat there silently, releasing my hand and leaning a little away from me. "What do you mean, you have feelings for me? Both of you?" "Yes, sweetie. We both like you very much. I know that you know I'm bisexual and like women just as much as I like men. Amanda, we asked you here tonight to explain to you that we're polyamorous. It means that we both desire to have a relationship with other people outside of this relationship. Specifically, with you. We would be so incredibly happy if you would be a part of what is called a polyfidelitous triad with us, where three people date each other equally and monogamously. I know this is incredibly confusing and we don't even know if you would like being with a woman or not, but..." "Yes." "Yes what?" I asked. "Yes. I want that. So much." "Seriously? Amanda, you probably need time to think about this. Do you know if you're even bi? Do you understand the parameters of what we're asking of you?" "You both want to date me and each other. I get that. We would all three be dating each other. And I've never been with another girl but I know that I'm attracted to you so I want to try." "Simple as that?" Matt asked. "Simple as that. I like you guys a lot, both of you. I enjoy spending time with you. I am attracted to both of you. I don't see why we can't give it a try." Out of pure excitement, I couldn't help but take her beautiful face in my hands and gently kiss her full, soft lips. Instead of feeling her jerk back in reaction, she scooted back closer to me and began moving her tongue in my mouth. We sat there kissing passionately for several moments while Matt watched us patiently. "Wow. That was amazing," Amanda said as she caught her breath. Matt slowly rose from his seat in the chair and came over to sit on the ottoman in front of us. Like me, he took her face in his big hands gently and kissed her passionately. It was incredibly hot to watch my boyfriend kissing this beautiful young woman. Then, once they stopped kissing, Matt put his hands on the backs of both our heads and pulled us into him, all three of our tongues dancing with each other in our very first triple kiss. We had made it a rule never to kiss the women we fucked but with Amanda, it was different. She was potentially going to be our girlfriend. "Why don't you girls come to the bedroom," Matt said, standing up. Amanda and I both rose, and I gently took her hand in mine. "Honey, we won't do anything you don't want to. You let us know your limits and we'll respect that. We have plenty of time to explore what we all like together," I whispered to her as we followed Matt to the bedroom. She nodded in agreement. Once we got there, Matt sat down on the bed and watched as I pulled Amanda's top off. I reached behind her and released her breasts from her bra, and then removed my own top and bra. We stood there before Matt in an embrace, our nipples touching as we passionately kissed. I traced my lips down her neck and across her shoulders before I took her breast in my hand and began to suck on her hard little nipple. She leaned back, pushing her tits out toward my face, and moaned. While I went back and forth licking and sucking on her perfect nipples, Matt was busy undoing her jeans and pulling them down with her underwear and then doing the same to me. "Amanda, honey, why don't you lie down in the middle that way Scarlett and I can take care of you," Matt said. Amanda crawled into our king-sized bed on all fours before she laid down on her back in the middle. I could see her perfect, tiny body: those gorgeous tits, a small waist, and a completely hairless pussy. Matt and I laid down on either side of her and he began kissing her as I went back to sucking on her nipple. I could see Matt's hand tracing up and down her thigh and soon she had parted her legs, inviting him in. He reached between her legs and dipped two of his fingers into her wet pussy, using it as lubricant to start rubbing her clit. "You are so wet, baby. I have a feeling you're really going to like playing with us." Three Is Better Pt. 02 This story follows perfectly in sequence with Part 1. ***** As Matt continued rubbing Amanda's clit with her pussy juices, I kissed her passionately, squeezing her nipples and kneading her breasts with my hand. She had such beautiful, round breasts with the most perfectly proportionate nipples. I couldn't help myself and absolutely had to stop kissing her so I could take a nipple in my mouth and taste it. I flicked my tongue back and forth across her hard nipple, sucking on it every now and again and as I heard her moaning in pleasure, I could feel my own pussy getting wetter. "Baby, why don't you go ahead and start eating her pussy," Matt suggested. He didn't have to tell me twice. I slithered down the bed and parted her legs only to see the most perfect pussy I had ever seen: pink and glistening with wetness. It looked so delicious that I wanted to dive right in but instead, I took my time kissing up her right inner thigh and back down the left one to her knee, teasing her. Matt suddenly reached out and shoved two fingers in my mouth and that little taste of her was enough to convince me it was time to stop teasing. I leaned down between her legs and kissed her right on the pussy, softly, gently, just enough to make her whole body quiver. Matt was stroking her hair and sucking on one of her nipples as I took my first lick straight from the bottom of her pussy right up to her clit. She tasted like absolute heaven. I began licking her clit, flicking my tongue across it in all directions, sucking on it, encouraged by the delicious soft moans and panting breath I heard above my head. I moved down and put my tongue as deeply into her pussy as I could wiggled it around inside her. It was the best pussy I had ever tasted in my life and I couldn't get enough. I wanted to eat her pussy all day long. Then, I reached up and placed my hands on the backs of her thighs, pushing her legs back, and moved down even lower to lick her tight little asshole. My tongue traced circles around it before I pushed my tongue in a little; her asshole was so tight I automatically knew she was probably an anal virgin. Helping Matt take her anal virginity was going to be such a wonderful experience later. "Okay, baby, it's my turn. I need to taste her pussy, too. And you know what? I think she needs to taste yours." "Yes, please. I've never tasted pussy and I want to taste yours so bad," Amanda pleaded with me as Matt moved down between her legs. Before I could even straddle her face, Matt was passionately eating Amanda's dripping wet pussy, moaning into it. I knew he would love her perfectly sweet taste. While Matt kept licking and sucking Amanda's clit, I straddled her face and slowly lowered my wet pussy to her mouth. I first felt a timid lick across my clit. I remembered what it was like the first time I ever went down on another woman; I was scared of the taste, the smell, if I would do it right, but I ended up loving it and craved pussy just as much as I craved cock. After a few more timid licks, I felt Amanda put her tongue inside me just like I had done to her. It was so fucking hot knowing this sweet, innocent 18 year-old had her tongue in a pussy for the first time ever, and I was glad it was mine. Amanda got bolder and bolder as she went, licking and sucking my clit and my pussy until I reached the point of no return and I began to feel an orgasm building up in my body. My legs tensed up, I could feel my ass cheeks clenching just as I was about to reach climax, and finally I couldn't hold it back anymore and I exploded, panting and moaning from how incredible Amanda was with her warm pink tongue. As I stayed there catching my breath and feeling soft, gentle little licks from my pussy to my clit, I heard Amanda begin to moan. I moved off her face and positioned myself beside her; I wanted to see what her beautiful face looked like when she came. "That's it, sugar. Cum for Matt," I whispered as I gently tugged on her hard nipples and kissed her shoulder and neck. Within seconds, she was pulling his face into her pussy by his hair, moaning loudly as her body jerked with convulsions. "Holy fuck, oh my God, that's it, that's it," she moaned until she took one last deep breath and held it. When she finally released her breath, her whole body relaxed, her arms and legs spread out around her in an exhausted Raggedy Ann limp position. Matt was grinning when he came up from between her legs, his face wet from her pussy. He moved up beside me and began kissing me so I could taste her on his tongue while she recovered beside us. "Now that you girls have gotten yours, I think it's time that I get mine, don't you?" Three Is Better Pt. 03 (This is the conclusion of Parts 1 & 2, Matt, Scarlett, and Amanda's first sexual experience as a polyamorous triad) Matt stood up beside the bed and motioned to Amanda and I. Immediately, I went over and kneeled on the floor in front of him, and Amanda followed my lead and did the same. When Matt unzipped his jeans and dropped them to the floor along with his boxers, Amanda gasped in surprise. "It's so...BIG!" she exclaimed. Matt's cock was slightly above average in length, about six inches, but the girth was what I found particularly impressive. It was so thick I couldn't get my hands around it, the kind of cock that really stretches a pussy out and gives that incredible full feeling. I couldn't wait for him to put it inside of Amanda so she could feel herself coming apart at the limbs. "Thank you, baby," Matt said as he reached down and stroked her hair. I began to lick the tip of his cock, around the smooth head and down along the edge before trailing my tongue back and forth along the length of it. Soon, Amanda eagerly joined me, licking his thick cock for the first time. I could hear Matt groaning as he looked down at his two girls sharing his cock. I tilted my head down and sucked one of his balls into my mouth, my tongue dancing around it while Amanda took Matt's cock into her mouth completely. I could see her wide-set eyes gazing up at him, and he gazed right back into hers lovingly. He gently placed his hand on the back of her head and began encouraging her to bob her mouth back and forth on his dick while I continue licking and sucking on his warm, full balls. When I finally raised up, mine and Amanda's eyes met and we began to kiss passionately with the tip of his cock in between our tongues. Matt moaned in ecstasy at the feeling of our tongues dancing across his most sensitive spot, so incredibly aroused by seeing us sharing his thick, perfect cock. "Amanda, baby, why don't you get over on the bed on your hands and knees, and Scarlett, I want to see you eat her ass while I fuck you," Matt encouraged. Amanda climbed onto the bed and crawled across to the other side, positioning herself on her knees with her face down close to the bed. I could see that glorious firm, young ass of hers in the air, her pretty pink pussy just dripping wet and I immediately followed behind and got on my hands and knees. I gently traced my tongue from her clit through the pink folds of her pussy (God, did her pussy taste so good) and up to her tight little asshole. Matt and I loved ass play so when I saw how easygoing and open to it Amanda was, I knew she really would be the right fit for us. I buried my face between her round cheeks, tracing circles around her asshole, then licking up and down and left to right across it. I fucking loved eating her ass and I knew Matt's cock would be rock hard watching me. "That's it. You two are my good girls. Amanda, honey, why don't you rub your clit?" Matt suggested and immediately, she reached between her legs and began to rub slowly. As she did that, I felt Matt line up behind me and run the tip of his cock up and down along my pussy to get it wet before he thrust it deeply into me. "Oh, fuck!" I exclaimed before returning to the task at hand: eating my new 18 year-old girlfriend's ass while the boyfriend we shared fucked me. Matt started out slowly, thrusting his perfect cock in and out of my wet pussy while I tongued Amanda's ass. I reached up and slid my middle finger into her pussy – fuck, she was so wet and so tight. I pulled her finger out and sucked the wetness off before leaning back down to lick her pussy and suck on her clit. The three of us continued sucking and fucking, all of us moaning and panting with pleasure. "I think it's Amanda's turn to get fucked, don't you, darling?" Matt asked, slowing his thrusting but still keeping his cock in me. "Amanda, honey, are you on birth control?" "Yes." "And you haven't skipped any days? I would really like to be able to cum in you. Scarlett has an IUD and we'll get you one soon, too." "I haven't skipped any; I have an alarm set so I always remember to take it. I want you to cum in me so bad, Matt. Please cum in me," Amanda pleaded as she turned around to face Matt and I. "Good girl. I'm going to fuck your sweet little pussy and I'm going to fill you up with my cum, baby," Matt replied. I moved on the bed and positioned myself sitting up against the headboard, my legs spread, and patted on the spot between my legs for Amanda. I wanted to look into Matt's eyes while he fucked our teenage girlfriend for the first time. She crawled over and positioned herself between my legs, laying back on my chest with my breasts as a pillow for her. I reached down and began playing with her hard nipples as Matt made his way over between her legs. He positioned himself and using only the wetness from my pussy, he slid his cock into her pussy. "Fuck, you are so tight, just like Scarlett," Matt said as he pushed every inch into her. "You feel so fucking good, Amanda." I began kissing her neck and shoulders, stroking her hair with one hand and pinching her nipple with the other. She was moaning now, grunting with every thrust Matt made into her pussy. I trailed my hand down even further and began to rub her clit. I wanted her to cum so badly, the muscle contractions in her pussy squeezing the cum out of Matt's cock into her. It wasn't long before I heard her breath start to quicken and she began twitching wildly with an orgasm. "That's it, baby, cum for me," I whispered in her ear as Matt groaned loudly in explosion, too. I loved knowing that he was shooting his huge load into her tight little pussy; nothing has ever turned me on quite like my sexy boyfriend filling girls up with cum does. "Fuck, Amanda. That was so fucking good. Now I want you to squeeze and keep my cum in you and straddle Scarlett's face. I want her to eat my cum out of your pussy, baby," Matt ordered. Amanda did as she was told and immediately straddled my face as I moved down to lay flat on my back. As soon as she moved her hand off her pussy, cum came dripping out, drenching my cheeks and falling into my open mouth. Matt had the sweetest cum I had ever tasted and I loved eating it out of the women we fucked. This time, I got to eat it out of our teenage girlfriend. I immediately felt Matt move between my legs and dive in to start eating my pussy; he knew I would cum quickly because eating his ejaculate out of Amanda's pussy would turn me on so much. As I started to feel an orgasm build, I buried my face in Amanda's dripping wet pussy, tasting all of her sweet wetness mixed in with Matt's delicious cum, and in no time I was moaning into her pussy, my face totally soaked with cum as my hips began bucking and shaking with an orgasm. As soon as I started to calm down, I leaned my head back and without even being told, Amanda moved down to straddle me and started licking up the cum off my face. "Well aren't you just a good little girl?" Matt said as he moved up on the bed to lie beside us. Amanda licked up every drop, cleaning my face before she kissed my mouth passionately, passing cum back and forth between our lips and around our tongues. We finally both swallowed what was in our mouths, and she climbed across Matt's body to lie down beside him. He lifted his arms and let the two of us snuggle up close on either side, our heads on his chest. We stayed there smiling at each other as he put his arms around us, stroking both of our backs. "I am one lucky man. I've got the two most beautiful girls in the world," Matt said softly as he played with our hair. Amanda leaned her head back to kiss Matt sweetly, and then he kissed me, too. We all three drifted off to sleep curled up like that, exactly the way we would for a long, long time.