18 comments/  249562 views/  51 favorites

Mixed-Up Revenge Ch. 01

By: Goldeniangel



Ray silently entered the unlocked back door of his ex-girlfriend Karen's house... Karen the bitch who had cheated on him with his best friend - supposed best friend - Ted. Karen who had told him how much she loved him, hinted at possibly getting married one day, and also told him that she wanted to wait till marriage to have sex. At 23 years old it wasn't exactly an easy wait for him, especially because he'd lost his virginity when he was 18 and then met her when he was 19. Although, you'd think that after almost four years that she would be a little more forthcoming, but no. And he'd respected her wishes, all the way up until he'd come over to her house to surprise her and found her riding his friend Ted. Not only was she not a virgin, like she'd told him, but she'd been cheating on him. For quite awhile... and although they had both begged for forgiveness, swearing up and down that they never meant to hurt him, he was filled with anger at her. Not so much at Ted, because as soon as he'd told Ted's girlfriend Chrissy, she'd not only dumped him but she'd kicked him out of their apartment - after cutting up all his clothes. 

Sure it was kinda messed up, and Ted was going to have to pay a fortune to replace his wardrobe, but Ray didn't really care. At least Ted had payed for it. Karen still hadn't paid... all that had happened was that she'd lost Ray, and somehow Ray just didn't feel like that was enough. After all, if she'd really cared about losing him then she wouldn't have cheated on him in the first place.

Silently he went down the hall, dressed completely in black and with his dick already achingly hard at the thought of what he was going to do to his slutty ex-girlfriend. She'd promised him a cherry, and he was going to take one... she might not have the usual one left for him, but there was still one place he was quite sure was virginal. His dick throbbed at the thought. 

At her door he stopped and began stripping - he wanted to be ready and raring to go in case she put up a fight, not hampered by trying to take off his clothes or anything. Quickly he lubed up his dick with the KY he'd brought with him... after all, he wanted her to pay but he didn't really want to damage her. When he thought his dick was slick enough he carefully began to push open the door, peering inside cautiously. There she was... laid out on the bed, face down with her head in the pillow; the moonlight played across her pale skin and he could see that she was completely naked. Her sheet was kicked off of her as she often did in her sleep, pale blonde hair covered her shoulders and she sighed in a dream. 

Grinning, his hand wrapped around his dick, he quietly stepped to the edge of the bed, his eyes locked on that delicious ass and her sweet looking pussy. But her pussy wasn't what he was here for, it had already been violated, she'd given that away when it had been promised to him... and so he was going to take something else. Her little crinkled hole looked tiny compared to his dick, but that didn't stop him at all, in fact it just made him harder. 

Crawling onto the bed he carefully positioned his dick at the entrance of her ass and started to push in; as she began to shriek and thrash on the bed, awakening to the cramping pain in her ass, he pressed her shoulders down, holding her in place. Her ass was exquisite, tight and warm, its walls slick with the lubricant that covered his dick. It rippled as she cramped and clamped down on him, massaging his dick as he began to press deeper, enjoying the feeling of her tight warmth. She was screaming and sobbing into the pillow as he buried himself, her voice muffled - not that he was listening to any of her protests anyway. 

When his groin finally pressed against the smooth curve of her buttocks he leaned forward and allowed his hands to wrap around her body, grabbing her tits and massaging them as he whispered in her ear, "You promised me a cherry, remember Karen? You gave one to Ted, but I think I like this one better anyway... It's a lot tighter than that slutty pussy of yours probably is."

She gave another shriek as he began to move his dick back and forth in her ass, little hard jabs as he tweaked her nipples and tugged on them. Feeling her begin to squirm underneath him as he fucked her, he reached down to her pussy and found - to his utter shock - that she was wet. 

Well, if that wouldn't be the ultimate revenge. Making the bitch cum with his dick up her ass... he stirred his fingers in her juices and she actually moaned and pushed back against him, her ass pressing against his body. Steadily thrusting in and out of her deflowered asshole, he began to toy with her pussy, running his fingers through the wet slit and rubbing her clit. The sounds she was making turned from pained to aroused and then to pleasured as he continued to fuck her and began to slide two of his fingers into her pussy.

He could feel his dick moving in her ass with his fingers, it was very strange and rather erotic, and he wondered how she felt with something in both of her holes. Rubbing her clit harder, he ground against her ass, making a circular motion with his dick and stirring her insides. Karen gasped and pushed back again, pushing herself up onto her forearms as he fucked her. With her ass high in the air she fucked him back, one of his hands gripping a hanging boob and the other knuckle deep in her pussy. 

The room was filled with squelching and moans, her ass gripping him tightly with every thrust... this was the first time that he'd ever fucked a girl in the ass and he thought he might be addicted. It was a completely different sensation than a pussy... ok so it wasn't quite as wet as a pussy would be but it was still tight and slick, and there was something very base about it. He felt like he was doing something he wasn't supposed to be doing - and not just breaking in and taking her without asking - but the fact that he was in what was often considered the "wrong" hole. Fucking her harder, he realized he was going to cum soon and redoubled his efforts on her pussy, pressing against the small rough spot in her hole with his fingers.

When she came, it was completely unexpected for him, and he gasped with ecstatic shock as her ass suddenly began to convulse around him with her climax. It massaged him, gripping and pulling at his dick, as if it was trying to pull him deeper into her hole. Groaning, he managed to thrust one more time, burying himself as deeply as he could, before he began unloading his cum into her ravaged ass.

He straightened up, exhausted and surprised at the way she had responded - not that he wanted to get back together with her. Looking at the firm globes of her ass he regretted that they would never do this again, he liked the way his dick looked lodged in her ass. Panting for breath, she had her head down as his dick slowly shrunk inside her.

Turning to look over her shoulder she said to him, "You know, you could have just asked."

Ray literally fell over, his dick falling from her ass, as he recognized Karen's younger 8 year old - sister Charlotte!

*********************************

Later they would sit in the kitchen, both of them freshly showered and in towels... although he had just seen her naked Ray was still turned on by the sight of her in a towel. There was just something so erotic about a girl who was almost naked, but still covered.

Sipping her hot chocolate the younger girl told him, "You know, I thought that what she did was pretty fucked up... not that what you tried to do wasn't."

Shame-faced, Ray looked down at the marsh mellows floating in his cup, "Charlotte, I'm so sorry... if you want to report me to the police I'll understand."

He looked up, surprised at her sudden laughter. Giggling, she gave him a speculative look, "Ray, if you didn't know that I've had a crush on you since forever then you're totally blind." His jaw dropped and she sighed, "Ok, so boys are totally blind... anyway, I'll definitely be giving Karen my blessings for leaving me here to house-sit for her! The only way I'll be mad at you is if you don't at LEAST take me out on a date after this."

Totally stunned he stared at this gorgeous, sweet, ok so younger, but absolutely wonderful girl who apparently had not only not minded his invasion but had been excited and enthusiastic about it, and told his stunned brain that if he turned down this offer he was a complete and total idiot and should probably be cut out of the gene pool.

"I'd love to take you out!" he said, reaching across the table to grab her hand, "Now that it's legal of course." They grinned at each other, a little goofily. Then Charlotte's smile became a little more sinister.

"Of course, I do still think that my sister deserves a little payback for the way she treated you... can't have her doing that to any guy that's going to be worth dating me." She tossed her hair.

"Of course not," agreed Ray, not sure at all what she was talking about, but perfectly willing to go along with whatever she wanted. What had he been thinking all those years that he'd be dating Karen and not Charlotte? Oh right... that Charlotte had been underage.

Smiling, she leaned forward and his eyes couldn't help but travel down to her cleavage, "I think we can arrange something for when she gets home, don't you?" The towel slipped a little and he could feel his dick stirring, "And I can think of a few things to do in the meantime... can't you?" She got up and started walking towards the stairs, her delicious ass peeking out from underneath the hem of the towel.

As he ran up behind her - his towel fluttering behind him before landing on the floor - and grabbed her, she shrieked with glee as he picked her up and began to carry her up the stairs as they shared their first kiss. 

Mixed-Up Revenge Ch. 02



Ray couldn't believe his good fortune. Not only had he not gotten in trouble for accidently ass-raping his cheating ex-girlfriend's younger sister, but Charlotte was going to help him get back at Karen as well! Plus, he'd taken her out on two dates while her sister was away and he was starting to really like her, and not just because she was a hell of a lot of fun in bed. She was spontaneous, cute, funny, smart, and they were interested in a lot of the same things... she'd even liked the jazz club he'd taken her to! It was a hell of a difference from dating her older sister.

And now she was just as into him getting revenge as he had been before... honestly at this point he could have cared less, because he was content just having her, but she really wanted it to happen. He kinda thought that she might be a little turned on by the idea of him raping her older sister's ass, and that she really wanted to watch. Maybe it was her own payback for past things done to her as well, whatever, he didn't really care - he was just doing it to make her happy. 

Happy she was too, she'd slipped a drug into her sister's drink during dinner and now she was helping him carry Karen up the stairs and tie her face down to the bed... they were going to wait until she woke up before doing anything else though. It would be nearly as much fun with her asleep. Stripping her down they placed her on the bed, a bundle of blankets was placed under her hips to keep her ass in the air... they tied her hands behind her back and her legs to the bed so that she couldn't go anywhere. Ray privately thought that Karen didn't look nearly as good as Charlotte would in this position, and he wondered if she would ever let him tie her up like this. It might be worth it to ask eventually.

While they waited for Karen to wake up she sat on his lap on the bed and they kissed passionately, slowly divulging each other of their clothes. Charlotte had the ability to make him more horny than ever.

"Are you sure you want me to take her ass and not yours?" he asked, panting as her fingernails ran down his back.

"No," she giggled at the expression on his face, "But we've already gone through all this trouble, and I really want to watch."

Ray groaned at the lustful feelings she aroused in him and gripped her ass with his hands, kneading her butt-cheeks with his fingers. Their kisses became deeper and rougher, his dick was rubbing along the inside of her thigh and he longed to just plunge it into her body, forget Karen and fuck his new girlfriend raw. Just as he was about to lose control they were interrupted.

"WHAT THE FUCK IS GOING ON?" They looked over to their side where Karen was now awake and glaring at them, Charlotte straddling Ray as they held each other.

"Oh good, you're awake," said Charlotte.

"WHAT THE HELL!" yelled Karen, "LET ME GO!"

Shaking her head in disappointment, Charlotte got off of Ray's lap as her older sister continued to scream at them and picked up Karen's panties off the floor. Balling them up, she shoved them into Karen's mouth before her sister had realized what she was going to do. Now her yells were muffled by the fabric, and Ray looked admiringly at his girlfriend. 

"Come over here and lemme lube you up honey," cooed Charlotte, picking up the bottle of KY jelly and reaching for him. Eagerly Ray went to his girlfriend's hands, his cock bouncing in front of him. She lathered him up as they watched Karen struggle on the bed... Ray mused that it was a good thing Charlotte was here, he didn't think he'd be all that aroused by Karen. 

But when he did get behind her, watching her jiggling buttocks, he found that he did want to part them, split them open... all his old vindictive feelings came rushing back as he watched her struggle.

"Decided to cheat on me with my best friend huh?" he snarled, pressing his dick into her ass as she shrieked and started struggling even more, Charlotte coming around to hold her sister in place and watch as he violated her ass, "Tell me that you want to wait for marriage and then you go fuck around with someone else." He jabbed a few inches deeper and Charlotte smiled as Karen's eyes popped. Looking around she opened the night stand drawer and pulled out her sister's vibrator, turning it on she pressed it underneath Karen and against her clit. If Karen came, while Ray raped her ass, it would just be too perfect.

Karen's body jerked as it was assaulted with pain and pleasure, the dick in her ass burning and make her bowels cramp as it invaded her, and the vibrator against her clit buzzing inharmoniously with the discomfort in her backside. Rubbing the vibrator against her clit, Charlotte smiled as she watched her boyfriend's dick bury itself in her sister's asshole, the formally crinkled hole looked stretched and whitish around the invading member. She wondered if her own looked like that when he took her... or maybe it would look different now that she was no longer an anal virgin. A giggle rose in her throat at that thought... not nearly virginal anywhere now!

Ray found that Karen's ass was just as tight as her sister's, although perhaps not as enjoyable - she certainly wasn't as enthusiastic as Charlotte was (or as she had been the first time), but the revenge factor made it plenty exciting for him. He pillaged her ass, fucking her hard and taking his own pleasure in it, leaving Karen's orgasm up to Charlotte to engineer. A vibrator would probably do a better job than he would anyway. When her hips began moving involuntarily against the vibrator - and consequently against his thrusts - he grinned and began fucking her even harder, gripping her hips as he set a bruising pace.

Although Karen was doing her best not to humiliate herself, the pumping of a dick in her ass actually was starting to feel kind of good. The burning pain had stopped and now it was a slick movement that left her feeling full and shivery; combined with the ever-intensifying vibration on her clit she was actually starting to build towards an orgasm. Wriggling, she tried to fight it, but her movements just ended up moving her closer to climax rather than further. 

As he moved within her, her ass started ripple around him as she writhed, and he could hear the change in her moans. Charlotte was watching her sister with an odd expression on her face - envy, lust, arousal... it made his balls tighten to see her watching them. Gritting his teeth he thrust hard into Karen, pushing himself as deeply as he could go each time before letting out a bellow with his final pump as his back arched slightly and he came, spurting cum into her bowels. Charlotte turned up the vibrator to its highest intensity and pressed it hard against Karen's clit as she realized Ray was cumming; feeling his dick pulse in her ass and the pressure of the vibrator sent her soaring and she began cumming as his orgasm finished. 

Breathing hard, he leaned on Karen's backside as her body shook and she finished out her climax, his dick slowly shrinking inside her hole. 

Charlotte removed the vibrator from her sister's pussy as he pulled his dick from her ass and they kissed happily. Making a face, he said, "I'd better go wash myself off, I'll be right back." She ended up going with him to wash off the vibrator as well.

Coming back into the room they looked at the sweaty girl on the bed; she was struggling again, trying to get loose. 

"You know," said Ray slowly, "There's still one person in this room who isn't satisfied... I don't think that's quite right."

"You offering to do something about it?" Charlotte smiled and wrapped her arms around his neck as he gave her a strange smile.

"Not me..." his gaze drifted over to the struggling figure on the bed as his hands stroked the small of her back, "Someone else..."

Surprised, a little unsure of what to think, Charlotte looked at her sister's jiggling backside.



Mixed-Up Revenge Ch. 03



Charlotte looked at Ray, "Are you suggesting what I think you're suggesting."

He grinned at her, "Well, I've always wanted to see two girls go at it, and you seem to be angry at her for something... besides, I know you're turned on right now. I think that it would be a good finishing punishment."

Looking back at her sister, Charlotte considered... it really would be a good final revenge. Years of having to deal with Karen lording over her rushed through her mind... along with all the times Karen had blamed things on her, all the guys that Charlotte had liked that Karen had gotten to first... the way that Karen had treated Ray - even if it had ended well for Charlotte. Not to mention the burning ache in her pussy from watching Ray take her sister's ass cherry... sure she wanted his hard dick in her, but that wouldn't be nearly as deliciously naughty...

"I can give her a spanking while she eats you out," continued Ray wickedly, watching the expression on her face carefully. He added, "Of course we don't have to if you don't want to."

Something inside Charlotte snapped into position and she grinned up at him, kissing him hard, "You dirty man... I'll do it. You better enjoy the show though."

"Oh I will," he grinned, "Besides, there's just something so much more taboo and erotic about it when it's your sister... heh, you're right, I'm definitely a dirty man. Think I need professional help?"

"Maybe, but get it later," she told him, giggling and tossed her hair flirtatiously as they moved towards the bed, where Karen seemed to sense their approach and stopped struggling. With their arms around each other they stood where she could see them.

"You're going to do one last thing for us," Ray told her, and he turned his face towards Charlotte as he stroked her hair, "You're going to eat out my new girlfriend here..." Karen's eyes got very wide and her struggles renewed, "And I'm going to be spanking you to make sure you're doing a good job. That means that the spanking will stop when she cums." Both of them grinned at her horrified face as Charlotte got onto the bed in front of her and spread her legs, scooting forward so that her wet pussy was right in front of Karen's gagged mouth. Screeching, the older sister tried to turn her head from side to side, anything to get away from that spread pink pussy. 

"Ready?" asked Charlotte, looking up at Ray with a mischievous grin, her eyes alight with anticipation and excitement. Grinning he slammed his hand down on Karen's ass as Charlotte pulled the gag from her sister's mouth and pressed her pussy to it. Karen's shriek vibrated her pussy lips, but there was no tongue follow-up. So she told Ray, "Hit her harder, the shrieking feels nice but she's not even trying."

As Ray's hand crashed down on Karen's backside again she began licking at her sister's pussy, ignoring her revulsion in favor of reducing the pain. It was slick and musky, but didn't taste too bad as long as she didn't think too hard about the fact that the pussy belonged to her younger sister. Charlotte moaned as her sister's tongue began sliding and licking along her heated slit, frantically swiping up her juices. Seeing the expression of satisfaction on Charlotte's face Ray reduced the brutality of his spankings; realizing that the better she pleasured her sister, the less her ass would hurt, Karen started sucking and licking like a fiend. 

Doing everything that she herself liked, she sucked on her sister's pussy lips, nibbling them gently and sliding her tongue up and down the wet slit, trying to press a stiffened tongue into the hole. Moaning, Charlotte humped her pussy up and down on her sister's face, coating her lips in juices as her hands wound in the blonde hair. The spankings lowered down to a light sting as Karen ate out Charlotte, licking frantically and teasing her sister's clit with her tongue. 

She made little figure-8's with her tongue, licked until the organ cramped and then sucked and nibbled until she could lick again. Eating frantically her ass wiggled as she tried to escape the slaps; they weren't particularly hard anymore but the more that he hit her the more her ass hurt anyway, and she certainly didn't want them to go back to being hard and painful. So she licked, nibbled, and found herself actually starting to get into eating her sister out. There was something very sexy about being so vulnerable, and even though the girl in front of her was her sister, she couldn't deny that she had always wondered what it would be like to be with another woman. 

Laying back, Charlotte kept one hand in her sister's hair and began playing with her tit with the other. Continuing to spank Karen's ass, Ray could feel himself getting harder as he watched this erotic display of lesbian incest, as he watched his girlfriend completely succumb to lust under her sister's tongue. Charlotte was writhing in heat as her sister found her clit with her mouth, nuzzling it with her lips before sucking it between them and rolling it between her teeth. Karen was eating her out better than any guy ever had, even Ray, she seemed to know all the exact right spots and pressures to use on her, spreading pleasure throughout her entire body. Moaning lustily, Charlotte shuddered and her back arched as Karen bit down, nibbling gently. 

Shrieking with rapture, Charlotte came hard, her juices flowing into Karen's mouth and she swallowed her sister's juices automatically. Ray watched as his girlfriend writhed, her face flushed with passion as her hands pulled her sister's face deeper into her pussy. She sighed as her orgasm completed, her expression dreamy as she looked up at him over her sister's body. 

Karen sagged, completely exhausted and her mind overwhelmed by everything that had just happened. 

The couple untied her hands and legs and left her there, dressing quickly and running out to the car.

"That was hot," Ray told her as they drove down the road. 

"I can tell," Charlotte giggled as she caressed the bulge in his pants with his hand, "You better hurry so that we can get back to your place and take care of this."