You pause to think about your choices. After a minute or two, you make your decision. "Hmm... I don't wanna wait, so I guess I'll go ahead and take your ass first." You say as you playfully grab Cream's ass, causing her to blush with embarrassment.
"Okay. You want it, you got it." Cream says, turning around so that she could slide your cock inside her asshole easier, using the cum from before as lube. Despite taking a couple tries, you eventually get your manhood inside her ass, sliding it in slowly to minimize her pain. "Ooooooh... Oh fuck... Deeper... Ohhhh yes..." She moans, slowly taking your dick to the hilt. Once there, you stop and savor the sensation of her tight, virgin ass gripping your manhood. After a bit you begin to slowly bounce her on your dick, waiting for her ass to stretch some so that you can start thrusting faster.
"Crikey! I didn't think Cream would let him root her in the clacker!" Marine shouted from off to the side, turning her attention from Blaze for a minute. Eventually, Cream's asshole stretched enough to allow you to begin thrusting quicker and harder.
"Oooooh... Yes... Ah... It hurts, but at the same time it feels amazing... Oh God... Please... Fuck me faster... Oh... As fast as you can..." Cream moans as she begins to bounce on your manhood quicker than before, loving the sensation of your cock inside her ass. Shortly after doing what she said, you can feel yourself approaching the edge once again.

Where are you going to cum?
Shoot it up Cream's ass.
Cum in Cream's mouth.
Spray it on Cream's back.
Cum in Marine's mouth
Cum in Blaze's mouth.