[My Little Brony] Black Heart Romance
[RELOADED Edition]
by @silvergunner

It was a warm day in Ponyville and once again the day of the Apple Family Reunion. From all over Equestria, members of the Apple family had descended on Sweet Apple Acres to celebrate being one huge family. However unlike previous reunions, members were allowed to bring guests who weren’t strictly part of the family, which explained why there were many more ponies there than ever before. Out of the new guests was no other but the latest addition to the extended Apple family - Speedy the young blue earth pony.

It couldn’t be doubted that Speedy was the most popular young stallion in Ponyville at the time, and a target of affection amongst all the mares there. He had gone from a shy loner who spent all his time by himself to a dude that was comfortable in social situations and was friends with a lot of people, despite past problems with his classmates. His friendship with the Cutie Mark Crusaders had helped a lot to bring him out of his shell, not to mention various encounters with some of the grown up mares around Ponyville.

Now today he was invited to the latest Apple Family Reunion, mostly because his current girlfriend was Apple Bloom herself - his previous girlfriend Applejack’s younger sister - and also because he had encounters with Granny Smith, and Big McIntosh in the past. Not just encounters of a casual friendly kind either, but ones of a much more sensual nature. However with Apple Bloom’s permission and due to his unofficial status as an Apple family member, he had insisted on inviting an additional guest - his twin brother Axl.

Axl was totally unlike Speedy. He had yet to come out of his shell, and his heart was full of greed and self-indulgence. His eyes glimmered malevolently, hiding behind a polite exterior a world of darkness inside his soul. He and Speedy were twins, created when Nightmare Moon’s parthenogenic son shattered into two separate young stallions, one good and bad. Both shared the same sky blue body and white hair, but while Speedy’s was spiky and short, Axl’s was greasy and lengthy. Their childhoods had being different as well - while Speedy had being found as an orphan and raised by Twilight Sparkle in Ponyville as a scholar, Axl had being raised by Zecora in the forest as an alchemist.

Having grown up seperately, Speedy and Axl had only reconciled a few months before and were still learning to get on with each other. However after a few mishaps the two were now close enough to consider each other brothers, and Speedy wanted his twin brother to come out of his shell and become a good young stallion just like he was. That included bringing him to social events and parties with Speedy’s other friends. Which wasn’t anything near what Axl wanted to do.

Today was no different than other social events. Axl was there for less than half an hour before he began feeling uncomfortable. Everyone seemed to be talking over him, and there was a constant crush for the snack table, with all the older ponies stuffing themselves with different desserts involving apples of some sort, and downing gallons of cider. Even worse, he felt completely out of place as far as who he felt he was. He hated social events. He hated being a goody-goody young stallion. He hated pretending to be somepony he wasn’t.

At this point, Axl had experienced enough. He wanted out of this event right now, but he knew if left now Speedy would go ballistic at him later on, accusing him of not trying and ruining things and everything. So he made a plan to sneak away from the party - he would say he was heading off for a bathroom break for a few minutes, but not actually come back until the reunion was over.

Putting his plan into action, he went over to his brother. “Hey Speedy, I need to take time out. I’ve had too much cider and I need to pee” he stated.

“Sure thing, Axl” Speedy replied, surprised at how blunt his brother was. He turned away as Axl trotted into the bushes nearby, assuming he would do his business there. He knew that the nearest toilet was half a mile away, and out in the countryside relieving yourself outside wasn’t frowned upon as much as it was in Ponyville.

As he went to hide behind the bushes he thought about what he could do for several hours. Maybe he’d sneak off somewhere, although there wasn’t anything interesting for miles around. He could take a nap, but he might lose track of time. He was completely stuck for what he could do to pass the time. He just wished he had a real friend. One who accepted him for who he was. One who didn’t want him to be good all the time...

Suddenly he heard a whistling come from beside him. “Ah, finally someone comes to join me” came a feminine voice. He turned to see a brown coloured young mare with red hair and freckles, wearing a wicked grin. “And bugger me if it isn’t Speedy’s double” she added.

Axl gazed at the young mare, and remembered what Speedy had said about the mares in Ponyville. Both the good ones and the bad ones, and the one in front of him wasn’t exactly high on his brother’s approved list... “You’re Babs Seed, right?” he asked.

“You got that right” Babs nodded. “So who are you? I know you’re not Speedy as that stuck-up young stallion wouldn’t come within six feet of me” she growled.

“I’m Axl...” the young stallion replied, a bit nervously. “Speedy and Applebloom have talked a lot about you...” he added.

“Yeah, no doubt bad things. Like i’m a bad girl and all” Babs shrugged. “But who cares if i’m bad? Judging by your experience today, pretending to be a good young stallion doesn’t get you any snacks. Being a bad one on the other hand does though...” she added. She then stepped aside to show off a stack of bottles of alcoholic apple cider she had obviously stolen from the refreshment table. “Like to share?” she asked.

“Sure thing” Axl smiled. Despite what Speedy had said, Babs seemed to like him at least. After all, she was the first to offer to share her stash of drinks with him...

Babs passed him a bottle and, after opening it, he took a swig of the delicious liquid inside. As he did, all regret and remorse left his mind. He didn’t care about what the others thought about him any more. He was being a bad young stallion, and he liked it. Plus, he felt an attraction growing towards the young mare in front of him. One that made him feel fine about avoiding a social event and instead hanging in the bushes drinking stolen booze. One who he felt had convinced him to take the road to darkness yet again.

“Hey Babs, do you have a boyfriend right now?” he asked, lustful thoughts beginning to flow through his mind. He wasn’t sure if it was the alcohol talking or him being honest for the first time in a while, but he knew either way in his heart it was his true feelings coming out. 

“Hardly. Nobody can take how bad I am” Babs grinned. “Thats why I wanted a really bad boy to come into the bushes with me and do stuff we shouldn’t” she grinned, holding up a bottle of cider she had almost completely emptied in three minutes flat. “How about it Axl? You have an itty bitty little crush on me?” she asked him, teasingly.

“If I hadn’t, I wouldn’t have asked if you had a boyfriend already” Axl grinned back at her. He had never felt such confidence before, and was unsure how he had gained it suddenly...

“Well just as well, as i’ve being wanting a good boyfriend for a while, one that doesn’t suck at everything” Babs grinned in response. “I think Speedy has the energy I crave, but he’s too goody-two-shoes for my tastes. I wanted a badder version of him, and you’re by far just perfect for that open position” Babs added, opening up another bottle of cider for herself. “Not to mention even if I had a boyfriend, i’d do this to you anyway” she started, in a seductive tone.

Before Axl could say anything else, she walked up to him and kissed him on the cheek. It was Axl’s first kiss, and it felt amazing to him. “You know Axl, you don’t have to hang with your brother and the Cutie Mark Fakers. We could do this every day of the week if you’d like, away from the interference of everyone else in Ponyville” she offered. “We could just skip school and drink and kiss in the bushes, and maybe even go further than that if I had my way” she giggled, winking at him.

“Do you mean...” Axl started.

“Yes, I mean sex. I want to be fucked by a horny stallion. I want you to fuck me Axl, and I want you to do it now” Babs said, draining her third bottle and chucking it away.

“Oh i’d be more than happy to, you bad girl you” Axl grinned. After chucking his now empty second bottle to one side, he walked up and kissed Babs back, this time on the cheek.

As he kissed her passionately, Babs moved a hoof underneath Axl’s body and felt between his legs. He let out a gasp of surprise as Babs grabbed at his sheath, and felt his penis rising slightly from it. “Well you’ve got a little horny but you’re still too soft. Disappointing” Babs scolded. “However, I know a way to change that...” she commented in a seductive tone.

Babs lowered herself down and gazed at Axl’s penis. She began rubbing her hoof against it smoothly. Axl was a bit surprised, as he had only ever touched his member himself before now, but decided to let Babs continue. The young mare then kissed the tip of his member and the feeling that shot through his system was unlike any he had felt before. He felt himself begin to get hard slowly as Babs continued to rub his member. Suddenly he felt a wet sensation on his dick, and on looking below himself he saw that Babs was now licking away at his shaft happily.

Suddenly Babs opened her mouth wide and took his member into it. As she softly sucked the young stallion off, he felt incredible sensations flow through his body. He had never felt anything like this before, and he was loving every moment of it. As more and more sparks of pleasure flowed through him as Babs continued to give him oral sex, he started letting out quiet moans, feeling an orgasm beginning to brew inside him that was way more intense than any he had experienced while just masturbating by himself...

Babs withdrew her mouth from Axl’s member just before Axl could climax. “Not yet, babe” she said to him, before taking his member in her hooves. “Eighteen inches... pretty good for a young stallion, considering many grown up stallions i’ve seen are shorter” she grinned. She then turned around and pushed her rear up in the air, moving her tail to the side to reveal her rear entrance and below it her pretty pink pony pussy. “No doubt its your first time, so i’ll let you off if it doesn’t go to plan” she said to him.

“So i’m guessing its not your first time?” he queried of her. “How much sex have you being getting exactly, Babs?” he asked in addition.

“Not enough for my tastes” Babs grinned. “I’m supposed to be in school and be a good little girl, but I hate doing that and i’ve already taken a few dicks in my time while skiving” she commented. “Not that I care. After all, we both just met and are doing sexual stuff already, but I don’t care about that or the fact that either of us are or aren’t virgins. Do you?” she asked.

“All I care about now is you and how much I want to fuck you” Axl grinned. He knew that other young stallions his age were iffy about fucking mares who were not virgins and losing their virginities were a matter of status, but for him none of that mattered. He was in love with Babs, and was eager for her to be his first ever sexual partner.

“In that case quit chatting and fuck me hard, you big bad boy you” Babs replied. She then laid on the ground face-up with her legs spread, her pussy wet with anticipation of Axl entering her.

Axl didn’t need to be told twice. He got close to Babs until he was on top of her, before putting both his hooves on her shoulders. He adjusted his hips until the tip of his erection was pushing against her vaginal opening. After taking a deep breath, he pushed into her tight young pussy, the first few inches of his stallion cock sliding in steadily.

Both him and Babs let out a gasp of surprise. Axl couldn’t believe how tight Babs’ pussy was, and how great it felt for his member to be inside it. Driven by natural instinct and by what he had seen in various magazines he had sneaked into his bedroom, Axl began shoving his hips backwards and forwards slowly. It felt incredible sliding his cock in and out of Babs’ tight cunt, even better than the blowjob she had just given him. He began to hear Babs moaning below him as he continued to thrust in and out of her, several more inches of his cock sliding into her.

Babs was enjoying the experience as well. Axl was way bigger than she’d imagined, and her pussy was struggling to accommodate his member. Just how she liked it in fact, as she figured she was growing up to be quite the size queen. With every thrust Axl made she let out a moan as sparks of pleasure began to fill her. Several minutes passed as they fucked, with both of them getting close to their first orgasm of the afternoon. However just before Babs could climax, she heard a loud moan from her partner on top of her.

Axl felt the greatest orgasm of his life erupt inside him. His virginity now lost, he moaned as pleasure surged through him, and his cock sprayed his seed deep into the mare he loved. Babs was a bit annoyed that he came before she did, but was willing to let him off as he seemed to have the technique worked out right...

As Axl slid downwards onto her in tiredness from his epic orgasm, Babs pulled herself off him slowly, his cock coming free of her pussy with a small pop and his cum drooling out of her stretched entrance. “Not bad for a first go Axl, but i’m nowhere near satisfied yet” she said to him. She then stood up after a few minutes and in front of Axl’s face, pulled her buttcheeks apart to reveal her rear entrance to him. “How about trying my butt? Because if you don’t, i’m going to leave you here all alone and unsatisfied” she demanded of him, grinning wickedly.

Axl jumped to his feet in response. He wasn’t intimidated by Babs’ outburst, but instead the lust inside him was burning to a point where he couldn’t wait to have more sex with her. One of his and his brother Speedy’s special abilities was to recover their libido pretty quickly, and as he rubbed his cock - slippery from a mixture of their cum on it - he felt it grow to full size again. “Are you ready to go, bad girl?” he asked her, and she nodded. After moving his hips around to position the head of his cock against her rear entrance, he took a deep breath and plunged his dick into her backside.

Babs moaned in happiness as she felt Axl’s member penetrate her tight butt. She had only used solid objects such as her older sister’s vibrators to probe her rear entrance before now, and the feeling of having a hot, slick cock inside it felt strange but amazing. As she felt Axl begin to thrust in and out of her, she felt her insides stretch like never before, and pleasurable sensations began to fill her even faster than when Axl’s massive cock had being stuffed deep into her vagina.

Axl himself couldn’t believe the sensations he was feeling from fucking Babs’ backside. It was extremely tight around his cock and it was tricky to move despite the lubrication on his member, but he continued to thrust in and out of her nevertheless. With every stroke he made he realised why Speedy preferred backdoor action with both mares and stallions.

Minutes passed as they fucked, with Babs getting closer and closer to orgasm. Eventually she could take no more and screamed in happiness as her long-awaited orgasm finally hit her. She moaned as pleasure flowed through her and her cunt dripped her fluids over the ground. Her rear tightened around Axl’s cock, and he barely lasted a few more thrusts before his own orgasm hit. Pleasure surged through him as his cock unloaded a second load into his crush’s butt.

After he had fully unloaded his balls for the second time inside Babs, he pulled out of the young mare and kissed her while she laid on the ground moaning in her afterglow. “Guess I did a better job this time?” he asked, grinning.

“Best... Buttfuck... Ever” Babs breathed. Axl pulled out another bottle of cider and laid next to Babs as he downed it. As he pulled her close to him, Babs turned to him and kissed him on the muzzle again. “You’d better be as good as that in future, or i’ll make you suffer” she said faux-malevolently towards him.

“For my fave bad girl? Absolutely” Axl replied. “Besides, I know you won’t make me suffer, as you won’t get to fuck me again if you do” he added, teasingly.

“I’m liking you more every moment, Axl” Babs grinned. “You’re the bad boy with the big cock i’ve wanted for a while now” she added. She then got to her feet and stared at the four empty cider bottles scattered around them. “All that drink hasn’t just gone to my head, its also gone elsewhere” she said. Axl watched as she stood and all fours and turned towards him. She then got an empty bottle, placed it between her legs, and began pissing into it. “Cider is nice to drink but its also nice to expel” she giggled.

Axl picked up a bottle himself. “No doubt we can do this to pretend we didn’t drink the bottles?” he asked.

“Not to mention give some of those stuck up ponies a bit of a shock” Babs giggled.

“Just as well I need to go too” Axl grinned. He held the open bottle against the tip of his cock and began pissing inside the bottle. When the bottle was full he grabbed a second and filled that up as well. With two full bottles he let his stream waver with the last few spurts splashing against Babs’ legs.

Babs, who had just filled up a second bottle as well, turned around to face him while still pissing. “You into that sort of thing, eh?” she asked. Before Axl could answer, she had turned around and raised her leg so that she soaked Axl’s own legs with her warm urine. Axl liked the feeling of it but couldn’t respond as his own bladder was empty. Only a few drops escaped Babs before she was done too. “Next time i’ll make you taste my piss, bad boy” she giggled at him.

“Just you try to make me. You’ll be drinking mine first” Axl replied with a wicked grin. Both of the ponies giggled before taking the bottles and putting the stoppers back on top of them. After agreeing that Axl would cause a distraction and Babs would switch the bottles, they walked back to the party and prepared themselves to sneakily switch the bottles.

Axl decided the best distraction was to become the centre of attention. He went up to Speedy and tapped on his shoulder. “Hey Speedy, isn’t it true you planned to propose to Applebloom?” he asked.

As the whole Apple family turned to Speedy with inquisitive looks, Babs placed the replacement bottles back on the table. As she did she heard Speedy try to avoid the question before admitting he planned to in the near future, but not now.

A few minutes later when Speedy had finished his explanation, Axl joined Babs in the bushes again and they watched the snack table carefully. When Braeburn went up and took a swig from a bottle he instantly spat the liquid out of his mouth in shock at the flavour. Axl and Babs laughed uncontrollably from behind the bushes when they saw that happen. It was a brilliant prank, and the first of many to come in Axl’s point of view.

As the party ended, Axl and Babs kissed each other while lying in the bushes. “Thank you for today Babs” Axl replied. “You’ve made me feel happier than i’ve ever been” he added.

“Because I showed you how fun it is to be bad?” she asked.

Axl thought for a moment and realised it was being bad that made him happy. Not because it gave him a sense of power or superiority, but because he was being who he was, and not pretending to be someone else he wasn’t just to please others. “Absolutely” he replied to Babs. “You made me rediscover who I really am, and I loved every minute of our time together again” he added.

“Well if you liked sex with me that much, I expect to see you more very soon, bad boy” she replied. “Whenever you get horny, come find me and you can fuck me as hard as you want” she winked. The two kissed again then went their separate ways.

On the way back to Ponyville, Axl caught up with Speedy. “Did you enjoy the party?” Speedy asked him. Axl nodded, but didn’t explain just how he enjoyed it. He knew Speedy would go nuts if he found out what he had done and who he had done it with. He knew Speedy and Babs Seed were still on bad terms, and if Speedy knew they were hanging out things would go wrong.

But he didn’t have to know. Being bad was a risky thing, but way more fun for Axl than having to pretend to be someone he wasn’t. Axl smiled as he walked home with the others. He felt something he had never before - freedom. He felt he was the person he wanted to be without the restrictions of other people forcing their opinions on him. And the mare he loved was behind him all the way in his descent to the darker side of love.

- The End -
