Amy tapped her foot as she waited outside of Sonic's house. The blue hedgehog had missed their date again and she wasn't having any of it this time. The ‘'hero' was lucky she loved him so much. More than once had she accidentally walked in on Knux in the shower or caught Tails working both his shafts at once at his work desks. Everytime she had, she managed to resist their advances despite their measurable equipment, believing Sonic had to be even bigger than the both of them. Still, she was getting sick of it. If he kept pushing her buttons like this there would be hell to pay, maybe she’d take one of them up on their offer. She was sure that would show him. She glared as she finally saw him coming up the path, with what looked like a blue tanooki in baggy black sweat pants following him. She couldn't believe it, he blew her off to hang out with some guy, one she never even saw before? That was the last straw, and the pink hedgehog marched up to the pair. From the look on Sonic's face, he realized what he did wrong.

	“Oh, hi Amy.” She could see him sweat as she glared at him, ignoring his new friend for now. “Listen, I know I missed our date, but I have a perfectly good explanation.” The glare continued as Amy waited, impatiently tapping her foot, letting Sonic sweat it out. “See, I was on my way to meet up with you when I found Vince here. The thing is, well... ya see.”

The tanooki cut in there, “Our mom spread her legs for both of our dads, not just his.” he grinned cheekily as Sonic blushed, and Amy found herself a little surprised by his bluntness. 

Still, she didn’t miss a beat before she scoffed. “So you ditched me to hang out with a guy? Really Sonic?” At that she heard her boyfriend's half brother give out a laugh.

“She’s got you there, man.” he put an arm around her, the tanooki pulling her close to him, “You never mentioned you girlfriend was this cute, Sonic. Gotta admit I’m a little jealous.” the tanooki guy grinned wide at her. At first, Amy was ready to slap him, but a light bulb went off in her head as she smirked at Sonic.

“Well. At least someone here appreciates me.” as she slid into the embrace she could see Sonic’s heart sink. “Poor guy.” she thought to herself, “But he shouldn’t have stood me up again.” It was the fifth time this month and Amy was sick of it. She knew the hedgehog was the jealous type, and quickly decided snuggling up to his newly found brother was the perfect punishment for the blue rodent, at least until the two had some time alone. 

	Finally Sonic cut in, “L-look, why don’t we all just go inside. I’ll order pizza and we’ll get to know each other better over a movie or something?” 

Sounds fun.” Vince grinned at Amy, “What do you think, Ame?”

She resisted the urge to fume at the pair. Sonic for deciding to keep this guy around instead of spending some time with her and Vince for being so willing to ruin her chances. Still, snuggling up to a cute tanooki to make her equally cute boyfriend jealous could be fun, maybe he’d finally be pushed to ‘claim what’s his’ that night if she did. “Yeah, fine. Whatever Sonic.” She resisted the urge to glare at the hedgehog before turning her attention to his brother, the pair walking inside arm in arm “So, what is it you do, Vince?”

	Amy was surprised at how fun the night had been talking and laughing with her boyfriend’s brother as he stared on in jealousy. The man apparently worked at his father’s store, learning how to be a trader. A surprisingly prestigious career move for someone she’d thought of as crude when they first met. She was beginning to think maybe having him as a brother in-law in the future wouldn’t actually be so bad.

	Sonic meanwhile was relegated to looking on in jealousy from an armchair while the two shared a couch, Amy's Plan working as the blue hedgehog was visibly annoyed with the setup, and the more obvious it was he was stewing over it the further Amy pushed. Finally, he decided to press the issue, “Hey Amy, why don’t you come sit with me for a while? Give Vince a break.”

	She giggled in response, “Sonic, that’d be rude to leave your brother sitting alone like that. Besides, where would I sit, on your lap?”

Vince then grinned, “Besides, I don’t mind her by me. Heck, she can sit on my lap if she wants.” Amy gave him a playful punch to the arm before looking at the fuming Sonic.

“Oh come on Sonic, he’s just having fun. No need to get into a dick measuring contest over this, I’m all yours right?” She gave the headhog a sultry smile, and by the looks of it it relieved some tension.

Vince however, cut that relief off, “Well, why not make it a dick measuring contest, winner gets a BJ from this cutie?”

Amy and Sonic both stared in shock at that suggestion, then it took root in Amy’s mind. On one hand she’d never seen Sonic’s dick. This was the perfect opportunity if she took it. Sonic’s brother or no, he had to have Vince beat in that department. On the other what if he didn’t? What if somehow this tanooki had an inch or two on her beloved Sonic, could she stand losing her first time to him? Finally, Amy made her decision, she took a deep breath before saying, “You know what? Sure. Let’s do that. But the winner has to go all the way with me.” She smirked at Sonic who looked like he was panicking. Ins contrast however, his pink lover was  exuding confidence even as butterflies danced in her stomach.

	“Amy, you can’t be serious!” Sonic yelled at her, eyes wide as he stared at his grinning brother. “You know I, I mean you can’t just-” he stuttered out before being cut off by the agitated pink hedgehog.

“Sonic, I’ve put up with this for years. You won’t admit we’re dating in public, we’ve never had sex, hell, I’ve seen Knuckles and Tails’ dicks by accident more than yours. If this is what it takes to get laid by my boyfriend for a change, then I’m taking it.” Amy had to admit, she was being harsher than she meant to be, but this was the last straw. Now with anger clouding her  mind, she no longer even cared if Sonic won, she was losing her virginity tonight.

	Vince meanwhile raised a brow, “Sonic, you’ve had this cutie to yourself and never touched her? Seriously? I mean, I’d be showing her off constantly.”

“I know!” Amy yelled, any hint of calm now gone, “I’ve never even seen his dick.” It was her turn to fume now, Sonic simply blushed sinking into his chair with any fight in him gone. Regardless, Amy stood up from the couch and pointed at where she’d been sitting, “Now you’re going to sit there and accept the bet, or we’re declaring him the winner by default. What’s it going to be, Sonic?”

The blue hedgehog sighed, unable to protest anymore. He stood up and sat beside his brother, knowing and dreading what was to come. The rage now leaving Amy, she collected herself. She knew she’d have to touch the other man to get the two out and compared, but it didn’t matter. She’d finally have Sonic. Or at least she thought, as  was Vince smiling at her, “Way to take charge, Ame. Mind helping me get these off though?” She hesitated for a moment, but complied. After all he was helping her get Sonic in the sack, the least she could do was get his pants off. As she did however she began to fear she had made a mistake. The tanooki had a very obvious sheath underneath, the girth of which rivaled Knuckle’s cock, and dangling below it was two massive orbs. She blushed as she reached out instinctively, massaging them as she stared.

“These can’t be real.” Sure enough though, the fleshy balls were warm to the touch, Amy’s attention thoroughly focused on Vince. As she played with the tanooki’s testes however, a bigger change was occurring. A large shaft was beginning to grow out of it’s hiding place, inch by inch Vince’s rod was revealing itself to the pair. Before long the monstrous cock was six inches and still growing. 

“A-Amy?” Sonic managed to stutter out as he watched as his girlfriend began to jerk off his brother.

“One second, Sonic. It’s only fair I get him as hard as I can first, right?” She wiped a bit of drool from her lips with her free hand. Even with her being a virgin, a variety of dildos and vibrators had left her a size queen, and as it reached past ten inches, she found it hard to keep her mouth off of it.

“It’s not that, I just… I kind of lost already…”

Amy’s eyes went wide at that and she turned to Sonic. Her heart sank when she saw just what she’d be holding out for. Between the hedgehog’s legs wasn’t a monster that would ruin her, one that’d leave her the envy of other women, there was a barely there blue twig matched by two tiny balls. At best he was three inches, and that was being generous. If Sonic took her there and now after all those years of masturbation with bigger and bigger toys, ones she only chose because she thought Sonic would be better hung than a porn star, she’d never even feel it.

	Something snapped in Amy at that point and within an instant her mouth was around Vince’s still hardening shaft as she put all the skills she had practiced on her toys to work. Sonic looked on in shock as his girlfriend deep throated his newly found brother, “Amy! Stop, what the hell are you doing!?”

She removed her mouth from the marvelous shaft with a wet pop, Sonic could see it was about five times the size of his by now, “Fulfilling my side of the bet Sonic, what does it look like?” She smirked at him.

“But, but you’re my-” He was stuttering, unsure of what to make of any of this.

“Sonic, the vibrator I lost my virginity to was the smallest one I could find, and it was bigger than you.” Amy smirked as Sonic went speechless, nearly in tears thanks to his brother laughing and his girlfriend wrapping her lips around his gigantic cock. 

“Amy, stop!” Her only response was to flip the blue hedgehog off as she made sure his superior brother enjoyed the sounds of her gagging on his length. New paths were opening up for her as she choked herself with the massive tool. She knew she’d be taking Tails and Knuckles up on their offers after this, spreading her legs for them any time they wanted from now on. 

	Then she felt it, Sonic trying to take some control of the situation back as his tiny cock rubbed against her slick folds. She pulled off of Vince as quickly as she could and shoved Sonic away, making him fall into his arm chair. She turned to him, glaring, “No, you didn’t want it before, you’re not getting it now.” She couldn’t help but grin at her new power over her boyfriend, “You sit there and jerk it while a real man shows you how it’s done.” Sonic looked down meekly, wrapping one hand about his pathetic shaft to obey her. Amy’s dominant streak ended abruptly however when Vince pulled her back, making her straddle over his massive cock. Now fully at the ready, it dwarfed her biggest by at least several inches, making her cunt drool over the head that was poised to finally take her.

	She grinned and Sonic watched wide eye’d as Amy positioned herself on his brother, his thick head splitting her folds apart. She shuddered at that and stopped moving once the entirety of the the bulbous tip was inside of her, her hands moving to ensure Vince had a hold on her hips. All while facing Sonic and smirking. In gratitude for that, the tanooki pulled Amy downward without warning, filling her with his warm cock as a reward. Her world went white when he did and Sonic couldn’t help but focus on how she looked. Her eyes nearly rolled back into her head and her tongue was lolling out, a perfect slut for huge cocks and a look Sonic would never see on her without this kind of help.

	Her hips were soon bouncing, first with Vince’s help, then on their own as she rode Sonic’s brother. Amy knew her first time would feel amazing, but she never thought this would be how it would happen, Sonic stroking his micro-dick while a real man filled her up. Still, she was loving it, and the moans her boyfriend was hearing from her proved it. She looked Sonic in the eye once more and grinned evilly, “He’s ruining me for you, ya know.” She managed to get out between labored breaths,  “You could stop us now and stop me from masturbating for a year or two. Maybe then I’d feel that pathetic little thing.”

	Sonic gritted his teeth and went to stand up, until the next words out of her mouth stopped him, “But I don’t want you to.” That floored him all over again, “Even if you did I’d just be fucking Knuckles and Tails behind your back. Have you seen their cocks?” The last of the wind was out of Sonic’s sails now as he slumped into his chair, dejectedly. Tears formed at the edges of his eyes as he stared at his tiny dick and wrapped what fingers he could around it. This was the best he’d be able to get, and he knew it. So might as well enjoy the sight of Amy getting fucked. His brother’s balls slapping against her and his shaft spreading her wide, making her call out a name other than Sonic’s. It wasn’t long until he shot out a pathetic amount of cum, getting a laugh from Vince, “Wow, that little? Let a real man show you how it’s down.” Suddenly, Amy found herself pushed forward onto the floor and pinned under the tanuki. Their fucking became more violent and harsh, the sounds of wet slapping and moans filling Sonic’s home. Minutes passed before Vince finally groaned, emptying his massive sack into Amy. By then her eye had rolled into her skull, her tongue lolled from her mouth and she could barely even focus on raising her ass in the air to give the man behind her better access. Her belly bulged with his seed as he unloaded into the pink slut before finally pulling out, covering her ass and tail with the last rope of his orgasm. Sonic sat stunned watching this, before her finally heard Amy’s weak voice say, “R-round two… please hurry…”