Donnie's Third Night
As Donnie wept outside, begging for whatever this creature was to stop, the guys enjoyed the show. Although April became more worried as the minutes rolled by. She knew that there wasn't any internet, but Don had to give up eventually. None of the turtles, or Casey seemed worried, but then again Donnie did this a lot in the sewer.  She heaved out a sigh. April decided that she should at least check up on him. She didn't like it when he didn't eat much. She got off the couch and went to the counter were Donnie put his pizza. Before she could grab it she heard the door open and then close. She turned to see Donnie with his mask hanging from his neck, his eyes were red and he looked in pain. This worried April even more.
"Donnie, are you ok?" April asked as she walked up to him.
"No, I- I, I just want to be left alone for a while." He said going upstairs without saying another word. She turned to the others who had the same worried and curious expressions. Except for Casey.
"Somethings not right." Leo pointed out.
"Dudes, maybe he sad 'cause he couldn't get internet. I KNEW IT! It all makes sense." Mikey said trying to help. Raph hit him on the back of the head.
"It does not Mikey! Didn't you see his face, he looked hurt. Something happened to him out there." Raph said.
"C'mon man, he's probably just moping' around cause he can't get anything to work." Casey said. April glared at him.
"I'll try and talk to him." April said walking up the stairs.
"I hope April finds out something. This isn't normal for him." Leo said having a worried big brother moment.
"Me too." Raph said also having one.
_______________________________________
April walked down the hall to the room Donnie used. She came up to the door and tried to listen if she could hear anything. The only thing that was heard was a few sniffs here and there. She knocked on the door but got no reply.
"Donnie. It's me April. Can I come in?" She asked. She waited for him to reply.
"I would prefer if you didn't." Donnie called back out to her. April opened the door. He was laying on his shell. His head was turned away from the door, his right leg was bent and both arms were resting at his sides. April closed the door behind her and walked up to Donnie's bed.
"Donnie? Are you ok?" She asked him again, placing a hand on his arm. He flinched from the touch. He turned his head to face her and slowly tried to sit up.
"I..I-I don't know April." He said. He held in a breath, trying to prevent himself from screaming when his tail grazed against the rough part of his shell. This didn't go unnoticed by April. She already knew about the turtles's tails. But it was still a weird subject for them to talk about.
"Donnie what happened to you out there?" April asked sitting next to her best friend. She could see the pain and fear in his eyes. It brought tears to her eyes but she couldn't cry, not now. She had to be there for him.
"I don't want to talk about it." Donnie says looking away from her. She felt hurt that he didn't trust her enough to tell her what happened, but there have been a lot of things that he's kept from her. Like the picture in his lab of him pushing her on the swing set.
"Donnie, you can tell me anything, and I promise that I will do anything I can to help." She said. He turned his head back to her. She watched as a tear fell from his eye. She had never seen him cry before, and she never thought she would. Then again she never thought Mikey would get shot in the tail by a Kraang blaster and that would be how she finds out about their tails. He took a deep breath and let it out slowly.
"I umm...... there's something out in the forest. I..." Donnie was having a hard time trying to describe what happened to him without using the 'R' word.
"Donnie, just say it, I swear I wont laugh or anything." She promised him. He took a few seconds to find the right words to says.
"Something out there ra.... attacked me. That's why you and Mikey found me outside. And thats why I'm in the situation I'm in now.' Donnie confessed. April was able to easily find out when he meant. She felt terrible for Donnie. She scooted closer to him and wrapped him in a hug. He hugged her back, feeling safe in her embrace. As she wrapped her arms around his neck she tried to think of the next set of words to say. 
"Do you want me to tell the guys?" She asked. She felt him tense up and he quickly pulled away.
"NO! Raph will make fun of me the first chance he gets!" He said.
"I will not!" He heard a voice say from the other side of the door. Donnie all of a sudden felt unsafe. The door opened to reveal Leo and Raph.
"You guys were eavesdropping!" April said raising her voice.
"Look April we're sorry but you're not the only one worried about Donnie." Leo said. He turned his head to face his younger brother. Why did you lie to me?" Leo asked him.
"You think it's easy blurting out that you got raped by some creature out in the woods while you were unprotected and not only that in the middle of the night!" Donnie called out. And for the first time, Raph didn't have a smart remark to say.
"Donnie how do you expect us to help you if you don't tell us anything?" Leo asks as he stepped into the room. Donnie brought his legs up and wrapped his arms around his knees pads.
"I don't know Leo.......I thought it would leave me alone after the first time." Donnie said burying his face into his arms.
"Don't worry Donnie, we're gonna get rid of this thing." Raph said. Without lifting his face from his arms he said
"How? Once you're in its grip there's now way you're slipping out till it's finished." Donnie said, his voice lower and muffled but could still hear clearly.
"Because we're going to kill this thing before it hurts anyone else." Leo said. Donnie didn't say or do anything. April placed a hand on his shoulder. "But were going to need your help so we know where to look." Leo said. Donnie lifted his head up to look at his oldest brother.
"What if it attacks me again?" Donnie said as a few more tears fell from his eyes. He was scared, and everyone here knew it. But they needed him to pull through if he wanted this to stop.
"We're not going to let that happen. We'll protect you. And that's a promise." Leo said as he stared into his hurt and scared brother's eyes.
"Ok." He said. He let go of his legs and slowly got out of bed. He stood up next to Leo who led him out of the room.
They made it downstairs to the living room. On their way down April asked if the would need her help but they said it would be safer if she stayed in the farm house.
"Were going to be out for a while. April make sure Mikey and Casey get to sleep on time." Leo said as Mikey watched the Crognard marathon. They came up to the door, walked outside, then shut the door behind them. Donnie instantly started having flashbacks from the first time.
"So where did it happen this time Donnie?" Raph asked. He looked at the barn and flash backs from about 25 minutes ago flooded his mind.
"Umm, by the- by the barn. Just about two feet in front of the doors." He said. And thats where they went. Leo was in front, Raph followed behind him, constantly looking back at Donnie, who was walking very slow freaking out over every noise he heard thinking it was the creature. Leo looked around the boundaries of the forest and Raph went around the barn, while Donnie stood in front of the doors of the barn listening for any strange sounds. He tensed up when he heard it. He didn't say anything, thinking it was his mind playing tricks on him.
Donatello took a few steps forward. He stopped walking but used his keen vision to search the boundaries of the forest and grass. He heard it getting closer, but much like last time he didn't see it. He took slow deep breaths trying stay as silent as possible to listen for it. He turned around to Leo to see if he had any luck, I could just be hearing leaves running across the grass. But that theory was shot down. His body tensed up and went completely still. He felt something slimy skid across his tail. He whimpered as it tried to find a way inside while more slowly wrapped around his ankles.
"Leo." He said to scared to yell. Leo turned around.
"Donnie!" He yelled out. Raph came around the other side of the barn and saw Donnie standing in complete fear while pink tentacles wrapped around his legs and wrists. Leo through a shuriken and one of the tentacles causing it to quickly unwrap Donnie's leg, giving him the chance to kick the other one off while he yanked his wrists away and running towards his brothers before the other tentacle entered his tail. Raph got to Don's left as Leo got to his right. Donnie started taking fast short breaths,  not even trying to control his breathing anymore as he heard it.
"Don't worry Donnie, we got ya." Leo said. Donnie turned his head around to see nothing but darkness and the barn. But this creature had tricks up it sleeves. At first Don thought it left but then the next second theres a tentacle wrapped around the strap on his chest.
"GUYS!" He screamed as he was pulled forward. 
"Donnie!" His brothers screamed out. As the thing had hold of his strap, Donnie was quickly working on undoing his belt. Once he was finished he slipped out of his staff's holder and leaped away. Leo crouched next to Donnie as he caught his breath while Raph ran up to the creature, his sais pointing to the tentacles. Raphael managed to stab two tentacles. But more came out. They wrapped around Raph's arms and threw him into a tree, knocking him out.
"RAPH!" Donnie and Leo cried out. They looked back to the barn. But what they saw was unexpected. The saw a monster that looked like the Creep. But instead of plant like vines it had pink tentacles on its back and it was all black with purple eyes. Donnie started freaking out as he saw the thing that raped him with his own eyes. How could I have not seen this thing? It's HUGE! Donnie screamed at himself. It shrunk down into the ground, the tentacles the only thing visible. Ok, thats how, he said.
"Donnie get behind me." Leo ordered. He didn't have to tell him twice. He quickly got to his feet and watched from his brother's point of view. Donnie stood behind his brother. The tentacles lowered into the grass, making them almost impossible to see as they dashed away from the dim light the barn preserved. Donnie got scared as the thing disappeared.
"Donnie just stay in my sight. I won't let this thing hurt you." Leo said as he looked over Don's shoulder. After Leo said that, a ghostly voiced filled his mind.
You can't protect him
He is mine
I claimed him
Leo didn't understand what the voice meant. He started losing focus when the voice got louder and wouldn't stop. He lost so much focus that he didn't even see or feel the tentacle wrap around his neck until it was too late.
"Leo!" Donnie cried out. Leo opened his eyes, not sure when the closed and saw Donnie on the ground trying to crawl to him while being pulled away from him. The tentacle around his neck cut off his air, causing him to black out. 
Donnie whimpered as he watched Leo slip into unconsciousness. Donnie laid on his plastron as he stared at his sleeping brother. The tentacle wrapped around his neck. Donnie looked up as the tentacle slowly came towards him. He was trapped now. Raph and Leo are unconscious, and Donnie was surrounded by the 'arms' of this creature. Tears stung Donnie's eyes as he was forced to go through this a third time. 
The tentacle wrapped around his shell, pinning him to the ground, unable to move. Donnie started freaking out because this was new. But this made no sense to Don. If this thing wanted to drink from him, wouldn't he need to be on his back? But Donnie still had a chance. His arms were free. He tried to lift himself up, almost getting free until something slammed onto Donnie’s shell pinning him back down. He looked up to see the owned of the tentacles. In its right hand it held his belt. Donnie stared up at it in complete horror. From the sight and from the fact that he could feel the tentacles graze over his tail and entrance. The new version of the Creep grabbed his arms and tied them with his belt. He tried struggling against its grip but this was an awkward position for him. He felt something grip onto his side, rolling him onto his back. His shell pressed against his bonded hands.
He watched as the creature sunk back into the ground, leaving nothing but the pink tentacles visible. He kicked his legs at one of the tentacles but it only made the situation worse as it wrapped around his leg. Another one wrapped around his other leg. The tips of the tentacles wiggled over his entrance and slipped in. He curled his tail around it, doing whatever the tiny tail could do to pull it out. He felt the tentacle that was wrapped around his left leg wrap around his tail and slip in. Bother tentacles thrusted into him, equally fast and hard, and gradually going in faster and harder. He flung his head back as the thing struck his prostate. He couldn't help but let out a churr, even though pain from his tail still coursed through him. He felt another tentacle start running against the slit in his plastron. Not wanting to cause more pain to himself, he reluctantly dropped down. He felt the slimy appendage wrap around him, licking at the pre-cum oozing from him. With the thrust that had already started before he dropped down he managed to quickly climax, getting round one over with. He felt the tip of the tentacle go into his cock, sucking in the cum that shot out. He tried shifting to cause less pain on his hands, the creature thinking he was making an escape dug the tentacle in his tail quick and deep into it. Tears fell from Donnie's closed eyes as the pain shot through him.
"Get away from him!" He heard someone scream. He felt all the tentacles all at once leave him causing him to sigh with relief. He brought himself into his plastron where it belonged. He opened his eyes to see Raph standing over a dead body, taking deep breaths. Raph looked do one of his youngest brothers. He ran over to him and helped him sit up.
"You ok Don?" Raph asked as he untied his hands. Once his hands were untied Donnie brought his hand to his tail that hurt severely. He thought blood dripped from it. Donnie sat with both legs bent in a 'V' shape, his right hand on his tail and his left supporting him.
"I am now. Thanks Raph." Donnie said as he looked to his 'hero'. He felt a hand on his shoulder and saw Leo crouched next to him.
"I'm........I'm sorry I broke my promise. I didn't know how tough this thing was until it was too late." Leo said feeling really bad about not protecting his brother like he promised him.
"It's ok Leo. Now that it's dead I think I'll be ok now. Though I would prefer to be in my room for a little bit." Donnie said as he looked into his eldest brother's eyes, his hand leaving his tail. 
"Take all the time you need Donnie." Leo said as he patted his shoulder. Raph helped Donnie to his feet. Leo started walking to the farm house, Raph close behind while Donnie stood staring on the monster.
"Donnie, ya comin'?" Raph asked. Don turned to his brother.
"Yeah, I'll be right there. I just need to get my staff." He said. Donnie crouched down to pick up his belt. After that he stood up again to search for his weapon. He saw it next to the creature's dead body. He walked over to it and picked up his favorite weapon. He stood still as he tried putting on his belt again. He heard a snake slither behind him as he adjusted the strap over his shoulder. He placed his staff in its holder and turned around, only to see a moving tentacle right in his face.
"No." He whimpered out.